6 ms·
You basically want reality to be simple? Well, it isn't. How about denying megaphones to the hysterical fringes?
by marcosdumay 4y ago
You basically want reality to be simple? Well, it isn't.
How about denying megaphones to the hysterical fringes?
- ceejayoz 4y ago"Don't let children work in sweatshops" and "let women vote" were once the "hysterical fringes" of public policy. There's often a benefit to exploring the edges of the Overton window.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoEugenics was controversial too. What's your point? No naive rules of thumb like "well if the public health experts like it then it must be good" or "bigger overton window = better" will ever come close to being a viable replacement for critical thinking on any specific policy matter. If the extreme fringes can't convert people to their cause then is their cause really that worthy?
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Eugenics was controversial too. What's your point? Eugenics is fringe now. It wasn't in the early 1900s. The point is that "no megaphones for the fringe" can also be a bad thing.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoEugenics absolutely was fringe in the early 1900s. To claim otherwise is revisionist. The fact that they got as far as they did, even passing laws in some states, is testament to what happens when people outsource their thinking to the experts and the experts engaged in extreme policy not supported by the people. Make no mistake, the policy would have worked but the end did not justify the means outside of the circle jerk in which the "experts" and were living. The fact that the fringe was unable to convert the broader public is why the overwhelming majority of eugenics policy was unilaterally adopted by institutions (government or otherwise) vs being legislated by politicians and that's because people didn't really want it en-masse.
- ceejayoz 4y agoCan you perhaps elaborate on your definition of "fringe"? "Official policy of 30+ states and upheld by SCOTUS" doesn't fit mine.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoEugenics came and went over the careers timeline of the people who peddled it (as most of these policy fads do). At best it was tolerated by the uninvolved masses. Things like women voting, gay rights, etc. managed to persist after the people who staked their careers on it and would be compelled to peddle it croaked. Eugenics failed to convert the masses (good). That official policy of what you speak is just that, unilateral policy by various government institutions (usually prison systems and public health institutions). Most states didn't manage to get it through the legislature in any meaningful capacity because it was not something the masses cared for and therefore not something that a politician could earn votes peddling. It was as endorsed by the masses as some DOT policy about pothole patching would be.
- actionfromafar 4y agoPothole fixing is very mainstream, I'd say. Eugenics got a bad reputation because of a certain moustachioed leader in Germany.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoYou don’t think the outcome of WWII might have changed minds and hearts instead? Most literature I’ve read was eugenics became deeply unpopular following a realization of what the Nazis had done.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoDo you have any references that support this lack of support? Everything I have ever read points to a general acceptance as being a modern and scientific theory if not a direct moral imperative at that time. It wasn’t until the results of WWII were unpacked and civil rights debated was it really revisited on a humanist basis. I would be genuinely glad to read material that refutes this.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt’s not fringe now. E.g. there are essentially no children with downs born in Denmark due to sex selective abortions.
- hutzlibu 4y agoObviously children should not work in sweatshops and rather go to school instead, but do good numbers exist, that the "hysterical" campaigns increased those numbers and not just put the kids on the street to do scavenging on toxic dumbsters? Well intended is not always well done and hystery is seldom helping. I remember from my youth(in germany), that work for kids was also forbidden. With some exceptions like delivering advertisement to every door. The result was, that this was a very shitty job, very badly paid (you were replaceble) and the ones illegally working for the bike shed for example, made way more money.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> do good numbers exist, that the "hysterical" campaigns increased those numbers and not just put the kids on the street to do scavenging on toxic dumbsters? So let me get this straight your hypothesis is that campaign to get kids out of sweatshops were harmfull, and the reason we stopped putting them insweatshops is not public pressure but spontanous mass enlightenment? Maybe it is your perception of these campaignes as hysterical thats wrong.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"So let me get this straight your hypothesis is that campaign to get kids out of sweatshops were harmful" My hypothesis is, that just banning kids working in sweatshop is not enough to improve living conditions for those kids, but can in fact worsen them. So I repeat my question, do you have good numbers, that the living conditions actually improved? Hysteric campaigns from the west often stop exactly there - so the companies can place a label on their product that says free of child labour, but it does not say at all, where those kids are now, but the consumers now feel better.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoDo you have good numbers that being polite, reasonable and timid activism will get large corporations to give up billions in profits to please you? We've had 26 climate change conferences, the issue was known for 40 years, nobody gave a flying fuck. Some kids blocked traffic in London for 1 day, and suddenly people paid attention. How are you going to solve Nestle level of indignity and inhumanity? "Nestlé admits slavery in Thailand while fighting child labour lawsuit in Ivory Coast" If people were more hysterical, and the HQ of offending corporation burned down occasionally, then Nestle would sort itself out prompto
- marcosdumay 4y agoIf they were fringe, those changes would never have happened. It's not like people ever had as much leverage for hysteria as they have now. You are not exploring the edges of the Overton window when you drown balanced speech. That just creates multimodal extremism.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> If they were fringe, those changes would never have happened. They were initially fringe. Activism by that initial fringe is what made it mainstream.
- ldh0011 4y agoThe implication of your first claim seems to be that fringe opinions would never become mainstream in society. I think essentially all of human history contradicts that pretty well...
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> How about denying megaphones to the hysterical fringes? Do you think it is an accident that, when there is a popular movement, whether it is punk rock or protests against vietanm war, the media will invite the most crazy person possible and portray them as maniacs?
- marcosdumay 4y agoI guess you have just understood what I am talking about. If the media is intend on lying and mass manipulation, that media exactly should not have the support of well meaning people.
- Jimmc414 4y agoMaybe it would be wise to try to understand why they are hysterical before you take away their voice.
- _Algernon_ 4y ago>How about denying megaphones to the hysterical fringes? Most megaphones today are in the hands of private corporations who profit off of "engagement", that is, giving megaphones to the fringes. How do you suppose we do that? Not to mention that the line between not providing a megaphone and suppressing free speech is a thin one.