3 ms·
> What takes 10 hours in a flight will take 13 hours on fast trains. Okay, let's look at that bullet train. At best that's 200 mph. A trip from SF to NY is the
by godelski 4y ago
> What takes 10 hours in a flight will take 13 hours on fast trains.
Okay, let's look at that bullet train. At best that's 200 mph. A trip from SF to NY is then going to be 12.85 hrs. Assuming we go in a perfectly straight line (trains can't do this) and no stops. We'll say 13 for ease. A nonstop flight (not hard to find) is about 5.5 hrs.
In both situations we're only considering the travel time of the vehicle and not including anything like layovers/stops or boarding and unboarding. These are not one or two hour differences in travel time and thus security would make the difference, there are over 7hrs difference! You could fly all the way back to SFO before that bullet train rider gets to NYC (you're already through security). (We're also assuming that as trains get more popular that similar security theater isn't also introduced)
Now I do think people would still take the train fwiw because even with a 7hr travel time takes up all your day and flying sucks. Plenty of people will make this trade as long as trains don't sardine pack like airlines do. But let's also not fool ourselves into thinking the times are roughly the same and that that train also isn't going to take closer to 16hrs to go across country. Which even means doubling the speed (400mph) still makes it slower than a plane with security check-ins.
- lostlogin 4y agoThere are plenty that average 200mph and the Chinese seem to be getting a bit higher, with one operating at 286mph. They are working on considerably faster ones. Surely a US train could aim to be up there with the fastest? Even with that boost though, your point remains. https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/travel/article/worlds-fastest-trains-cmd/index.html https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/travel/article/worlds-fastest-trains...
- nradov 4y agoThere's no way any future US bullet train could hit 200 mph through the Sierra Nevada and Rocky mountain ranges unless we bore tunnels straight through. Transcontinental bullet trains across North America are a total pipe dream just based on simple geography. But bullet trains should play a role in our regional transportation infrastructure.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoOur rail system is built for slow speed freight hauling and passenger trains have to share the same rails (and give priority to freight, which is why we have enormous unexpected delays on our passenger trains). It's simply not feasible to run bullet trains in the country without building entirely new tracks. It is an enormous and expensive undertaking to build new rails across 2600 miles, through a couple enormous mountain ranges and more.
- godelski 4y agoNote that I calculated with 200mph and did not consider stops or a train's need to travel not in straight lines. Kube made a comment comparing with Japan's system that may extrapolate better as it considers stops[0], but may bound from the other direction as there are likely higher demand for stops along that route than SF to NY, which is mostly traveling through low population dense areas. Consider that my napkin calculation was intended to give many advantages to the train for a naive best case scenario. Also note that while the Shanghai Maglev does have a maximum speed of 268mph it has an average speed of 139/155mph (different schedules = different speeds). We need to consider average when calculating travel times. You'll also note that on that CNN page that several of those trains have test runs that reach near 400mph! This is good for considering where we might be able to get with high levels of optimization but they do not reflect the reality of speeds that a passenger will actually experience. Considering the extrapolations we'd realistically need trains that could have max speeds above 600mph and sustained speeds (through quite windy areas and mountains mind you) of 400+mph. I do think cross continental passenger trains can still have a market but I think more coastal focused lines will have substantially better markets and we shouldn't expect trans-continental train alternatives to planes being popular for quite some time. The coastal lines mostly make sense because the total times are still relatively short and we consider the convenience tradeoff more influential. I'm pretty sure that this trade-off is highly non-linear with respect to travel time (convenience weakly dominates in short transit but time strongly dominates on long hauls). [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34549637 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34549637
- qbasic_forever 4y agoGetting trains up past 600mph is going to be right at breaking the sound barrier. There's no way communities and people living near tracks would put up with constant sonic booms all day. It's just not feasible.
- kube-system 4y ago> Assuming we go in a perfectly straight line (trains can't do this) and no stops I looked it up out of curiosity. To travel the length of Japan's bullet train network, which goes most of the length of the country, it takes 3 trains and 31 stops, for a total of just under 12 hours. A flight between the same locations is just over 3 and a half hours. For those who want to look it up, these figures are for Kagoshima-Chuo Station to Shin-Hakodate Hokuto Station. I can see how the train would be come out ahead for shorter distances, but I think this kind of trip is more reasonable of a comparison with the distance of flights that many Americans are taking.
- dzhiurgis 4y agoThat’s only 870 miles in straight line. NY<>LA is 2500miles. Extrapolating from there your train would take 36hours.