7 ms·
Testing Noctua’s NH-P1 with Ryzen 7700x and Intel’s i9-13900K
- Havoc 4y agoWas looking at these yesterday since I'm contemplating using it to make my desktop (3700X) quiet when retiring it to server duty I saw a nice price drop on them too (30%)
- extasia 4y agoGetting a 404 error
- FullyFunctional 4y agoThe link appear dead already
- Normal_gaussian 4y agoIs there a good aggregation of cooler performance somewhere? I've recently completed a build for the first time in a decade and was pleasantly surprised by tools like PC Part Picker, the assembly was a breeze (many micro improvements by everyone), and everything 'just worked'. Literally the only question I was out cold for was which cooler is good enough? With some coolers rivaling RAM costs and cases having fixings for radiators... it really leaves you thinking. Then again, I left it on stock and have hooked temps into prometheus and everything seems fine so far...
- emn13 4y agoYeah, the ad-funded model and how that supports reviewers seems to have damaged well structured and comprehensive independent review sites. It's all in videos or really low-effort stuff nowadays, and that makes it hard to draw conclusions without significant effort - and even then, considerable risk of drawing the wrong conclusions. I think this affects far more than just coolers; it's simply that for categories that have few options (say, CPUs) it's easier to slog through all the youtube videos, and there still exist a few text-based reviewers. But cases, ram, motherboard AIB versions, GPU AIB versions... even power supplies often - reviews are suprisingly sparse and hard to compare and rarely comprehensive.
- mrlucax 4y agoThe Gamer Nexus reviews are independent and extremely methodical and honest. It's by far the best PC components reviewer on YouTube right now.
- newsclues 4y ago“It's all in videos or really low-effort stuff nowadays,” GN doesn’t really update their website with written reviews.
- oblak 4y agohttps://techpowerup.com https://techpowerup.com is still alive. I can think of a few others, including an offshoot of [H] called thefpsreviews.com but I've seen a lot of crappy, low effort "reviews" just in time for the "video cards are finally cheap" manufactured craze last year, which was last straw for me.
- AshamedCaptain 4y agoThey have degraded significantly over the last few years. Up to around 2015 it was about my #1 reference source. It's how I found out about the fact many GPUs used to triple or quadruple their power consumption just because of an extra monitor being connected, and that AMD's HBM-based GPUs were at that point a surprising exception (when otherwise AMDs GPUs are usually the worst at it). These days however I have to take everything they measure with a grain of salt, and at some point I even had a discussion with a member of staff on the merits of having idle power consumption measurements at all. Something has definitely changed on their side.
- oblak 4y agoThe one I really miss is techreport.com Now, these guys used to deliver some quality stuff, including the big frame pacing thing that finally convinced the masses that no, fps number is not everything. One of the owners joined AMD and yeah, it's been dead for several years. Community was quite nice, too.
- Trellmor 4y agoWhile not a replacement for independent reviews, Noctua provides compatibility lists with rough thermal headroom indicators[0]. They also have compatibility list for motherboards, cases and RAM to see if it will physically fit[1]. [0]https://ncc.noctua.at/cpus https://ncc.noctua.at/cpus [1]https://ncc.noctua.at/ https://ncc.noctua.at/
- wincy 4y agoThe ice giant thermosiphon seems to be the state of the art right now from what I’ve seen. To the point where that’s being used by the world’s top overclocker instead of water cooling loops. If I were building a system I’d just slap one of those in, buy some Noctuas for quieter fan operation and ignore it, and let the CPU turbo to its hearts content. Edit: link https://www.icegiantcooling.com/ https://www.icegiantcooling.com/
- robga 4y agoOn my 32 core ThreadRipper I’ve been running an Ice Giant since it came out. It’s excellent. The only gotcha is to ensure your case can fit it in.
- oblak 4y agoHow big is this thing next to something like NH-D15?
- drtgh 4y agoI didn't know about them, so I've checked, IceGiant ProSiphon Elite vs Noctua NH-D15, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0OQxbMvo80 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0OQxbMvo80 At min 26:30 it's shown test results, and the performance seems better with Noctua NH-D15. Less noise (less rpm) for the same temperature dissipation. Noctua's performance with low noise is among the main reasons why I own one since several years ago ( And also why I choose air-cooling over water-cooling). It would be interesting to know if someone has beaten them (At same performance, less weight would be something for to take in account).
