4 ms·
When you think about taxation, in principle if the taxation strategy were perfectly optimal then the government would never have a spiraling debt problem. The
by imtringued 4y ago
When you think about taxation, in principle if the taxation strategy were perfectly optimal then the government would never have a spiraling debt problem.
The explanation is quite simple. If you subscribe to MMT, the government issues legal tender currency and creates it and today that happens via debt. This means debt just represents untaxed money in the private sector. In other words, the government didn't bother to collect all the money that is in the private sector.
When you understand this, then having a single tax like income tax be the primary source of tax revenue is a bad thing.
Let's assume that we have an economy where all income exists in the form of wages and therefore is taxed at the income tax rate of 50% (I can't do this math on the phone, sorry). This means the half the income is taxed once every year. This money has a half life of exactly one year if the government were to use all of it to pay off debt. This means that in this example the government can never really go bankrupt as long as it doesn't do some inherently backwards things that break the economy in the long run.
But what if there are two types of incomes that are taxed at different rates and at different frequency?
What if you have wages and offshore companies where income tax can be delayed indefinitely until you bring the money back home where it is taxed at the usual income tax rate? Then suddenly it is possible for money to be stuck abroad and never taxed for long periods of time. As we know, this is money the government simply didn't bother to collect. It actively lets people keep the money abroad untaxed, so it shouldn't be surprising that the problem cannot be solved by hiking income taxes. The debt has to be extended not because the government is living beyond its means but because it is simply not collecting the money necessary to pay off its debts.
This is supposed to be an illustration, not a perfect description of the real world.
I didn't talk about low capital gains taxes. Which also means money could be stuck domestically inside the financial systems.
The lower the tax rate and the lower the frequency of the taxable event, the more time money gets to spend away from the government and the longer the government will spend its time being in debt and I am still assuming that debts are eventually paid off. In principle there is no rule that money can't be stuck in a non productive sector indefinitely which then means the government must constantly intervene by spraying money at the productive sectors so they don't dry out like plants in a desert.
- fallingknife 4y agoThe central idea that the government knows what sectors are productive and not productive is laughable.
- Oxidation 4y agoSome sectors aren't "productive" on their own but still necessary. Railways basically never pay for themselves by fares paid by (mostly) workers out of post-tax income, but the value they bring to the economy by enabling economic activity is worth it. Roads, education, healthcare, much of these things would either be unprofitable or unaffordable if they have to be self-funding. But they bring social value even if they don't make their own shareholders rich.
- fallingknife 4y agoThe commenter I was replying to was not talking about social programs. He was talking about a command economy.
- anonuser123456 4y agoI’ve never understood why this argument wasn’t the first thing economists bring out as a counterpoint to MMT. The entire thing hinges on a central planner knowing where to spend money. Gee… we’ve seen that work out so well in the past.
- neilwilson 4y agoAlternatively you stop talking about 'debt' because there is no such things. What there is is people with financial savings, and a balancing item in the national accounts because of that. That balancing item occurs naturally, costlessly and without concern as a consequence of the way double entry bookkeeping works. Money is never stuck because it isn't a thing. It's really just an accounting record. If you have £50 in your wallet or purse you are 'causing' the balancing item to come about because you have spent it yet. Tax isn't there to raise money. Tax is there to stop the private sector hiring everybody - so there is somebody left for the public sector to hire to do the jobs the government needs doing to fulfil its democratic mandate.