10 ms·
Why I’m making my family German (2017)
- vidoc 4y agoThe EU version of the culture war :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Tomte 4y agohttps://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_gg/englisch_gg.html#p0729 https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_gg/englisch_gg.h... (2) Former German citizens who, between 30 January 1933 and 8 May 1945, were deprived of their citizenship on political, racial or religious grounds and their descendants shall, on application, have their citizenship restored. They shall be deemed never to have been deprived of their citizenship if they have established their domicile in Germany after 8 May 1945 and have not expressed a contrary intention.
- mslate 4y agoThis article understates the context of this “right of return”—-that the German state in the 1940s systematically murdered over 6 million Jews. Today’s Germans are not guilty of this crime, but it is an oddly missing fact from this article—-especially in the context of fleeing Brexit. I say this as someone who has exercised my right of return to Austria.
- denkmoon 4y agoYou don't always need to elaborate... Do you think there are many germans exercising their right of return that aren't aware of the holocaust?
- harvey9 4y agoThe audience for the article is mostly not comprised of Germans exercising their right of return, so adding context would benefit the majority of readers.
- krageon 4y agoAre there many countries where this is not part of the curriculum? I've genuinely never met anyone that wasn't taught this in school.
- nelblu 4y agoHolocaust was not taught to me growing up in India. It is quite shameful, I learnt about it watching movie (life is beautiful).
- snowpid 4y agoYou dont have to be feel guilty about it. I can understand that non - Western countries dont teach Western (or German) history. In Germany we didnt talk about India as part of the British empire. My scarce knowledge is based on talks with an Indian friend and Wikipedia. Also there are many many genocides unfortunately.
- goodpoint 4y ago> non - Western countries dont teach Western (or German) history In general they do because history is human history, not just some country's history, and it would pretty appalling to gloss over genocides of that magnitude.
- vinay427 4y agoHonestly, I find both of these anecdotes a little mind-boggling, although it may also be a function of my attending school relatively recently. The vast majority of history lessons in my secondary/high school (IB curriculum) were about overseas regions, including comparative studies of single-party states in the "West" and the "East," colonialism, etc.
- yorwba 4y agoIB meaning International Baccalaureate? That might explain a more international outlook. The average German history curriculum tends to cover topics with a German-specific lens. E.g. comparison of single-party regimes will likely involve the NSDAP and SED, colonialism may feature British India in a sidebar but mostly talk about German colonies in Africa, the Berlin Conference, Herero genocide etc. (German New Guinea and the other Pacific colonies seem to get less attention for some reason.)
- thepangolino 4y ago[dead]
- fguerraz 4y agoLet's not forget 10 millions Soviets. https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/documenting-numbers-of-victims-of-the-holocaust-and-nazi-persecution https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/documentin...
- mslate 4y agoYou’re right, let’s not.
- jokethrowaway 4y ago[flagged]
- fmajid 4y agoIt's not a toy passport. The right to live and work in the EU is pretty valuable for Britons who have lost it due to Brexit. Russian oligarchs pay millions each for Malta's golden passport wheeze, and Roman Abramovich suborned a corrupt Portuguese Rabbi to be declared eligible for reinstatement of Portuguese citizenship for the descendants of Jews expelled in 1492, thus making an end-run around EU sanctions imposed on him.
- hef19898 4y agoThat Abramovich plan is genious! And yes, EU passports are very beneficial. And the German one ranks usually under the top three most "powerful" passpoets in world, measured in the number of countries one can travel to without visa requirements. A second EU passport would be somewhat of a "toy" so, but might still make certain things easier in said country.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoSure, I just meant to denigrate the institution of needing a passport to travel, not how useful is a particular European passport. It feels like we're not that far from middle age.
- opportune 4y agoThis is like the holocaust equivalent of trying to explain someone else’s joke. It’s not understated, everybody else got it. If I had to point out what’s understated or lost by many, the author is not comparing this to the holocaust (obviously Brexit is nowhere on the same level). They’re drawing comparison to one of the central narratives of the Jewish Diaspora where Jews periodically have to relocate to get away from declining or unfavorable regimes. But they also recognize that since they were secular and seemingly fully assimilated as a Brit, it’s a little different (which is also a common facet of the Diaspora especially in secular Western countries)
- tobinfricke 4y agoMore recently (August 2021), the option of German citizenship has been extended to descendants of people who were deprived German citizenship due to gender discrimination in the law that was in effect at the time. For example, until 1975, the children of married parents would only be German if the father was German. Furthermore, if your ancestors left Germany after 1904 and had children in the United States before naturalizing as American citizens, you may be already a German citizen even without knowing it. A reddit dedicated to these topics and more: https://www.reddit.com/r/GermanCitizenship https://www.reddit.com/r/GermanCitizenship
- opportune 4y agoCan you explain the part about being a citizen if you have ancestors after 1904? What other criteria are there? From some quick searching I don’t see this mentioned explicitly anywhere. Is the argument that your great grandparent’s (immigrant from Germany in let’s say 1901) children, per the current naturalization rules, were a citizen, and thus your grandparent, thus parent, and thus you? Since the citizenship requirements don’t mention it, is this something that would actually hold up?