- robga 4y agoThe IceGiant ProSiphon has fittings for 4 x 120mm pwm fans. Fitted on my ThreadRipper, I switched the stock IceGiant fans out for Be Quiet Silent Wings. A significant extra cost to be sure. I'm sure some Noctua fans would fit. Best of both worlds. Any judgment on thermosiphon technology (where noise is largely not a factor) should not be conflated with a judgment on the quality of attached fans. Sold together as a product, though, I suppose it remains relevant. Remember to compare any noise savings against the total noise. e.g. I have 8 other fans in the box. If memory serves when I built it, tech websites were reporting that the temperature under load with an IceGiant was lower.
- knolan 4y agohttps://www.frostytech.com/ https://www.frostytech.com/ used to be good but I’ve not looked in many years so I’ve no idea if they’re still useful.
- m463 4y agoI did a lot of research for a theadripper, including AIO liquid cooling and all the reviews said noctua fans were as just as effective and as quiet for a fraction of the price and complexity.
- dogma1138 4y agoThe U14 or D15 cost about as much as a 360/420 AIO. Whilst they can have similar performance you aren’t saving on costs especially when you buy a 2nd fan for the main cooler which is another $25 or so if it’s Noctua.
- jeffbee 4y agoI switched from a Noctua to a 320mm AIO and was not happy. The cooling capacity with the AIO is slightly higher, but it makes much more sound at idle. The pump never stops and unlike a loafing fan it makes a high-Q tone that is clearly audible in a quiet room. That was very disappointing. All the reviews said the AIO is “silent” which would have been easily disproven by objective measurements, even with free apps on a smartphone.
- zokier 4y agoI'm in similar boat; my current desktop has 360mm aio cooling, and it makes me wonder what is peoples baseline if it can in any way be considered quiet. It feels louder than any my past aircooled builds, I definitely expected more from it.
- caycep 4y agoFor just Noctua, they have a numerical rating scale for all their models, I think. SilentPCreview?
- rejectfinite 4y agoNoctua always. For best performance on air cooling.
- neilv 4y agobroken link. https://web.archive.org/web/20230129101252/https://boringtextreviews.com/a-cooler-without-fans-testing-noctuas-nh-p1-with-ryzen-7700x-and-intels-i9-13900k/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230129101252/https://boringtex...
- smileybarry 4y agoIt was probably taken down for being published before the embargo dropped, since it shows the 7700X.
- ilyt 4y agoNope. Other links on main page also do not work, someone fucked something up
- amaranth 4y agoThe 7700X came out months ago, the one supposedly coming out soon is the 7700X3D.
- smileybarry 4y agoAh right, they just released the non-X models and the X3D, not the X-s.
- _dan 4y agohttps://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:z0qv4igbYUYJ:https://boringtextreviews.com/a-cooler-without-fans-testing-noctuas-nh-p1-with-ryzen-7700x-and-intels-i9-13900k/&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:z0qv4i... Google's cache, for anyone else having trouble with archive.org.
- mckirk 4y agoWell, now that link is dead as well apparently, so I'm starting to believe there is indeed some info here that wasn't supposed to be public (yet).
- prvc 4y agoHope these catch on. There have been a handful passive coolers for mainstream desktop CPUs that have been released over the past two decades, but they never became very popular.
- neilv 4y agoThis cooler itself doesn't have a fan, but it looks like the test system has at least 4 large case fans, including 2 directly inline with the cooler. And sounds from the text like the fans were spinning. I love Noctua, but a totally fanless system would be a more interesting test.
- Trellmor 4y agoGamers Nexus have a video testing the NH-P1 fanless[0]. Without fans it wont handle as much and you are probably limited to about 65W TDP CPUs. As a matter of fact, Noctua has a compatibility guide where they list the expected performance w/ and w/o a fan[1]. [0]https://youtu.be/N8EjMwS2ut0 https://youtu.be/N8EjMwS2ut0 [1]https://ncc.noctua.at/coolers/NH-P1-68/cpu/all/AM4 https://ncc.noctua.at/coolers/NH-P1-68/cpu/all/AM4
- topspin 4y ago> Noctua has a compatibility guide where they list Of course they do. Noctua is an excellent company. Hard to imagine how they might improve. And some credit to PC builders is deserved as well; they've supported this company and its products and paid the requisite price for years, despite a literal horde of cheaper competition. I appreciate how little regard they have for the RGB blinkenlights crowd.
