5 ms·
Note that drip pricing for restaurants (e.g. 10-20% non-tip surcharge) is illegal in many jurisdictions (if not "conspicuously advertised" before eating), but s
by crazygringo 4y ago
Note that drip pricing for restaurants (e.g. 10-20% non-tip surcharge) is illegal in many jurisdictions (if not "conspicuously advertised" before eating), but some restaurants try to do it anyways (claiming the policy is "conspicuously advertised" on the last page of the menu, or a tiny sign behind the bar).
Sometimes you can just refuse to pay it and they'll back down because they want a repeat customer more. Sometimes they'll insist, but you can still just... not pay it, if you don't plan on going back. It's not like they're going to call the police, and you're paying the main bill.
Unfortunately, it's not infrequent for restaurants to also withhold any unpaid part of the bill from a server's tips. That's usually illegal as well, but most servers would rather keep their job than complain. So you might think you're not paying the restaurant, but then it's the server who suffers.
In other words, literally everything about this sucks.
- lolinder 4y ago> Sometimes they'll insist, but you can still just... not pay it, if you don't plan on going back. It's not like they're going to call the police, and you're paying the main bill. This only works if you have enough cash on hand to cover the main bill or you're able to be really pushy and get them to run only the main bill on the card.
- crazygringo 4y agoYup, you definitely have to be willing to waste 10+ minutes of polite arguing and be willing to insist they run only the main bill or you'll walk out without paying anything at all. Which in many (most?) social situations, it's not worth doing. But if you're willing to take a moral stand against sneaky surcharges, maybe you care enough. Again, literally everything about it sucks.
- II2II 4y agoRestaurants must be happy that I am not the type of person who eats out more than once or twice a year. I don't tip unless there is table service. I withhold tips if the quality of the product is bad (sorry servers). Even in social situations. That doesn't mean I don't tip when it is appropriate, but I view it as more of an incentive for good service than to reinforce bad business practices. I'm not sure how I would respond to sneaky surcharges since I haven't encountered it. Most likely, I would pay and never go back. If the amount was excessive and I was on my own, I would likely protest it and never go back.
- hadlock 4y agoServers make $2.14 an hour in Texas, they're fully dependent on tips. They often/always have zero control over the kitchen or management's ability to do staffing. Keep this in mind when you eat in that state.
- ApolloFortyNine 4y agoStill required by law to pay the difference up to minimum wage. Still only 7.25 but let's be accurate.
- seadan83 4y agoLaw and practice can often be different. Often "the agreement" is cash tips are not declared on taxes, and you don't hassle the company when you make an hourly shortfall. My impression is that arrangement is far more common than companies actually making sure you get minimum wage every hour.
- kmoser 4y agoThe IRS assumes servers get a certain amount of tips, so if you don't report close to what they expect, you run a high risk of being audited.
- seadan83 4y agoTrue. The loophole is that most tips are on credit cards and hence automatically reported. There is no distinction of cash vs CC tips when reporting. So effectively zero dollars in cash tips is being reported. In the 90s I delivered pizzas for one of the big companies. I raised that if I didn't make tips the company was supposed to pay me $5.50 instead of the $3.25 that was my wage. The boss said, ok, but if we do that then you have to report your cash tips" - the "agreement" was quite explicit
- thayne 4y agoThat is not unique to Texas.
- csomar 4y agoThey are only authorized to charge what you have approved. Period. If they charge more, then charge them back for the extra or the whole amount. Make it clear before they run your CC.
- nraynaud 4y agoIn France the prices have to be visible from outside the restaurant and you’d better be able to pre-compute your final bill before pushing the door. I am always surprised that a country like France protects its invisible market hand better than the US that is more capitalist minded. Information symmetry is absolutely essential for market actors to behave in their own best interest.
- wolverine876 4y ago> I am always surprised that a country like France protects its invisible market hand better than the US that is more capitalist minded. The US now serves 'capitalists', which is different than serving the free market or a capitalist economic system.
- xbar 4y agoIs that all of EU?
- maweki 4y agoProbably not. In Germany you have to show an excerpt of the menu (including prices) outside the restaurant. Usually the owners prop one or two of the middle pages of the menu and a page of the seasonal menu in a wall display by the entrance.
- db48x 4y agoMany but not all restaurants in the US do that as well, even though they aren’t required to do it. They do it because customers appreciate it, and they know that customers are more willing to try an unfamiliar place if they have some idea of what the food is like.
- nicbou 4y agoGerman law also states that the price you see must be the price you pay, including applicants taxes. It’s in the Preisangabenverordnung.
- HelixEndeavor 4y agoEvery day it seems more and more like restaurants in general are a completely unsustainable business unless you want to pay $20 for a cheeseburger.
- bradleyjg 4y agoRestaurants should generally be expected to get more and more relatively expensive, especially “sit down” restaurants, because of Baumol’s cost disease. There’s a large labor component that isn’t getting significantly more efficient over time.