- techsupporter 4y ago> being a citizen if you have ancestors after 1904? Prior to a 1914 change in the nationality law, a German citizen lost citizenship if they lived outside of Germany for more than 10 years and didn't file to retain citizenship. The general case is thus "after 1904." Other common criteria are that the chain of citizenship is unbroken, that no parent naturalized elsewhere (also a loss of citizenship without permission to retain) prior to the child being born and no voluntary military service (with some exceptions for EU and NATO depending on year).
- opportune 4y agoI see, that explains why I kept seeing 1914 when researching. I just thought OP might have made a typo in the year I knew one of my great grandparents was born in Germany, but after some digging it turns out they emigrated as a toddler well before the cutoff, so no EU passport for me. I was surprised to learn that their family came over in multiple ships in the span of a few years. And also at how many dark patterns genealogy websites use to try to get you to pay! Pro tip for anybody also interested: there are free sites for genealogy although their SEO is often poor, and they use clunky interfaces from like 15 years ago. Often operated by governments and perfectly capable of describing in words how to manually do a join, but incapable of automatically doing a join. I found aad.archives.gov useful for Ellis Island records - if you search the manifest id from a record you can see the ship name, source, and year. And you can filter by last name + manifest id if you find what seems like partial data (the person you think is missing may have had their name recorded differently). There is some German emigration data also available but as you might expect it’s pretty patchy - nonetheless I was still able to find my great grandparent in their polity’s emigrant records.
- vr46 4y agoSince this article was published, it is no longer straightforward to have dual-nationality between Germany and a non-EU country - the UK in this context. They're considering it, but right now, you would need to give up your passport in order to gain a German one.
- Semaphor 4y agoThat would still be the same, this is the "right of return" rules which is one of the exceptions to our "no dual citizenship" rules. What’s supposed to be changed soon is the normal way, like my South African wife who could get citizenship due to being married to me. Currently, she’d have to give up her SA citizenship to get the German one.
- hef19898 4y agoIn those cases, if SA doesn't care, is to renounce the SA citizenship in front of German authorities and just get a new SA passport later. A lot of people with German and Turkish passports (also technically not allowed) do so. Trick is to not carry both at the same time. Or to apply for security clearances. Edit: There are countries in which you cannot loose citizenship, Afghanistan comes to mind as of a couple of years ago.
- brmgb 4y agoYes, it's mostly fine doing that. The German law is incredibly stupid in the context of international law anyway. The issue is that citizenship is stricly a country own prerogative outside of the agreement not to make people stateless. So Germany is free to tell you they won't give you the German nationality if you don't renounce your other ones and is free to strip you of your German nationality if they find you have another one. Meanwhile, the other country can still consider you a citizen if it wants to. That's its sovereign right and it doesn't have to agree to you asking not to be considered one.
- Semaphor 4y agoI think we’ll be fine just waiting ;) And also, SA is also a bit weird about dual citizenship, you have to ask for permission first before getting another, and can’t even start the process of getting another before getting permission, which takes about a year. And apparently they almost never deny permission… Yet if you get another without asking them, you instantly lose your SA one.
- throwaway09432 4y agoAs pointed out below, she still lives in London after all this verbiage. https://twitter.com/intent/user?screen_name=byameliahill https://twitter.com/intent/user?screen_name=byameliahill Edit - Censored [flagged] because we are apparently not allowed to criticise. Pathetic.
- Tomte 4y agoShe never claimed to have moved to Germany. Or to plan it. She wants the option open, especially for her children.
- throwaway09432 4y agoReading it back you are indeed correct. I found the article misleading.
