5 ms·
The customer is always right in matters of taste
- tshaddox 4y agoI’m not sure I even agree with this weaker framing of “the customer is always right.” I don’t think a barber should be expected to give any conceivable hair cut the customer can come up with. I think it’s very reasonable for a barber to feel uncomfortable with their skill level to provide a certain hair cut, or even to think a certain hair cut is unreasonably weird. In my view, the barber is entitled to be proud of the service they provide, and to refuse to provide service outside that scope.
- josephg 4y ago> I don’t think a barber should be expected to give any conceivable hair cut the customer can come up with. I think I agree with both statements. Customers can be "right" in matters of taste - they are welcome to prefer one wine over another. But the service provider is also welcome to refuse to cater to a customer's taste; and refuse to stock a certain brand of wine for ethical reasons or whatever. A Thai resteraunt might have the equipment and ingredients necessary to make a hamburger; but they're still welcome to say no to a customer who asks for one. If they get outcompeted in the long run by a burger shop down the road, so be it. As I understand it, Apple refuses to have any adult content in their app store because they don't want to sell adult content. I think they should be welcome to make that choice, but I also find it a compelling argument to open phones up to alternate app stores.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> As I understand it, Apple refuses to have any adult content in their app store because they don't want to sell adult content. They don't refuse to have adult content in the app store. They only refuse to have unpopular adult content. Twitter and reddit have been there forever.
- xnyan 4y agoLet me start by saying that I think Apple does have a long history of being up their own ass regarding "frivolous" uses of their products, aka video games and porn. Apple has no issue with people viewing or making adult content with their platform, their objection is selling it. An iOS device is capable of viewing any and all adult content on the internet via Apple's own web browser and other Apple software. Apple does not (as far as I know) ban applications that could present adult content, but rather those who's main purpose is to present adult content. I think the reasons apple bans porn apps is 1) They think it's trashy/beneath Apple to sell applications that are primarily horny/porn and 2) banks make it expensive or impossible to move sex industry profits.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Apple does not (as far as I know) ban applications that could present adult content, but rather those who's main purpose is to present adult content. This doesn't support the idea that their objection is to selling the material. It's an unrelated concern. It also suggests that Apple would be fine selling e.g. HuniePop, which seems unlikely.
- xnyan 4y ago>This doesn't support the idea that their objection is to selling the material. It's an unrelated concern. Does Apple restrict adult content in anything besides the various marketplaces it owns (applications, media, advertisements)?
- thaumasiotes 4y agoApple restricts adult content regardless of whether that content is being sold or not.
- watwut 4y agoAdult content is euphemism for porn. It does not mean "content targeted at adults" in general.
- atoav 4y agoWhile I think your first examples are fine, I think whether it is okay that a service provider forces their decisions on someone is also a matter of size and scope. E.g. some food chain deciding not to sell a certain type of wine (for ethical, or totally selfish reasons) has no huge impact on the rights of others, because there are many other food chains and even if there were not drinking a certain wine. The bigger the company and the more it's services resemble the public square the less a company should be able to just decide freely what people are able to see.
- josephg 4y ago> The bigger the company and the more it's services resemble the public square the less a company should be able to just decide freely what people are able to see. I absolutely agree. This is why I call out Apple. Either they're a marketplace that should resemble the public square (and thus include adult content in their app store). Or they're one company amongst many competing for customers - in which case the iPhone should allow other app stores. I don't think they can play it both ways. Visa and Mastercard are also guilty of this. They often make it very difficult for adult performers to get paid with their policies. If they're like the public square for money, then they should allow any customer within the bounds of the law. If they're a businesses competing, then we need more competition. POS terminals should be extensible and able to support newcomers to the payment space to allow for more competition.
- Akronymus 4y ago> While I think your first examples are fine, I think whether it is okay that a service provider forces their decisions on someone is also a matter of size and scope. I think certain services, like custom orders, should always be able to be refused (I don't agree with putting message x on it), while service in general should be VERY hard to be refused. (Stuff like being banned from a store for shoplifting is obviously one of the things that should allow general service to be refused) IMO stores/marketplace that place themselves as "publishers" aka, vetting their products and such should have the right/obligation to refuse carrying products they don't want. But also be responsible for products they DO carry. While marketplaces where essentially anyone can sell on, like ebay, should indeed be treated like the public square.
- Georgelemental 4y agoIn your examples, the customer remains always right. People who want what the business is unwilling to provide, simply aren't customers of the business after all.
- satvikpendem 4y ago> In my view, the barber is entitled to be proud of the service they provide, and to refuse to provide service outside that scope. That is true and I don't think that is really what the phrase is saying either. The way I understood it is that at a macroeconomic scale, companies must cater to customers or be left behind by competitors who do. This barber may not cater to a specific haircut, but if many customers want such a haircut (perhaps due to some trend), then barbers who refuse to have that haircut will be left behind (financially, at least) by those who cater to such a haircut. So, both statements can be true, it's just operating on different economic scales, one at the micro, the other at the macro.
