5 ms·
I think this concern has to be balanced against the billions of dollars promoting the status quo. A lot of people want to believe that all we need to do is buy
by acdha 4y ago
I think this concern has to be balanced against the billions of dollars promoting the status quo. A lot of people want to believe that all we need to do is buy electric cars, and there are multiple industries pushing that since it’s good for business while politicians like not having to tell people that lifestyle changes are necessary.
- CraigJPerry 4y ago>> A lot of people want to believe that all we need to do is buy electric cars The people i hear most vehemently arguing for ev adoption are quick to share a laundry list of all the other things we should be doing. I haven’t run across the EV-and-we’re-done brigade. I’m not dismissing that they exist but I haven’t met them.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoLiterally every time I see anything about "green transportation" from federal, state, or local government and non-profits the talk starts with and ends with electric vehicles. The feds talk some talk about alternative transit, and some cities are leaning heavily into alternate transit...but at my county and local level there's basically zero interest in public transit, walking, or biking infrastructure.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoAdvocating for walkable cities and being anti-automobile is all the rage nowadays, but that doesn’t translate well to real world action. As much as we want to, and should, redesign cities, that is a monumental undertaking that will necessarily require several decades worth of effort and billions of dollars. Switching to electric vehicles, meanwhile, does not require eminent domain and does not ask citizens to change their mobility standards. It is also something local governments don’t have to pay for.
- paulryanrogers 4y ago> ...does not ask citizens to change their mobility standards. My how far we have come from "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country."
- sokoloff 4y agoThat challenge was to find ways to contribute in your own sphere. Converting one car to an EV (and accepting the resulting compromises) is more realistically in that spirit than something like “knock down your house and build a mid-rise on your lot” would be.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoCollective action and sacrifice will be necessary to change density. Still that doesn't prevent us from adapting to more sustainable transportation modes, both collectively and personally. I was addressing the fear that governments have of disrupting current mobility 'standards'.
- ajross 4y ago> A lot of people want to believe that all we need to do is buy electric cars, and there are multiple industries pushing that Um... who? I think it's rather the opposite: I see a "lot of people" in "multiple industries" making strawman arguments like this. Essentially, it's a deflection from "EVs are better than cars" (a clear truth that can't reasonably be argued with) to "EV proponents don't have all the answers either" (a winnable argument that feels like it's related even though it isn't). Buy the EV. Also move closer to the urban core, WFH, and otherwise reduce your dependence on the suburban road networks. But buy the EV if you need a car.
- mellosouls 4y agoEven leaving aside your dubious claim about what can and cannot be argued with, your conclusion about what choices people should make is pie in the sky for a significant part of even the developed world. Economic and logistic reasons mean that carbon fuel cars are still the best transport option for most (?) people outside of urban centres and well-paid jobs.
- ajross 4y agoThis seems like a dodge? You said lots of people were saying something, I asked for a cite.
- mellosouls 4y agoI'm not the poster you are referring to.
- b112 4y agoUpvoted, as I see you were downsmashed because you spoke of realities, not "where we want to be". What you say is true. I find "everyone EV now!" proponents, often just use handwavy platitudes when given "I can't" info. For example, for many, many people ... range is a vital, and sadly an electric EV preventive thing. When told this, EV absolutists often blather on about why a person is wrong, and do so while ignoring that person's reality. The same is valid for cost. If you are poor, and can barely afford a truck for work, telling someone to spend 2x or 3x for a EV variant is exceptionally unfeeling, unrealistic, and elitist. What we need to do, is be open to solutions to help people switch. One is H2, which has multiple cars with extensive range on the road, yet EV absolutists will start going on about green or not h2. While at the same time ignoring that all excess power in the US, currently comes from fossil fuel! Until the last fossil fuel shuts down, that is excess kept running by EV needs. But you see, the goal is not where the battery charge, or h2 comes from, it is where it can come from! We can 100% make green h2, just as we can eventually fully purge fossil fuels from our electric grid. And it takes decades to move cars and transport from fossil to alternative options. We are doing it in parallel. So that one day, when we are free of fossil use, all our cars will already be fossil free! Including poor people driving 20 year old cars!
- dheera 4y agoWhat I really don't understand is why don't Shell, Exxon, Chevron and their ilk get into the EV game and start setting up DC fast chargers at all of their gas stations? They profit, and EV range anxiety becomes a thing of the past by having chargers literally everywhere.
- pharmakom 4y agoLow profit. Accelerates decline of the cash cow.
- imtringued 4y agoBut the gas station cash cow is often the overpriced kiosk and not the gasoline.
- pharmakom 4y agoGas stations are usually franchised and the gas companies make good profit from that arrangement. The problem with supporting electric, is that most EV users don’t visit gas stations at all - they charge at home overnight.
- CharlesW 4y agoI'm guessing for the same reason innovation rarely happens within companies that are printing money by maintaining the status quo. The Innovator's Dilemma by Clayton Christensen is a good book on this, and the iPhone is another good example that had to come from outside the telecom industry. Plus, there's an impedance mismatch between EV charging times and the retail store model, in that retail stores want customers in and out ASAP.
- SECProto 4y ago> What I really don't understand is why don't Shell, Exxon, Chevron and their ilk get into the EV game and start setting up DC fast chargers at all of their gas stations? At least in Canada, there has definitely been a push in this direction. Both Petro-Can[1] and Irving[2] have set up fast charging networks at their stations. Many of the Tesla Superchargers in Canada[3] are also located at various gas stations and truck stops (that specifically benefit from more restaurant customers when they use the charger). [1] https://www.petro-canada.ca/en/personal/fuel/canadas-electric-highway https://www.petro-canada.ca/en/personal/fuel/canadas-electri... [2] https://www.irvingoil.com/en-US/on-the-road/electric-vehicle-charging https://www.irvingoil.com/en-US/on-the-road/electric-vehicle... [3] https://www.tesla.com/findus https://www.tesla.com/findus