5 ms·
His first gripe is the prompt for USB HID devices, where he even has been told the correct answer but attempts to pretend it away. Unfortunately, Apple is right
by acdha 4y ago
His first gripe is the prompt for USB HID devices, where he even has been told the correct answer but attempts to pretend it away. Unfortunately, Apple is right whether or not he appreciates how many people have tried clever attacks – see https://github.com/topics/hid-attacks https://github.com/topics/hid-attacks – but my favorite write up is this one:
https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/plasma_globe/ https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/plasma_globe/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- goosedragons 4y agoHow common is it though? This was my beef with Apple too, they add security to the point it was actively getting in my way. I'm sure my house would be more secure if I auto-locked every room and they all had seperate keys but it would also be incredibly annoying. I don't use a Mac anymore but does Apple also prompt you for plugging in say a Magic Mouse or Keyboard for pairing?
- mwint 4y agoThey do.
- AdamN 4y agoMagic Mouse and Keyboard do not prompt once the relationship has been created over Bluetooth. Once they are disassociated, then you have to re-pair to get them on again.
- acdha 4y agoThey definitely do prompt, because it’s not uncommon. There’s an entire cottage industry selling tools: https://shop.hak5.org/products/usb-rubber-ducky https://shop.hak5.org/products/usb-rubber-ducky More importantly, it puts you one hack away from arbitrary code execution. That device is a dedicated testing tool but there are tons of USB devices which have vulnerable firmware, and the OS vendor can’t know whether you’d pick up a USB key you find on the ground, buy a gadget off of Craigslist, or maybe you care about security but not enough to stop using Google Chrome and it turns out that one of your attached devices is exploitable via WebUSB/Bluetooth/MIDI/etc. but you won’t learn that until the next time you plug it in to charge it. Apple does prompt their devices, and if memory serves that’s for the same reason: USB isn’t authenticated so they can’t easily tell that a device claiming to be an Apple keyboard actually is.
- eviks 4y agoBut how would the prompt help if the user plugging the off-the-ground USB key would just click yes?
- acdha 4y agoIt’s not foolproof but it gives people the opportunity to notice a problem and ask why something which isn’t a keyboard is trying to be one. The long-term fix is securing the USB protocol but when the deployed device count is measured in billions even a stopgap is useful.
- eviks 4y ago> It’s not foolproof Then don't use a fool picking up USB keys from the ground to argue for this act of a security theater! > gives people the opportunity to notice a problem But it doesn't do that because constant nagging dulls the senses. Also, how do you expect the users to learn that he needs to be on the alert for keyboard mimics? Is there an emphasis on this in the warning? > long-term fix is securing the USB protocol but when the deployed device count is measured in billions even a stopgap is useful. long-term has already arrived: USB protocol is ancient. Meanwhile the gap is still there post Ventura
- acdha 4y ago> Then don't use a fool picking up USB keys from the ground to argue for this act of a security theater! I didn't. Note the scenarios I gave included other things. Here's a good list to consider: one of your devices can be compromised in some other way (e.g. an IoT device which uses WiFi normally but charges or gets firmware updates over USB, a device which can be attacked via WebUSB & suborned), you have a friend / family member try to charge something unaware that their phone/tablet/etc. is compromised, or a device which you purchased unaware that it was compromised at the factory or while the previous owner had it. Note that none of those require malice or targeting: harder variants of this problem would be things like someone dropping a USB drive with your company's logo on it in the parking lot. That's a relatively cheap attack but at least you presumably have professionals working to prevent it whereas most home users do not. > But it doesn't do that because constant nagging dulls the senses. Just how frequently do you connect new USB HIDs? The system doesn't re-prompt devices you've used before so it's less “constant nagging” than “a couple of times over the lifetime of the device”. You appear to be having a very emotional reaction to this change – looking at your comment history shows a lot of anger and at least one time where you're angrily asking that Apple implement the current behaviour. I would suggest taking some time to cool down, think through what this actually does and some of the different scenarios other people have given you, and reconsider whether you really want to take such a strong position.
- nixpulvis 4y agoI feel dumb, but how do you ever setup a mouse/keyboard on a brand new macOS desktop?