- netsharc 4y agoHa, cute, a snippy comment from a throwaway who admits it when s/he gets it wrong. Could it be that your presumptions about the author ("attention-seeking") is what misled you?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway09432 4y ago>"attention seeking" Oh I stand by that comment. It is my opinion, did it offend you? I'm curious why you even felt the need to comment. Not every Briton has the power to do what she did. So the article is essentially just about her. She told all her friends what she was doing beforehand. Now what type of behaviour would you describe this as?
- lispm 4y agoThough she writes: "I find myself imaging what it would be like if my husband and I retire to Germany."
- roenxi 4y agoThis article appears to have been written by a senior reporter for the Guardian in a case of journalists-reporting-on-journalists. Somehow, that seems like it should be an interesting factor although it is a struggle to pick out why that is. Also if I were in Europe, I would be looking at contingency plans that involved alternative continents. The combined actions of the US and Russia have probably turned Ukraine into the next Afghanistan. I'm not sure what the implications of that will be for the rest of the EU, but that level of destruction, the rearmament of Poland and the concerning energy situation overall (the last decade more than the last year) are inauspicious.
- jstx1 4y agoThe main impact to most people living in Europe has been the higher cost of living which is also the case in the just about any alternative continent/country you can think of.
- krageon 4y agoSouth America is not more expensive and there isn't really anything there for anyone. Except for the US meddling in politics, but that's hard to escape.
- scared333 4y agoLet's just say it the way it is: russia is attacking Ukraine, a free nation. Russia is committing atrocities and war crimes against Ukranian people. When russia stops fighting and leaves Ukraine, the war ends. That is all there is to it.
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoWell, yeah but they have nuclear weapons so that limits the amount the West can do to help. For a comparison of what happens when a country does this and doesn't have nuclear weapons - see the First Gulf War. It seems the energy situation has gone better than expected so far, but if the war drags on it could be hard to sustain that. I don't think anyone disagrees with you that the Russians are the bad guys here.
- erulabs 4y ago[flagged]
- makerofthings 4y agoOur European citizenship, something many of us were proud of, was taken away against our will after a misleading campaign and a badly run referendum full of lies. Brexit has turned out incredibly badly. I understand why this was sickening, I felt that too.
- erulabs 4y agoI hate to knee jerk but this feels very much like US politics: “they lied to everyone but I’m smart enough to see through it”. Do you, even for a moment, believe the other side even has a point at all? You must realize the opposition says the exact same thing: “they lied but I’m smart enough to see through it!” If there is a clear argument for or against Brexit, then it’s not “sickening”. To paint it as such ignores legitimate arguments and as such makes me question the journalistic integrity.
- jmopp 4y agoThe other side may have had a point if Nigel Farage didn't immediately backpedal on the "Let's give 350m a month to the NHS instead of the EU" talking point after the referendum.
- dmitriid 4y agoYou can't overstate how immediately he backpedaled. He reneged on the promise in a morning show the very next day after the referendum.
- ben_w 4y agoThe closer I look at politics, the more I think democracy is driven by emotion rather than rationale. I'm somewhat perplexed that 3 years after the UK's actual departure and 6.5 since the vote, with 3 Prime Ministers being defenestrated in shame in a row (I don't count Cameron for that but YMMV) — May for 95% disapproval of her Brexit plan, Johnson for being pathologically dishonest and reckless, and Truss once they realised they'd mistaken the wood scraped off the bottom of the barrel for "leadership qualities" — that there's anyone who thinks that specific party has "a point". (One can of course say that Lab is also bad, especially as they've yet to win despite all that, it doesn't matter) It's also noteworthy that Farage, who complained of too many people coming into the country during the referendum (the "Breaking Point" posters), is now upset about people leaving the country and the possibility of a brain drain).
- jp0d 4y agoIn a way it feels like the writer despises the UK and thinks that the NHS will implode. Not saying that it can't happen but so can the German economy or any other nation for that matter. The UK gave her family shelter when the fatherland was busy murdering millions of Jews. I think it's important not to forget history, especially one's family's.
- n4r9 4y agoI really didn't get this feeling. The feeling I got is that the writer's British identity is intertwined with their European identity, and no longer feels whole after the referendum. A lot of people feel similarly.
