4 ms·
Nice article, with some good insights. My take is that Mad Men has something that's missing from so many other shows: strong larger-than-life characters. Their
by narag 4y ago
Nice article, with some good insights.
My take is that Mad Men has something that's missing from so many other shows: strong larger-than-life characters. Their wills and quirks trump over rationality, circumstances and luck, good or bad. They never miss the oportunity to be themselves, no matter what. I watched it with the impression that they were real people that I had met.
- cm2012 4y agoThey are also horrible people in a way that doesn't feel as real in the Sopranos. That's a downside for me, I couldn't watch more than 6 episodes of these horrible, selfish people.
- narag 4y agoThat's interesting, I see them more like trapped and still doing what they really want instead of what the prison they live in tries to force them to do. It's a theme that repeats all over the place. I would call it "assertive" instead of "selfish". Edit: as an example, Peggy goes to extremes to do what she wants to do, overcoming all the obstacles that come her way. Is she selfish? Maybe but what kind of life would have she had if she had acted in some other way?
- cm2012 4y agoPeggy has an affair with a married man in the first episode and many more throughout the series. I don't blame the characters for hustling at work because everyone needs to make money, I blame them for their completely horrible and short sighted personal life decisions.
- yywwbbn 4y agoI’d still argue that the worst characters in mad men are still better human beings in almost every way than the best ones in Sopranos.
- freejazz 4y agoLol you can only understand their work motivations but not anything else? Seems more like a you problem than a the-show problem
- jassyr 4y agoI can't think of any worthwhile stories based solely on rational, moral characters. I mean I love watching Great British Bake Off as a palette cleanser for exactly this reason, but real characters are flawed, make mistakes, and are involved in real life conflicts.
- mc32 4y agoYes, but it also often reduces its characters to caricatures. In todays day and age, reducing people to caricatures is a no-go, but for some exceptions, but even so, I think this is too heavy handed and makes the show less compelling as commentary and instead reduces it to sort of crass entertainment whereas it markets itself as somewhat "middle brow" and provoking.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]