6 ms·
Manatee county teachers close class libraries, fearing prosecution under FL law
- jleyank 4y ago[flagged]
- slater 4y agoWait till they hear about the provenance of this 'Algebra' thingy the eggheads keep talking about!
- CamperBob2 4y agoCareful. The admins are looking for insightful comments rather than outrageous comparisons that can't possibly refer to things that might actually happen if enough people take their eyes off the ball. So, say something insightful that doesn't risk offending anyone on the right side of this obviously-two-sided issue.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoThis is the kind of rationalism and level-headedness I want in an educator.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> rationalism and level-headedness I work in a regulated industry. Keeping a wide berth from criminal conduct, even when a bit ridiculous, is the rational move.
- skissane 4y agoLots of people don’t “keep a wide berth” at all, and make billions doing so. Look at all the corporate tax avoidance schemes that most megacorps engage in, many of which are only a few debatable legal technicalities away from criminal tax evasion
- the_only_law 4y agoYeah but those people are often above the bureaucrats, not stuck below them.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> only a few debatable legal technicalities away from criminal tax evasion They're a few technicalities away from civil tax evasion. The difference is disclosure.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoUnfortunately it’s not the educators making the rules.
- GoldenMonkey 4y agoAs it should be. Legislatures and accountable people. Not some random educator who wants to teach whatever they want. Parents are tired of these educators not teaching the basics. And indoctrinating their kids.
- jasonjayr 4y agoI am a parent, and I am not tired of it. Teachers study & hard to work out the best techniques to motivate all students, find make lessons and experiences to encourage healthy curious minds. It's laughable that those who have not studied childhood education think they are making the right call, or that these teachers have an agenda besides trying to help these kids be better.
- agensaequivocum 4y agoNo one cares more about my kids' well-being than I the parent do. It is quite clear that a large number of "educators" at best have no regard for the well-being of the children that they have authority over. The books that these school are allowing the kids to have access to are absolutely disgusting. The founders never intended for obscenity to be protected by the 1st amendment.
- jasonjayr 4y agoThe founders are dead, and they no longer hold any power over our current government. Further, the case that considered if the first amendment covered obscenity was only considered in 1957, and even then left a big grey area. The community I was raised in, and grew up in, and continue to raise my kids in, do not consider the same things this law considers obscene. A very vocal minority is flexing whatever power they can hold on to, and forcing this unwelcome intrusion into our communities.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI thought first that it was a theatrical protest by just a single teacher or school, but it turns out to be broader in scope: The Manatee County School District directed teachers to remove all books that had not yet been approved by a specialist from their classroom libraries [..] ...so I thought that was worthy of mention. Library access/availability seems like a fundamental thing for me, in line with the hacker ethos of self-directed learning and maximizing access to information.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wkdneidbwf 4y agothis is so amazingly stupid i’m stunned. i’m just glad my kids don’t go to school in florida.
- sebmellen 4y agoHow would a teacher who stocks books in their classroom be held liable for this? Wouldn’t any such case end up in the Supreme Court?
- standardUser 4y agoTeachers are in the crosshairs now in a lot of communities and any action taken against them under state law could takes years to get heard in higher courts. If I were a teacher, I wouldn't be betting on the restraint of state regulators under DeSantis or any exceptional speed and efficiency from the court system.
- akudha 4y agoAcross the country, many laws are passed by red states that might not hold up if they are challenged in Supreme Court. But how many cases can SC take on? How long will these cases take? Primary objective of these laws is to scare people and theatrics. By that metric, this law seems to be doing well. That said, are we even sure the current SC will act in the best interests of the ordinary citizen?
- krapp 4y agoThe reason red states are passing laws like this is that they believe the Supreme Court, recently stacked by Conservatives hand-picked by the Federalist Society, will either leave it to the states or rule in their favor.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoAnd given Roe v Wade, a so called by the Catholic majority “settled decision”, has been reverted, all the evidence suggests it will rule in their favour. If the SC can’t protect a freedom as fundamental as person’s bodily autonomy and integrity, they will do nothing here.
- xupybd 4y agoWhile I understand your point I think that ruling came down to the technicalities of constitutional law. It should not be up to the judicial branch to make laws only interpret them. If there is a problem with the law congress needs to fix it.