- brigandish 4y ago> In a way it feels like the writer despises the UK It's the Guardian, that is their schtick. Orwell summed up this attitude well in England Your England[1]: > In intention, at any rate, the English intelligentsia are Europeanized. They take their cookery from Paris and their opinions from Moscow. In the general patriotism of the country they form a sort of island of dissident thought. England is perhaps the only great country whose intellectuals are ashamed of their own nationality. In left-wing circles it is always felt that there is something slightly disgraceful in being an Englishman and that it is a duty to snigger at every English institution, from horse racing to suet puddings. It is a strange fact, but it is unquestionably true that almost any English intellectual would feel more ashamed of standing to attention during ‘God save the King’ than of stealing from a poor box. Plus ça change. [1] https://orwell.ru/library/essays/lion/english/e_eye https://orwell.ru/library/essays/lion/english/e_eye
- brigandish 4y agoAs someone who's bought and read the Graun more times in the past quarter of a century than most people have had hot dinners, I feel vindicated by those downvotes, they feel a lot like the response most Graun readers would give. What kind of response do you think the people Orwell described would give?
- Mashimo 4y ago
- knbknb 4y ago"> I find myself imaging what it would be like if my husband and I retire to Germany." I think in case she has dual citizenship, she still has to pay into German social security. These payments are mandatory and contributions are accrued over a lifetime. I think The minimum fee is about 150 Euros per month and family (even as an "inactive" citizen). Maybe she can refuse to pay ("Hey, I've moved back to the UK / never moved to Germany"), but this also means almost? no pension payments later, and she can expect trouble when paying invoices for any German doctor or hospital. Of course she can live off her wealth (gained in the UK) as a Pensioner in Germany but I think when she never contributed to German Social Security she cannot expect much. In this respect, Bookkeeping by German authorities is very accurate, over decades, to the penny.
- peterpost2 4y agoThis is less of a problem for UK citizens, since the statepension is pretty bad. Most people Here pit money in a pensionfund, e.g for me my pension is about 90% from my pension fund and the state part is just an extra(not that I expect i will ever receive it).
- RektBoy 4y ago> and she can expect trouble when paying invoices for any German doctor or hospital. What? Your social security is linked to your health insurance, how? Doesn't make sense.
- hef19898 4y agoIt is not directly linked. Both are linked to employment (sozialversicherungspflichtig, what atrue German word) which gives you health insurance, social security, unemployment and retirement. Lower salary ranges give you health insurance, but sometimes not unemployment or social security (not sure about the latter without looking it up), while freelancing or being a GM at a company (your own or someone elses) can come without retirement or unemoloyment benefits. Except some extreme edge cases, there is no way to be not health insured in Germany. There are multiple ways to not have unemployment, social security or retirement benefits. The prudent path here is to either contribute voluntarily (expensive with the exception of unemployment) or pick privtar alternatives. None of that so is connected to citizenship so.
- lkramer 4y agoI'm a little bit in the opposite camp. I live in the UK and have lived here for a total of more than 10 years in the last 20, but I have a EU passport. I would not say that I feel that I'm British, but I have strong ties with the country and plan to keep it my home for a good chunk of my future (though not my whole future necessarily). I believe I qualify for British Citizenship, and I'm currently debating with myself whether to apply. It's kinda a no-brainer from a practical point of view - it will allow me to come and go as I please, but even though I would not lose my EU citizenship in the process, it has prompted some feelings in my where I have come to consider where I belong and what exactly I feel. I think Citizenship is, whether you like it or not, one of those things that are really important for one's self understanding. Like the author, I feel European first and foremost I think, and Brexit and the way it was carried was cataclysmic for that identity if you live in that country.
- hef19898 4y agoIn case you don't loose your EU citizenship, I think it is really a no-brainer to have both. It's different for, e.g. a Spanish and a French passport as the benefits might marginal. In case of the UK and Brexit, the benefits are really tengible.
- lkramer 4y agoAbsolutely, and I think that's what I'll end up doing.
- prennert 4y agoProblem is: if your first passport is German, you are at high risk of losing it and you have to essentially decide which way to go. Germany only allows dual citizenship with EU countries (at time of application).
- lkramer 4y agoyeah, I'm lucky. My passport is Danish and Denmark have allowed full dual citizenship since 2015.
- Havoc 4y agoI'm trying to do the opposite. Unfortunately you lose the German one if applying for another country's. Unless its a EU country. Guess which country is no longer in the EU... There is apparently a way around it but that may require lawyers
- prennert 4y agoWould be interesting to hear what that way is. From memory they only allow it if you are being discriminated against (voting is explicitly excluded), but maybe I missed something. Right now the UK seems to have left all the doors open for indefinite-leave-to-remainers, including public servant positions.
- Havoc 4y agoThere is a process to apply to retain the german one on acquiring a foreign one. ("Beibehaltungsgenehmigung") The tricky bit is you need to motivate it & they're looking for something a bit more substantial than "it'll make airports easier".
