7 ms·
Why the infosec community is ahead of the curve and rationalists and nihilists
- adenozine 4y agoNice that they’ve found an even worse method of longform writing than twitter posts tied together. I remember a time when “blog about it” was a pejorative dismissal applied to weird ranting. Now, I think of that phrase except I’m pleading for people to just put the sentences… into paragraphs!
- adolph 4y agoThis is a true comment. MS Word has less pointless computer administrivia. It’s cargo cult as a service.
- quickthrower2 4y agoThat said the site UI could do this for us. It then becomes just a beef on the protocol.
- adenozine 4y agoSure, and to take it further, I could’ve just copy and pasted it myself and not complained at all. It all reduces, but it’s simpler to just have categories of content. And this is a category error of a blog post in tweet form. There’s probably browser extensions for twitter threads already, could be a good starter project for someone to adapt one for fediverse sites.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agoI know. But please: "Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—e.g. article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- adenozine 4y agoPerhaps you should review the definition of tangential. The medium of something is hardly tangential to the self-nature of that thing. We could go more into Kant, but why waste the time? Not that I expect you to (re)consider anything other than the same three links your account spams anytime you see a post that you personally don’t appreciate. Thanks for all you do, you’re truly a marvel.
- dang 4y agoLet's not argue about what 'tangential' means or what Kant said (or McLuhan for that matter). If you can suggest a better word I'm all for it. The point is that these generic-offtopic complaints are extremely repetitive. Maybe the first 1 or 2 (or 17) times one sees them they aren't a big deal, but after that it's bad to be overrun by them like weeds. It's not that they're wrong—rather, precisely because they have a point, they tend to get upvoted, crowding out more interesting/specific conversation. That then leads to complaints about the complaints and god help us. That's why we added that rule. It's a tradeoff between the particular (yes the annoyance exists, yes the comment is valid—I personally agree with it) vs. the general (it's even worse to see these things over and over again, especially at the top of threads). Both are valuable, but only one can prevail and the global optimum is more important. If you really feel strongly about such formats, you should take it up with the people who are choosing to publish this way. Complaining to a link aggregator is like yelling at a photograph. Thanks for the kind words, I think! - but... three links? Also, I protest. The number of HN posts I "personally don't appreciate" is massively greater than the number I reply to. This is an internet forum, after all; I spend my days failing to appreciate things.
- adenozine 4y agoProbably half the people who frequent this website, if not more, are some form of web engineer or at the very least are web-adjacent. It’s a function of UX being a core paradigm of that work that leads to such frequent reflections about a submitted link’s “finer points.” I understand the posts are extremely repetitive, but I’ve not seen a non-regressive attempt to account for this clear and evident desire to discuss this on HN’s part. As far as I know, HN has never tried to have a different comment section for this or other “””offtopic””” discussions, it’s only ever harangued people for talking about it. I was a roofer in my twenties, three decades ago. When you ride around with roofers, you inevitably hear “oh, that one’s a piece of shit. Oh that one’s nice. Oh, they screwed the pooch with that flashing. Oh, that pattern looks great.” It’s part of the trade to reflect on other roofs, and it comes with the territory in most trades, ime, to talk to other tradespeople about best practices. I’ve long thought splitting the comment section into Topic and Offtopic would result in better user experience, as well as tagging posts, being able to mute other users, and a million other features forums had twenty (!) years ago. I already know how desperately HN insists upon itself, but this is my frustration with the moderation surrounding these points. Users have no customization of the experience, they want to talk about the experience, HN says no, of course not.
- quickthrower2 4y agoMaybe the other way round? Infosec has caught up with “social concerns” that, say governments would have been dealing with for centuries especially during wars.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI want to believe this is somewhat accurate given the names dropped in this... tootstorm, but then the more I read it, the more alarm bells went off. The whole thing reads like a tired, old "critique" of a strawman of a group one doesn't like, with a mix of hocus pocus nonsense on top. The last two toots make for a particularly clear example: > Chapman calls this "fluidity", and that's what today's infosec community seems to be in: an acceptance of the coexistence of both "nebulosity" (boundaries are fuzzy, nothing is ever cut and dried, there are no universal truths) and "pattern" (form and structure still exist, things can still be "more or less" X or Y in a certain context). I mean... this "fluidity" is literally what the bayesian stuff is for. Probabilistic reasoning isn't in opposition to "fuzzy boundaries", it's a formalization of it. From this description, "fluidity" isn't something new or superior, it's just informal baby steps in the direction of what later became Bayesian modeling. > the infosec community may be ahead of society at large in understanding change, nuance, and complexity. The world is filled with conflicts over boundaries and meanings. Not if it rejects reason and starts buying into mathematical equivalent of homeopathy. > Some want to impose rigid norms, definitions, and structures on everyone in a flailing attempt to restore certainty and order. It's definitely not those evil rationalists, given how rationalist movement is all about handling uncertainty (with maths!), and insistence on "rigid norms, definitions and structures" is the first thing it makes you unlearn. EDIT: Disclaimer is in order, I suppose - I'm triply biased here, because: 1) I have positive feelings towards the LessWrong flavor of rationality movement as it was in its heyday, and its intellectual contributions; 2) I have negative feelings towards the infosec industry in general, and 3) some years ago I actually worked on an infosec product and tried to add some provably correct probabilistic reasoning capacity to it, and found it to be an uphill battle against corporate and infosec cultures.
