7 ms·
The global village is basically here, courtesy of social media like TikTok (which did not come from California). What we didn't expect was that the village idio
by zozbot234 4y ago
The global village is basically here, courtesy of social media like TikTok (which did not come from California). What we didn't expect was that the village idiots would also come along.
- donatj 4y agoAnd that the loudest village idiots get the most attention.
- quickthrower2 4y agoAnd there are training courses on being a village idiot so you can be heard too!
- stjohnswarts 4y agoSurely you aren't referring to all the "how to become an influencer" courses?
- danrocks 4y agoYes, and don’t call me Shirley
- intelVISA 4y agoAgile methodology(tm)
- seydor 4y agoTiktok is a specific kind of entertainment, nothing more, and hardly a medium to debate ideas. Maybe twitter is a more engaged kind of crowd but there too, the people making the loudest voice get preferential treatment. But certainly the global village does exist and this podcast is even a good example of it.
- gsatic 4y agoWhat type of villagers have contempt for the village idiots?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- didericis 4y agoSome of us did expect that. The initial techno optimism about global connectivity that I think really picked up during the 90s (all of this was before my time, correct me if I'm wrong about timing) always seemed doomed to this particular end given the lack of segmentation. You can't have a village with 8 billion people. I distinctly remember a period when the iPhone came out and the high score leaderboards for certain apps went from like a couple thousand to tens of thousands to like a million. I realized this kind of connectivity is going to select for a tiny percentage of hyper competitive winners. Those people are mixed in with billions of people not used to operating in that kind of a space. More and more people are being forced into a competition they don't really want to be a part of. The rooms are way too big and way too flat to allow for proper self selection and sorting into like minded peer groups at similar levels. They make 99% of people miserable, including many of those at the top who need to work ungodly hard to maintain positions that used to be more secure due to less global exposure. What you can do is create a village of about 200 people and their networks with a much more interesting and larger set of like minded people than what your geography limits you to, and self select and bypass gatekeepers to create new and emergent communities beyond anything people might have dreamed or expected. But that requires a kind of community maintenance and segmentation that we haven't figured out how to do yet.
- asdff 4y agoI think what makes technology so hard to be optimistic about is that there are two sides of the coin. There is the side that this is a utility for our species, that tech should exist to serve us better, that things should get more efficient and take less time. That side exists entirely in opposition to the other side of the coin, that is most likely to win out as its the more profitable side. That is the side that tech is merely a product to be marketed like any other, that it should further a profitable status quo versus introduce something new that might not be as profitable, that taking up more users time is more profitable because you can monetize more of it, etc. All the incentives of our society, are aligned to give us a lot more of the latter sort of products, and not much of the former. Imagine if the wheel were invented today; how many times will a dozen companies have reinvented it in ten years time trying to get around the patent, each with their own patentable twists to the idea? I don't believe this sort of thinking can be sustainable for long.
- Apocryphon 4y agoWho's more idiotic? The village idiot, or the idiot who forgot about Eternal September?
- version_five 4y agoWith the utmost respect, the above post is ironic because it's exactly the sort of shallow, snappy internet post (I make them too) that's the opposite of what good "public square" social media discourse should look like, and it ends up as the top post. It's the incentive structure that's inherent in social media that means it's doomed to fail as a method of intelligent discussion from day 1. Maybe this is what "the medium is the message" means, I never really understood it.
- zozbot234 4y agoIn my view a terse, mildly irritated comment is an entirely appropriate response to the sort of aimless rambling we see in pieces like the OP. I'm sympathetic to those who think a "public square" should strive for a good balance, but length is just not a meaningful correlate to "intelligent discussion".
- scyzoryk_xyz 4y agoHistorically „public squares” are used for lots of things - trade, speech, politics, taxes, faires, revolutions and public executions all come to mind. The square usually remains unchanged even as people do all sorts of things. If that’s what we take that phrase for, then anything goes - both mildly irritated comments and aimless rambling pieces. Moderation too.
- ryandrake 4y agoBrevity is the soul of wit. We all have a limited amount of time. For most topics, I'd rather read a quick, witty "hot take" than a longform article or an exhaustively comprehensive academic paper, even if those forms contain the details and nuance required to fully understand the topic.
- nine_k 4y agoI'll take a proper academic paper because it ought to have an abstract in the beginning with the compressed summary. Long-form articles rarely do that.
- aaron695 4y agoTikTok is popular because it brought back humans, and importantly nice humans to the Internet. > was that the village idiots would also come along An example of a village idiot would be someone with Down syndrome, I couldn't say I see it more or less than real life on TikTok. I think that's complex, we didn't handle that well in the past, we don't handle it well now but it's still orders of magnitude better. TikTok is more human than anything else, unlike Instagram for instance, but it's still an escape from the real world. It's not fair to expect it to be reality, we have reality for that. Just be happy it's non-toxic.
- csdvrx 4y agoVouched for your comment because it's spot on. It's for gold nuggets like that I'm happy there's the showdead option! If there are indeed "idots" in society in a sense that they have physical or mental problems, I think looking down on them is wrong. But I really wonder if there are "idots" at all. What's most likely is that tech people are angry that non tech people have different tastes and preferences, and by virtue of being a larger group, have the market cater to them. However, who's to say that for example teaching is more important than the NBA? TikTok success should be a cause of celebration, as it means people with different tastes that weren't served by the market, now have an offering that makes them happy. If you don't like it, don't participate. I don't like cellphones, so I don't operate one. Yet the few times I've had a friend show me funny stuff from TikTok I've been legitimately happy for them. "De Gustibus Non Est Disputandum". EDIT: BTW I checked your other comments, you don't bother with the niceties and speak your mind. And you are a goldmine! I especially loved the great content you gather about IQ and theory of the mind on https://i.redd.it/i1ywg8dajac71.png https://i.redd.it/i1ywg8dajac71.png
- zozbot234 4y agoThe biggest problem with the content you link is that it was gathered from convicts. Why would you assume that they'd care about looking smart to some random researcher? Also the way I.Q. scoring works, there's roughly as many people with <90 I.Q. as >110 I.Q. and so on. Even assuming that these accounts are true, they're likely heavily influenced by that environment.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoTikTok? Try AOL. Eternal September has the name it does for a reason.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoYou just have to internalize social realism. Intelligent discourse is a losing proposition. In the social market, whatever captures people's interest _is_ definitionally speaking the most important social thing. If intelligent discourse isn't capturing social attention then it's not socially valuable. This shouldn't be news to anyone familiar with Society of the Spectacle. If you want sorcery over the spectacle, there are much better ways than pining for intelligent discourse.
- nine_k 4y ago"Most important" and "most captivating" are not exactly the same things, because people's attention is imperfect. Hence the ability to play the meta game, to capture and direct mass attention, is what remains the most efficacious skill, as it has been for centuries, if not millennia. Sadly, it is rarely used to direct the social attention towards a more intelligent discourse.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bjornsing 4y ago> What we didn't expect was that the village idiots would also come along. And that there would be so many of them.