- maxehmookau 4y agoYeah, my wife applied for and got Irish citizenship after the Brexit referendum on account of having Irish grandparents. She now retains the right to freely work and travel in the EU, whilst I have now lost that right. Our children will automatically get it though, so thanks Ireland!
- ashconnor 4y agoYou gain these rights via your wife under EU family mobility law. Your children won’t automatically gain these rights unless they are born on the island of Ireland. It’s important at to register their births on the FBR.
- johnwalkr 4y agoJust for the benefit of others reading: you can get on the FBR[1] if a grandparent was born on the island of Ireland. If you get on the FBR before your kids are born, they can get on it too, and their kids can get on it and so on. If you have a right to citizenship through a grandparent and you don't get on the FBR before your kids are born, they cannot get on it. [1]FBR = Foreign Births Registry. If you have a right to citizenship, you become a citizen once you are in the registry.
- Symbiote 4y agoIf you accompany her, you gain most of the key rights based on her rights. (You lose them if she leaves the country, or the relationship ends, unless you can maintain the rights based on one or more of the children.) Example: https://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-GB/You-want-to-apply/Residence-as-a-Nordic-citizen-or-EU-or-EEA-citizen/EU-Family-member-EU-citizen https://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-GB/You-want-to-apply/Residence-...
- ThePowerOfFuet 4y ago> (You lose them if she leaves the country, or the relationship ends, unless you can maintain the rights based on one or more of the children.) This is incorrect. Refer to Articles 12 and 13 of Directive 2004/38/EC: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A32004L0038 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A...
- Archelaos 4y agoThere is currently a legislation underway to reform German citizenship law, the details of which are still somewhat open. Among other things, it should make dual citizenship much easier for British or US-American citizens and many others. Some historical background: In 2002, the then coalition of Social Democrates (SPD) and the Green Party, at the special insistence of the latter, attempted to pass a new immigration law. The law passed the parliament (Bundestag), but also required the approval of the German states represented by the Bundesrat. At the meeting of 22 March 2002, the state of Brandenburg, which had 4 (deciding) votes, voted in such a way that it was unclear whether the criterion that a state's votes must be cast uniformly was met.[1] The German Constitutional Court ruled on 18. December 2002 that the votes were not cast uniformly (two judges opposed that decision) and none of it should be counted as a Yes, thus the law did not pass.[2] In subsequent years, all attempts to generally[3] ease dual citizenship were blocked by the Conservatives (CDU/CSU). However, the 26 September 2021 elections have resulted in a colation without the Conservatives at the federal level and the situation in the states is so diverse that chances are high that a law that extents dual citizenship might be passed this time. [1] For the relevant passages of the voting protocol see: https://www.bundesrat.de/SharedDocs/pm/2002/062-2002.html https://www.bundesrat.de/SharedDocs/pm/2002/062-2002.html (in German) [2] For the ruling see: https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2002/bvg02-113.html https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/SharedDocs/Pressemit... (in German) [3] There have been reforms that made dual citizenship easier for citizens of EU countries and Switzerland, though.
- ur-whale 4y ago> as I put the finishing touches to sheaves of paperwork That's just the beginning. As much as I like German culture, their insatiable hunger for paperwork is borderline inhuman.
- jamisteven 4y agoDid I miss it or does she has zero actual points or real reasons for wanting this citizenship?
- drewm1980 4y agoThe author feels dual citizenship gave her options. Another option is to be a permanent expat without seeking local citizenship. An upside to that is that you may still be able to leave the country if it goes to war and locks in its own citizens (like what happened to Ukrainian men when Ukraine was invaded). And if your country of citizenship tries to lock down its citizens, you're already not there and you would probably have to commit a serious crime to be extradited.
- halicarnassus 4y agoMost people can only enter foreign countries if they get a time-limited visa. And sometimes you cannot get another visa without being out of the country for a longer time.
- llasse 4y agoThe debates about citizenship and the inherent feelings that they provoke are an outstanding example of how artificial and unintuituve the concepts of nations and borders are.
- ibejoeb 4y agoUntil we're no longer bound to the availability of physical resources, we need some way to manage it. Citizenship addresses that, even if it doesn't do that perfectly.
- seanw444 4y agoThere will always be nations and borders. The alternative is the entire planet being a nation, and I have a feeling that would break down pretty fast. It would also be terrifying. Imagine being a whistleblower against the world government, and you have no jurisdiction to run to for amnesty.