- nyolfen 4y agoi agree that it's a bit up its own ass but chapman is definitely worth reading on his own, and his writing is in dialogue with contemporary rationalism; his audience is also mostly rat-adjacent (typically labeled or self-identified 'post-rationalist', which also sounds pretty up its own ass, but so does 'rationalism')
- 4y ago
- mikewarot 4y agoThat's funny... the InfoSec community has no clue about what it takes to actually secure a computer. It was figured out in the 1970s[1], after issues with mixed levels of secret information couldn't be handled quickly in the Viet Nam conflict, and is now mostly forgotten. You can take $5 from your wallet and hand it to a stranger, without needing to trust them with everything in your wallet. You can not take a single file in a folder and hand it to an executable, without needing to trust it with everything on your computer. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multilevel_security https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multilevel_security
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oefrha 4y ago> You can not take a single file in a folder and hand it to an executable You totally can, with macOS and iOS’s sandboxing model.
- mikewarot 4y agoWhile that's an interesting option for the developer, it doesn't appear to be something the end user can use on any random executable. (I'd LOVE to be wrong) As with the Android thread above, this is encouraging news.
- eternityforest 4y ago
- mikewarot 4y agoThe actual video referenced is a hoot[1] A cautionary tale about AI, Technological Manifest Destiny, IoT, and why you shouldn't trust it, ever. His take down of IoT devices is hilarious. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ajGX7odA87k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ajGX7odA87k
- EvanAnderson 4y agoJames Mickens is a treasure. It's well worth your time to seek out anything he has written.
- generated 4y agoAll models are wrong. Some are useful.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mjburgess 4y agoI think one issue, underneath this, is that threats are anti-inductive. Whatever you learn eg., about hacking-X today, will be obsolete tomorrow because X has been patched. You can't do induction (here, I supposed called Bayesianism) nor can you deduce anything since the problem space is intractable. (The system underneath this, of course, is the human animal). There's a new epistemic (, ontological) framework lurking here that has to do with complex systems, anti-induction, the failure of the scientific method (eg., methodological reductionism), and the limits of human knowledge. "Antifragility", complexity theory, chaos etc. get you 70% of the way there. But as this article demonstrates, all that talk still doesn't give us a clear language for, eg., infosec. In my view we're 95% of the way along the S-curve called "scientific knowledge of the reducible world", and nearing an end of the success of the scientific method. Since all open domains now have the characteristics above, and simply, there is no method which produces knowledge in the face of them.
- _glass 4y agoThis is actually why we have in the social sciences the concept of abduction. Finding out something that defies the rules, where new rules have to be created. In deduction, you have a type, and infer the tokens. For induction, you have tokes and infer a type. But for abduction, you have a radically new token, where the type needs to be created. I am pretty sure that the techy infosec community finds out that it's closer to the social sciences.
- mjburgess 4y agoWell all explanation, imv, is abductive. But in scientific abduction, the "types" are properties which obtain invariantly across "the space in which they're located". Eg., water heats the same regardless of where it is, assuming identical other conditions. Whereas if we think of human society (, psychology, threats, etc.) as a space, then properties arent invariant (eg., there's path dependence). Hence, I dont think there is such a thing as a "social science". I think we'd be better of ditching the term science entirely, and scrapping much of the scientific method here. We need a new term, we arent building explanations, but rather ways of coping not having them. A kind of "empirical-speculative coping".
