4 ms·
Any widespread message must be simple. Even a moderate, sane movement will have hysteria on the fringes, just owing to it being large enough to have a fringe.
by actionfromafar 4y ago
Any widespread message must be simple. Even a moderate, sane movement will have hysteria on the fringes, just owing to it being large enough to have a fringe.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoSo then why is HN, a community full of people who are much more educated than average and much more frequently employed in fields where logic and reason are key, so constantly receptive to the "hysteria on the fringes" take on such issues? Reddit, 4cham, other cesspools like that I get, but why HN? This community fancies itself as having a little more rationality and self awareness than that. So either there's an explanation for why those takes gain as much traction here or... (this is a serious question)
- saiya-jin 4y agoSmarter people on average != less emotional ones. What parent is complaining are emotional reactions. Here we have a proof that even HN readers do have emotions and sometimes they get the best and worst out of us, just like everybody else.
- moffkalast 4y agoWell it's not like HN is a council of Vulcans debating logic all day, we're all as human as the next guy.
- giantg2 4y agoSpeak for yourself
- moffkalast 4y agoWell it's not like I'm a council of Vulcans debating logic all day.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> fields where logic and reason are key, so constantly receptive to the "hysteria on the fringes" take on such issues? Many on HK has emotional intelligence id an edgy highschool student, plus often they live in a buble. This leads to poor grasp of social issues. 'Average' places like reddit are actually better in this regard.
- gruez 4y ago>'Average' places like reddit are actually better in this regard. That might be true in that niche subreddit you subscribe to, but it's clearly not true for /r/all.
- Brybry 4y agoIs more education and being employed in a field of logic and reason likely to make one less receptive to fringe beliefs? For example, engineers are probably overrepresented amongst Islamic extremists[1] and, from what few studies there are, may be skewed conservative and religious compared to other higher education fields. [1] https://eprints.lse.ac.uk/29836/1/Why_are_there_so_many_Engineers_among_Islamic_radicals_%28publisher%29.pdf https://eprints.lse.ac.uk/29836/1/Why_are_there_so_many_Engi...
- marcosdumay 4y agoYou basically want reality to be simple? Well, it isn't. How about denying megaphones to the hysterical fringes?
- ceejayoz 4y ago"Don't let children work in sweatshops" and "let women vote" were once the "hysterical fringes" of public policy. There's often a benefit to exploring the edges of the Overton window.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoEugenics was controversial too. What's your point? No naive rules of thumb like "well if the public health experts like it then it must be good" or "bigger overton window = better" will ever come close to being a viable replacement for critical thinking on any specific policy matter. If the extreme fringes can't convert people to their cause then is their cause really that worthy?
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Eugenics was controversial too. What's your point? Eugenics is fringe now. It wasn't in the early 1900s. The point is that "no megaphones for the fringe" can also be a bad thing.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoEugenics absolutely was fringe in the early 1900s. To claim otherwise is revisionist. The fact that they got as far as they did, even passing laws in some states, is testament to what happens when people outsource their thinking to the experts and the experts engaged in extreme policy not supported by the people. Make no mistake, the policy would have worked but the end did not justify the means outside of the circle jerk in which the "experts" and were living. The fact that the fringe was unable to convert the broader public is why the overwhelming majority of eugenics policy was unilaterally adopted by institutions (government or otherwise) vs being legislated by politicians and that's because people didn't really want it en-masse.
- specialist 4y agoYes and: Message simplicity, discipline, and repetition, to maybe somewhat mitigate the inevitable and very effective nutpicking by corporate media (and other shills) for the purpose of discrediting any reform, accountability, etc. -- "The practice of sifting through the comments of blogs, email threads, discussion groups and other user generated content in an attempt find choice quotes proving that the advocates for or against a particular political opinion are unreasonable, uninformed extremists." https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=nutpicking https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=nutpicking
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoEvery person that has ever fought for improvement p of any kind, against power, was accused of extremist or worse, terrorism. If you weren't, you never made enoufg waves to be noticed.
- kshahkshah 4y agoIs that empirically the case? Maybe in the marketing world but policy tends to get debated with more vigor. From my view 'defund the police' seems to have severely backfired.