- steponlego 4y ago[flagged]
- CamperBob2 4y ago[flagged]
- the_only_law 4y agoJust make the most empty, milquetoast statement saying nothing, but wrap it in multiple paragraphs with clever word choice so it looks like you’re actually saying something.
- whatshisface 4y agoSee if you can come up with something that we're not already all thinking - that's what that rule is really about.
- skissane 4y agoThey don’t agree with the law, so they are deliberately interpreting it in the most extreme and nonsensical way possible, in order to make a political statement against it. The fact is all laws are up to interpretation, and discretion is an essential part of their enforcement. I really doubt anybody would prosecute a teacher for an obviously non-controversial text which hadn’t technically been approved yet. I think the teachers have a pretty good idea of what texts are completely safe, and which texts are potentially problematic-but they are feigning ignorance to make a political statement.
- mathgorges 4y agoI don't see that expressed in the article. From the article: > If you have a lot of books like I do, probably several hundred, it is not practical to run all of them through (the vetting process) so we have to cover them up I imagine teachers in Florida are expected to uphold their normal duties while complying with this new law, and teachers are famously overworked. Manually checking hundreds of book against an allow-list seems rather time intensive. Since failure to comply with the law could result in a felony charge this course of action from the teachers seems perfectly rational to me. ETA: Even if a court would throw out the charge (remains to be seen), would you really want to go though all the legal trouble?
- alistairSH 4y agoFlorida made it a felony to share books that weren’t approved. As a teacher, it makes sense to remove books instead of risk prosecution. This isn’t the school libraries, this is books individual teachers keep in the classroom.
- skissane 4y agoHow many teachers have been prosecuted for said felony? How many unrelated felonies have they committed, which they don’t care about? If everything which is technically a felony were (successfully) prosecuted, probably every adult American would be a convicted felon - http://alex.kozinski.com/articles/Youre_Probably_a_Federal_Criminal.pdf http://alex.kozinski.com/articles/Youre_Probably_a_Federal_C... - but I doubt they’d apply the same attitude to all those other laws
- ryeights 4y agoStatus: WONTFIX Desc: working as intended
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoYou Americans are going to be in for a hell of a ride if Desantis runs for president and wins.
- vidanay 4y agoSoap box, ballot box, ammo box. In that order.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoWe deserve it for making the executive and federal government in general so powerful. We should be able to elect almost any idiot with minimal damage so long as congress and the court are not too stuffed with idiots of equivalent bent.
- SamReidHughes 4y ago[flagged]
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoWould you be happy if your school inspected your daughter’s periods and demanded information about it? Because that’s where this is heading. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/florida-athletes-menstrual-periods/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/florida-athletes-menstrual...
- jeremyjh 4y agoWhat the hell happens to someone to make them believe teachers are handing out pornographic material just because Faux News tells them so?
- SamReidHughes 4y agoHuh? I don't think most teachers are -- where did you get the idea that I did? If they aren't, then complying with this law will be easy.
- moistly 4y ago
- whatshisface 4y ago>New training approved by the State Board of Education also asks media specialists to avoid materials with “unsolicited theories that may lead to student indoctrination.” Unsolicited?
- jachee 4y agoYeah, the racist whites (edit: as opposed to the non-racist ones) didn’t ask for CRT, so they consider it an “unsolicited theory”.
- akomtu 4y agoThe intent is to ban CRT and all its mutations. I guess the law can't call it by name for it would instantly change its name.
- richbell 4y agoI'm sure there are people who'd love to keep the "theory" of evolution out of schools as well.
- roenxi 4y agoSure, but the issue here is different people want different things out of school for different reasons. We happen to know a dangerously large group of people wants to make everything about race - ie, classic racist ideology. We happen to have a couple centuries of evidence that this is not a good idea. If they are organising under the banner of critical race theory then that needs to be resisted. There is no place for racism in the public school system.
- imglorp 4y ago“The real heroes are the librarians and teachers who at no small risk to themselves refuse to lie down and play dead for censors.” ― Bruce Coville
- ironmagma 4y agoThere's a line where not being a hero just bleeds into not taking stupid risks. Third degree felony is past the line IMO.
