2 ms·
Healthcare can't be fixed. We are headed over a demographic cliff with an aging population and an increasing incidence of chronic metabolic diseases caused by l
by nradov 4y ago
Healthcare can't be fixed. We are headed over a demographic cliff with an aging population and an increasing incidence of chronic metabolic diseases caused by lifestyle factors. Those patients have effectively infinite demand for healthcare. Switching to a single-payer system or nationalizing provider organizations or whatever won't fix the root cause. So, we are going to end up with longer queues, lower service quality, and more explicit rationing no matter what we do.
If we want to maintain a high-quality healthcare system, then the only option will be to reduce demand through incentivizing people to make healthier lifestyle choices. That will require sweeping, systemic changes and may not be politically feasible.
- cudgy 4y agoChanging the world’s behavior is the most feasible solution? That seems like the least feasible solution. Also, what good is a high quality healthcare system if it is only accessible to a fraction of society?
- wizofaus 4y agoI'd think COVID demonstrated that people's behaviour at a society-wide scale can be changed surprisingly easily.
- nradov 4y agoI didn't claim that changing the world's behavior is feasible. It may not be. But given the horrific human cost of having so many people become obese and diabetic I think we ought to try. What's the alternative? It's not going to be politically or economically practical to devote a larger share of GDP to healthcare, and minor improvements from increasing automation or reducing waste won't be sufficient.
- midoridensha 4y agoOver here in reality, other countries with even more aging populations have little trouble providing good healthcare for everyone at reasonable cost. The problem in the US isn't old people, it's a horribly-designed system.
- nradov 4y agoThose other countries are generally heading for the same care delivery and quality problems as the US. It's just that the US is on the leading edge of the wave because our population is sicker and thus the problems show up here first. To get a sense of what's happening in other countries look at metrics like 5-year cancer survival rates or wait times for joint replacement surgery.