- paganel 4y ago> But we see that societies and systems can work -- sort of -- because we, collectively, with good judgment and sincere effort and appreciation for context and nuance, make them work. In the spirit of this mini-essay, what happens when the centralised "collective we" goes berserk? Or treats some other parts of society as having gone berserk? Also, and partially related to this, I'm surprised that not that many thoughts have been given to the fact that most of the anti-Covid measures, especially in the tech-heavy West (but not only, see also China or Singapore), were in fact pseudo-infosec measures "adapted" to real life. I mean many of us were forced to use our smart-phones plus some dedicated apps just to be let in inside a coffee shop, or a bookstore, or just to take the bus.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoThe issue is that - and the same is true for the IT scene at large - many of the authors are disconnected from reality. It's like Marxian economics: Works great in theory when you're thinking it up all in your mind, sitting at your desk. Math is like that and coding too. Real humans are not machines though and society is immensely complex, with billions of semi-independent highly intelligent actors in different situations and with disparate goals. They are not going to behave the way the average infosec "expert" thinks they will. >I'm surprised that not that many thoughts have been given to the fact that most of the anti-Covid measures, especially in the tech-heavy West (but not only, see also China or Singapore), were in fact pseudo-infosec measures "adapted" to real life Among the advocates we have the aforementioned educated idiot who's not going to bring this up because they don't see the issue to begin with. Then you have those who're pushing it knowing full well what they're doing. The power hungry, the authoritarians, the psychopaths. They may mostly be less tech literate and not good at coding but it doesn't matter because they can get others to built it for them in the name of "security". In principle this isn't new, the pretense of protection has been used as a means of control for a long time. So among the thought leaders we're left with a minority who see the problem because they don't fall in either camp and do not personally profit from such measures, nor find them ethical, but they aren't influential enough to convince the masses. They're outnumbered.
- scandox 4y ago> the infosec community may be ahead of society at large in understanding change, nuance, and complexity. I think almost everyone outside of tech knows all about change, nuance and complexity. And every time they mention it we tell them they're overestimating the unique complexity of their particular situation. Then we prove it by forcing solutions on them that artificially reduce that complexity. And in the end they accept that reduction as a new reality (with some grumbling). I feel sometimes when tech and humanity converge we end up accepting a lowest common denominator rather than accepting that our stuff isn't very good.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>I feel sometimes when tech and humanity converge we end up accepting a lowest common denominator rather than accepting that our stuff isn't very good. Passwords.
- atoav 4y ago> overestimating the unique complexity of their particular situation. Then we prove it by forcing solutions on them that artificially reduce that complexity. As an electrical engineer I have the habit of asking people to explain to me the function of the part they want to remove. Just because it worked briefly without that part does not mean that part did not serve some vital function. How you can tell experts from beginners is that beginners will be pleased with the thing working. Experts will think about weirder edge conditions, thermal cycles, maintainability, safety, security, testability, sustainability, you name it. Don't get me wrong, I love simple, elegant solutions with little (or no) moving parts — they often win out on all of the above. But sometimes the people with the complexity of the domain in mind are right, when they insist that certain elements of a system are needed.
- maxbond 4y agoChesterton's component
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThere's a strong business component here that often seems to be blamed on technologists (at least in discussions in tech and tech-adjacent communities, like here), but really has nothing to do with technology, and is present in every industry. Yes, we like elegant and simple solutions, but "artificially reducing complexity" of the problem to make an elegant and simple solution work is no fun at all. We do it not because it's right or gratifying, but because it's what the business side tells us to, it's what permeates the culture of this and every other industry - of everything in the market economy. We do it because if we don't, our competitors will, and then we'll lose our jobs and won't be able to feed our families anymore. Or, in short: the trend towards "accepting a lowest common denominator rather than accepting that our stuff isn't very good" is caused by market competition itself. After all, the market doesn't know when something is just perfect - there's always a marginal profit to be extracted by repeatedly making it ever so slightly shittier, and competitive pressure ensures you can't move in the opposite direction.
- saagarjha 4y agoI find that infosec people are typically pretty bad at understanding how the world works, because they often think that people and processes work like computers and can be hacked or gamed around, and that’s not really how the real world works. The post talks about “fluidity” but a lot of things that people come up fail to account for the fact that e.g. public opinion or people with guns can subvert the thing they’re trying to do pretty effectively. It’s good to have a mindset where you’re able to think beyond traditional threats but I think it’s really odd how this often leads to a sort of blindness to things outside of whatever scope you think is the novel or clever way of looking at things.
- Havoc 4y agoWhile intellectually interesting I don’t think it’s particularly helpful in any sort of practical context.