- gizmo686 4y agoI always viewed "the customer is always right (in matters of taste)" to be a statement on corporate policy. If you are a self employed batber, then go ahead and decide what you are comfortable doing. However, if you are a barber shop with a dozen barbers, you need to decide on a policy. One approach is to have a list of approved styles, from which customers must pick, or take their bussiness elsewhere. The other, "customer is alway right" approach would be to allow your barbers to go off menu. Both are reasonable policies with pros and cons; but at a certain scale, you need a consistent policy.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIf they're not confident in their ability to do it, that's not calling the customer wrong. So that only leaves "too weird to want to do", which does seem like needlessly bad service.
- slyall 4y agoA similar thing might be "well done" steaks. While somewhere between 10% and 30% of people like well-done steak this choice is mocked in articles, conversation, and internet discourse. It is discouraged (and sometimes refused) at some restaurants. Personally I grew up eating steak well done. But these days I never go to steak restaurants and I've not eaten steak in 10+ years.
- tshaddox 4y agoI’m not an expert and I certainly wouldn’t mock someone for liking well-done steak, but my impression was that it’s discouraged for certain kinds of steak, namely ones that cost more because of qualities that won’t be enjoyed when cooking it to well-done.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoIf the customer was right everyone would be using Linux
- satvikpendem 4y agoActually, your example precisely demonstrates this phrase. I am assuming this is talking about desktop Linus, not server, so if that's the case: customers have chosen to primarily use Windows and macOS instead of Linux, so now someone who creates Linux distros must deal with that fact and cater to getting those users instead of assuming a prior opinion about how the world should be (ie, everyone should or would use Linux). Basically, this phrase is the is/ought distinction in action.
- 29athrowaway 4y agoPlease, proofread your reply.
- satvikpendem 4y agoWhat are you referring to? I don't see any grammatical or spelling errors in my reply.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 29athrowaway 4y agoThen you should go see an optometrist, or read slower.
- satvikpendem 4y agoNo, looks like you didn't understand the article and are instead for some reason thinking I made a mistake. It happens, don't worry.
- tracerbulletx 4y agoI've always read this phrase very loosely as something like "make decisions based on the reality of what the market reaction to your decisions is telling you and not on your opinion".
- satvikpendem 4y agoThat's exactly how I read it too. It's also closely related to product market fit, something very topical on HN and for startups in general; don't assume that you the creator of your product are right. The customer is right, so cater to them and their needs and problems instead of trying to push your own pre-supposed solution onto them. If you can do that, you have a very high likelihood of achieving product market fit.
- tshaddox 4y agoBut it’s a useless term if it reduces to “don’t do things that are bad for your business” and doesn’t provide any insight on how to determine which things are bad for your business.
- satvikpendem 4y agoAnother topical article, shipping what your customers want, versus what they don't want. It's a case study on Notion vs Gumroad, and how Notion was able to understand users' concerns and solve their problems while Gumroad apparently did not seem to solve their problems but spent their time removing features instead. https://dontdo.popsy.site/case-study-shipping-what-customers-want-notion-vs-gumroad https://dontdo.popsy.site/case-study-shipping-what-customers... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34574951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34574951
- karmakaze 4y agoI agree with this in individual cases. On the whole though, most customers don't have good taste--by definition--because 'good taste' is a smaller fraction of the population.
- satvikpendem 4y agoTaste need not be good to be worth catering to. If people like things with bad taste, a competitor will cater to them if others aren't, just as competitors will cater to those with good taste too. This is a phrase about macroeconomic implications rather than in the micro.
- pessimizer 4y ago"The customer is always right" isn't some sort of religious belief, it's the fact that if you tell a customer that they're wrong, in the best case you're going to lose that customer and in the worst case you're going to lose a lot more customers if that one has a big mouth. It's a heuristic saying that 99% of the time it's better to lose a trivial amount of money on a customer than piss them off. Everybody is right on matters of taste, so that's just vapid. It's an area for which it has long been well known that accounting doesn't apply.
- nicoburns 4y agoThe best case is that the customer sees the error of their ways, is impressed by your knowledge, and shouts about you to everyone they know in a positive way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kbos87 4y agoThe point I think the author is trying to make is that you should take it as a strong signal when a customer expresses preference or displeasure on matters of taste. At the other end of the spectrum, I’d need a strong signal from customers on matters of price.
- bruce511 4y agoI work with independent developers, many of whom write bespoke software for individual customers. I encounter them saying "the customer is always right" all the time, and it drives me mad. It seems to me like there's a willingness to do whatever they dream up, regardless of sanity, with no push back. Ultimately the customer gets crap that doesn't work (By Design) and they are unhappy. IMO part of the reason the customer is hiring me is for my experience, judgement and skills, not just to "implement their vision". They are not qualified to design the database, design the UI and so on. Of course they are there to articulate the goals. They prioritise this over that, they need this output and so on. They determine the platform (its no good me writing for Mac if they have a Windows). Its my job to build deliver those goals. To build something coherent, intuitive, that works, that is performant, that is maintainable and so on. Obviously pick your battles. But be aware you will be visually judged by more that the check-writer. All his staff will be happy to complain about the crap, even when he specified it. (I had one customer insist on an outdated ugly font. I gave them a system where the user could choose the font.) Yes, the customer is sometimes right, and usually important, but hiding behind the "always right" moniker bugs me. (quick anecdote - the guy who wanted to log in by placing their hand on the monitor - the customer is always right, right?)
- satvikpendem 4y agoYour anecdote is precisely what this article is not about.