- uni_rule 4y agoSeems like a neat heatsink to slap on a 5700x if you wand absolute silence without risking leaks.
- ricardobeat 4y agoThe case fans are larger and spin much more slowly, plus they are running them at 35% speed. This should be practically silent compared to any CPU fan.
- Ygg2 4y agoThat's fine I can stick a bit more case fans to avoid a huge CPU case fan. It be perfect for my DIY home NAS build.
- politelemon 4y agoThis does look interesting, PC building has improved by bounds and bounds in recent times, giving me better performance and longevity for my money. This fanless design is worth a consideration, the current go-to for people who want silence is AIO liquid coolers. They aren't terrible but do affect radiator placement. If this NH P1 can be prove viable for gaming setups it might take off. > Nonetheless, I strapped on Noctua’s NF-A15 fan and tested the NH-P1 again. The added fan increased the total cooling capacity from 150W to 200W in long term cooling scenarios. A photo of this setup would be quite useful
- def_true_false 4y agoAIOs are far from silent.
- onli 4y agoAIOs can be very quiet. Mine is (Corsair H90), but only when the pump is not running full speed (then it is quiet, but not very quiet).
- layer8 4y agoThere can be an arbitrarily large difference between “very quiet” and “silent”, or more precisely, between “still perceptible” and “not perceptible”. This depends on the environment (whether it’s so silent that you could hear a pin drop) and also on the individual hearing threshold and accommodation. AIOs are generally more perceptible than a silent build using fans.
- onli 4y agoHm. Sure, silent and "very quiet" can be a different thing and you are right ofc about the subjectivity of perception. However: > AIOs are generally more perceptible than a silent build using fans. I'm honestly not so sure about that, but I thought the same before. But then I saw the charts of how well the AIOs can cool, which means the fans and pumps can be ramped down a lot. I know some models are loud, but know also from experience that not all are. Okay, an air cooler that cools mostly passive can't be beaten, but will also need air flow as soon as the TDP is higher - and on low TDPs an AIO can again be ramped down a lot.
- salzig 4y ago> Error 404 - Not found > Your browser can't find the document corresponding to the URL you typed in. My browser? And I thought the server would search through its files to serve me a page. This site seems to be included in my browser.
- chx 4y agoVery interesting. The pioneering cooler in this space was the Scythe Ninja which has been shipping with fans for a while now so I am not sure how well it fares in passive mode. Deepcool has the GAMMAXX S40 and the REDHAT both of which mentions passive cooling but it ships with fans. NoFan IMO is gone, Prolimatech doesn't even have AM4 much less AM5 brackets for the Megahalem... Is the space deserted save for this NH-P1??
- pshirshov 4y agoThere was also Thermaltake Sonic Tower, I've used it more than 10 years ago, it was a very nice cooler.
- Klaster_1 4y agoI used to run a first gen Mugen with a E7200 and i5 4570 in passive mode, with a 12cm case fan nearby, similar to what OP did. What a great product, I still regret selling it after 12 years of use, but it would not fit into a SFF case.
- onli 4y ago> Is the space deserted save for this NH-P1?? To my knowledge: Yes. The NH-P1 is the only somewhat recent passive cooler I saw released. Which is not all that surprising, when Intel cpus regularly use 200W and more and you basically never want a completely passive build. One with only an optionally used fan, sure, but then why not use a cpu cooler where the fan can spin so quietly that is is not noticeable, like with the NH-D15 or many AIOs? (That said the NH-P1 is definitely on the list for a future build of mine)
- lmz 4y agoThermalright still seems to sell the HR-02 http://thermalright.com/product/hr-02-plus/ http://thermalright.com/product/hr-02-plus/ / "Macho" family which still says "fanless" somewhere in their description but it's unclear how much power they can handle when fanless.