- throwaway9191aa 4y agoI don't know this person, and I'm glad he writes children's books. I wonder if he has been shot by a six year old while writing any of those books [0]. All while the government actively undermines all the work he does. Any teachers here? Or folks married to teachers? I can't cite all the horrible pay, and parents ridiculing you, but it happens to my wife almost constantly. I doubt it is very different for other teachers. If it is so noble maybe they deserve some more money and respect. I wouldn't stand up to this governor in a state that elected him. Maybe I'd move to another state and get a teaching job there (which I could not do if I picked up a felony in Florida). [0] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/teacher-shot-6-year-old-texted-dire-warning-loved-one-was-wounded-sour-rcna67290 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/teacher-shot-6-year-old...
- germinalphrase 4y agoI left in June. After six weeks of looking, I took a position at a small tech consultancy and doubled my salary, improved my benefits, and work about 15 fewer hours per week. I have very conflicted feelings about leaving education, but my life - and my family life - is much better in some significant and measurable ways.
- locutous 4y agoIt's bad on both sides. As a parent. If your child ends up in a class where other children are abusive there is almost no recourse for changes and you are treated poorly for trying. Ditto if the teacher is abusive, which also happens. Most of the time the only recourse is to pull them out.
- vidanay 4y agoFive years ago, my company offered me a fully funded relocation package to Florida. The shitty education system was one of the primary reasons we declined the offer. I have never regretted the decision for one single minute since then.
- the_only_law 4y agoOut of everything I have to say it’s the weather that’s going to drive me out. I was born and raised in the south, but at least other states I’ve lived had seasons.
- vidanay 4y agoThe weather was the second strongest reason for our decision. It was a long list to be honest.
- georgeburdell 4y agoHaving gone through said system many years ago, it actually was not a bad system for certain types of people: 1. My area had gifted programs, unlike SF where I live now, which has dispatched them in the name of “equity”. I lived in a 2/10 school district because my parents were poor and got bused across the county to a 10/10 gifted school for free 2. College tuition is the lowest in the nation —— far lower than any Blue state. UFlorida is $6k/year, and there are easy scholarships that halve that or more I’m actually considering moving my family back
- jleyank 4y agoAt least your honest. Florida attracts certain types of people. If you're comfortable with those kinds of people, avoid mirrors. Harsh, yeah, but doing something for the money has a name and it's not always considered favourable.
- the_only_law 4y agoI will say I agree that Florida tuition is a godsend if you’re a resident, but otherwise, I find the job market better in Atlanta or Raleigh, so I’d pick those above anywhere in FL if I wanted to stay in that south.
- crawfordcomeaux 4y agoIt's really time for some radical civil disobedience. I'd love to see a video of every teacher in a district shelving a copy of the same unapproved book or giving one to a kid.
- nhchris 4y agoUnapproved book? You mean something like White Identity by Jared Taylor? Or do you mean "unapproved" that you can find on Amazon and every other online or offline bookstore? Everyone's against book bans, until it's a book they want to ban. Lucky for you, teachers agree with you, so there's no need for a ban to keep it from school library shelves or curricula - teachers simply don't stock or assign it, and you can pat yourself on the back about how pro-knowledge, pro-academic-freedom, and anti-censorship you are.
- crawfordcomeaux 4y agoWhichever book. I simply mean the ones the law is looking to ban. I'm literally not against any book being available. It's the cultures of domination that are the issue and those need to be practiced to spread. I'm uncertain what you're upset about. I'm literally talking about civil disobedience against laws. Is that something you disagree with?
- xupybd 4y agoWe have wanted to home school for years but the more I think about it the better it seems. Social values around the world seem to be diverging. States will now struggle to offer families an education that matches their values. They'll come up with law like this that end up making it near impossible for teachers to do their job.
- hueyluey 4y agoI was reading up on the history of Iran the other day and thinking: "wow, how can a relatively educated and secular country end up with such fanatical laws?". This sounds likes it's in the same wavelength. I'm interested in hearing if there are non religious people that support these kind of laws. I come from a secular country, so all this is very difficult to understand
- fuzzythinker 4y agoWhy flagged? Who's flagging this?
- djkivi 4y agoOh the hu-manatee.