3 ms·
If we assume (for the sake of a reductive argument) they want either food, or water, then feeding them apples can't resolve which it was, because apples are moi
by ggm 4y ago
If we assume (for the sake of a reductive argument) they want either food, or water, then feeding them apples can't resolve which it was, because apples are moist and in Deer-efficiency terms may be "meh: I was thirsty this does"
So from a "what action/noun" pair perspective its give <something> and it's not clear what <something> is without a more consistent experiment to make it clear its a choice A or B.
But what it can go to is "give" is in this. <stare at human> is pretty strongly bound to 'give me something' -Right up until you realise they want to headbutt you or are staring at their own reflection in the glass or really are just zoned out.. or a million other potential interpretations.
The thing here is that Animals are probably doing min/max on the cost/reward outcome and could stare for an hour, for a remarkably diffuse win. If its safe, warm, sheltered and MIGHT have one of food, water or a back rub, it might be a win set against the energy cost of foraging.
- foota 4y agoI guess this explains why humans scroll reddit mindlessly for hours :-)
- pxc 4y ago> If we assume (for the sake of a reductive argument) they want either food, or water, then feeding them apples can't resolve which it was [...] see Quine on radical interpretation and the indeterminacy of translation: https://iep.utm.edu/indeterm/ https://iep.utm.edu/indeterm/