- whoisthemachine 4y agoMany restaurants in our area are "removing the middle man" so to speak - with modern technology, the waiter isn't a necessary component, as ordering, paying, etc. can all be done either through a smart phone or a smart display at the table. A server is still somewhat necessary, but requiring someone who is highly sociable or remembers orders well is no longer needed. Of course, nicer restaurants will retain waiters because it is nice to be waited on by another human being, but you need to pay for that experience!
- smileysteve 4y agoAfter tips, taxes, and beer prices; U.S. did has been much more expensive than just European food for the last decade.
- nicbou 4y agoCanada sure feels like that when I visit. I always forget the double 15% for taxes and tip. Them comes the expensive beer. In the end I pay more to eat even accounting for the exchange rate.
- bruce511 4y agoIf you think about it, this is not surprising. Ultimately you are paying for a lot more than the food. Let's assume you can make the meal yourself at home. You'd pay for the ingredients, but probably ignore all the other costs. A) labor is the obvious first candidate. Purchaser, chef, server, host, barman, dishwasher, table cleaner- there are lots of people involved. The price of your meal should include labor at fair rates, including benefits etc. (in the US it doesn't hence the need for tipping.) By contrast your home-cooked meal uses your (free?) time so already has a head start. B) location. Your living room is free. Your plates are free. Restaurants pay a lot for space (rent etc). They also pay for equipping the space, and for breakages. C) wastage. When something goes bad in your fridge you throw it out. Restaurants take this straight off yhd bottom line. I could go on - marketing, regulation, health standards, parking and so on. It all adds up. Most restaurants fail because margins are tight - and if there isn't sustained volume small things will drive you under fast. And frankly the food offering at most places is inferior to home-made with only the smallest amount of kitchen skills. So yeah, small establishments with very low overhead (think food trucks) can be both good and good value. But most places either have to skimp on quality (think most fast food) or try and externalise the cost (via tipping etc) Put another way. Teach your children to cook. It's not hard. And it's a LOT cheaper than eating out. And yeah, your cheeseburger at $20 is a bargain.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoWhen I was being trained to work at a McDonald's restaurant (like four decades ago) they had us watch an awesome PSA about "the customer". To this day I remember the closer spoken by the poorly treated customer in the video, "I don't get mad, I just don't come back." I've left notes on my bill explaining to "management" why I'm not returning to a particular restaurant. I don't like doing it, but I think someone needs to call them out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fencepost 4y agoI've left notes on my bill explaining to "management" why I'm not returning It's likely much more effective explaining in a review why you're not returning.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JKCalhoun 4y agoYou're probably right. I'm thinking specifically of a few restaurants at a time that was pre-Yelp.
- hinata08 4y agoI figured that out as well But I realized that it was not encouraging for management to have complaint emails. And I hardly had a reply back (I assume most businesses just don't care) Nowadays I'm once again just the silent customer who doesn't come back. However, I can hapilly reply to polls, reviews, or send thank you emails to businesses that I liked, to encourage them. I get a lot of _you welcome_ replies. And a small company even indicating that they would include my review in their staff training, to show what points customers liked. So instead of being negative, I found it was more constructive to have a positive perspective on services that were worth it, to make them more stable.
- habitue 4y agoI mean, it sounds like every part of this where a restaurant owner is committing a crime sucks.
- illumin8 4y agoOne thing I've noticed recently on 2 restaurant trips in the last couple weeks: The automatic tip calculations are wrong in the server/restaurant's favor. Most of us typically check the 20% option and don't double-check the math, but in the past these calculations were always done pre-tax. If your food came to $100 and you tipped 20%, the total would be $120 + sales tax. Now, the last 2 times I've eaten out the automatic tip calculation was done on the post-tax amount. I live in Alameda county where the sales tax is over 10%, so this is a big difference. Not only that, the default tip options were something like 18, 20, and 25%. The only reason I can see for restaurants to do this is that the minimum wage here is $15/hour, and if tips alone don't make that rate, the restaurant pays out of pocket because it is illegal for them to pay below minimum wage. This seems like yet another example of restaurant owners passing higher labor costs onto customers in a less than ethical way. Has anyone else noticed a similar practice?
- xmprt 4y ago> The automatic tip calculations are wrong Wrong implies that there's a right way to tip and that it isn't just a way for employers to get away with paying employees less.
- jaxn 4y agoI suspect most people tip on the after-tax amount when they calculate it themselves. I get that you don’t. I also know people who tip on the non-alcohol amount. Personally, I have always tipped post-tax. These are also low-margin businesses. A post-tax surcharge keeps your overall bill lower than if they had raised prices, which would also raise the tax amount. The high labor costs are going to be passed on to consumers regardless. The surcharge shorts the government (which most of us are probably fine with).
- illumin8 4y agoI always tip on my alcohol purchases, and usually tip 20% regardless of how good or bad the service was. It's mainly because the sales tax is over 10.25% in our county. If the tax were only 5-6% like in most places in the US, it wouldn't be as big of a deal. The food prices are also quite a bit higher here than in most places, but that's just due to cost of living. It is not uncommon to spend $200 to feed a party of 4 even without alcohol, so that tip on the extra $20.50 starts to add up.
- hyperhopper 4y agoThis reads like yet another reason to outlaw tipping and enforce minimum wages for everybody to get rid of tipping culture