- indig0F10w 4y ago[dead]
- anthonyryan1 4y agoI feel compelled to mention that this space has existed as a niche community for many years now. I've personally been using a NoFan CR-80EH in my workstations for over 10 years. I think it's subjectively the most beautiful heatsink I've ever seen. You do need to plan your build to accomodate such a cooler though. - Open Air case to allow free movement of air in and out of your case - 65W TDP CPU While a lot of people feel like 65 watt TDP is limiting, there are some impressive chips you can use under that threshold that don't feel like a compromise. Eg the Ryzen 9 7900 (not-X). And if the rest of your office is quiet, eliminating ambient background noise is a delightful improvement.
- bjoli 4y agoI always wanted to do such a project and decided to go for it. I ended up hating it because it made me realize how much I hate coil whine. I mean: it looks so friggin cool, and placing it on your desk will probably give much better air circulation than under it. No fans spinning just made me realize how much noise most computers make that is hidden under fan noise. I did have dedicated graphics card though, but a passively cooled one. None of my friends found it bothersome, so maybe I'm just sensitive.
- dijit 4y agoFWIW Coil Whine affects some machines much more than others. The sad part is, coil whine is unpredictable, two machines with the same make/models can behave differently. Coil whine is usually much more noticeable when you fully load a system too. What I would do is buy components and then fully load them as much as I could, and RMA anything with noticeable whine. It's not "normal", Dell XPSs for example were notorious for bad coil whine where as my macbook air doesn't have any at all.
- cout 4y agoI do like that design -- it reminds me of the Zalman Flower, which I also find beautiful.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>this space has existed as a niche community for many years now Yes, I also remember the passive cooling community has existed for a long time, with it being a very big thing when PCs were loud monstrosities, but I feel it has peaked sometime in the mid to late '00s and has been slowly loosing momentum since active cooling solutions became much quieter and better at ramping up/down with load, with most CPUs, GPUs, PSUs coolers nowadays even turning fully off when idling or under low load, along with the shift from PCs to mobile devices, making the need for passive-only PC cooling solutions a small and expensive niche that not many venture into.
- jmyeet 4y agoCalling this fanless is one of those things that is technically correct but not really accurate. Instead of the HSF having a fan directly on it, you're simply relying on the case's cooling to dissipate heat. Fans usually allow you to put larger fans on and larger fans means more airflow and quieter operation. You can design the entire system to be passively cooled but this will limit the potential power. This might be fine. Having a high-end GPU means this is almost impossible. For anyone wanting such a system, you'll want to go with an AIO HSF and intake and outtake fans on the case.
- meta-level 4y agoHave a Streacom DB4, much cooler (pun intended)
- PufPufPuf 4y agoI noticed that this page published 5 reviews in total, starting just three months ago. I wonder how they convinced the companies to send them hardware to review (even if it's not "free" and they have to return it afterwards). I always thought that these large corporations only care about big reviewers / influencers.
- AnotherGoodName 4y agoThey usually spin off from forum posters on larger sites who have been buying and reviewing their own gear as forum posts and have enough clout from those communities that they start to be sent things.
- albert-thomas 4y agoAuthor here - while I'm not big by any stretch of the word, I'm not new to cooling reviews. I've published cooling reviews to Tom's Hardware and other platforms. When it comes to review samples - I'll say this : It depends on the product you're reviewing (and how expensive it is), and the history you have of reviewing similar products. The cheaper an item is, the more likely the companies will send it to smaller reviewers.
- alexklarjr 4y agoNoctua brand is magical. You put noctua logo on any radiator and it dissipate heat twice more effective. You put noctua logo on a fan and it twice as silent while pushing twice more air. Noctua’s aluminium is not your regular aluminium, but much, much more. I heard car with Noctua radiator cooled to -274 once.
- shmerl 4y agoI think passive cooling generally benefits from design where walls of the case are themselves working as heatpipes.
- mjh2539 4y agoThis is only tangentially related, but I've been using these graphite-based thermal pads instead of thermal paste, and it's been painless. No throttling, and no messy paste!
- ComputerGuru 4y agoI somehow get a 404 for this page. Archived copy: https://archive.is/ZrbgR https://archive.is/ZrbgR
- avsteele 4y agoIts so big you could fit a large fan on it and just run it at absurdly low speed. No way you are going to hear it unless you are a mouse and i'm sure you'd get a lot more performance.
- merpkz 4y agoI find it amusing that this huge hunk of metal made to dissipate heat costs as much as state of the electronic marvel CPU underneath it.