3 ms·
Become poorer, more religious, and get people to work less. I don't believe there's any examples of modern countries doing it. Providing lots of childcare bene
by astrange 4y ago
Become poorer, more religious, and get people to work less.
I don't believe there's any examples of modern countries doing it. Providing lots of childcare benefits doesn't seem to help, though it does make the children you do get healthier.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoChildcare benefits don't work for the same reason steep prison sentences don't work. Nobody does a cost benefit analysis of "years lost"/"benefit of murdering someone". I'm sure there is a positive correlation with "home ownership, and low debt" with children however. Because that would make you feel secure about your future.
- satvikpendem 4y agoMaybe not true for criminals, but many people don't have kids precisely because they did a cost benefit analysis on having them and decided it was too expensive to do so.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat correlation is due to people doing the cost benefit analysis. Do I want to deal with the costs of raising a child in an apartment? Do I want my child to bear the costs of having to change schools? Do I want my child and I to bear the costs of losing income while still paying lots of education/auto/home debt? Unfortunately, at some point the benefits to not having a child at the individual level become costs at the societal level once enough opt out, and that becomes costs again at the individual level, on a sufficiently long timeline. Of course, these net costs/benefits can flip from being costs at 10 years to benefits at 30 years and back to costs at 150 years. Maybe excess population leads to excess resource consumption and entropy generation. Maybe some of the excess population figures out how to mitigate excess consumption, and buys a little more time. Who knows?
- walkhour 4y agoIncidentally what Afghanistan has done, with the claim that it will raise the birth rate. Women are banned from universities.
- rayiner 4y agoMore religious yes, but not necessarily meaningfully “poorer” (at least not if the goal is a sustainable TFR). France and the US had birth rates around 2 as recently as the early aughts. Two big issues are probably the cost of housing, and educational credential inflation. Young people these days spend four years in college, and concomitantly postpone establishing their real lives by four years, just to get the kind of office jobs prior generations got with a high school diploma.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoI would say it’s not just the cost of housing, but cost of (good) childcare in general. Children are massively financially costly… daycare, clothing, food, medical care, education, etc. They’re expensive in terms of time too, and parents are practically always short on time due to needing dual incomes to be able to pay the bills without constantly sitting on the edge. So realistically, I think that what all this means is that an economy can’t have its cake and eat it too; its workforce can work itself to death or it can have kids at replacement rate, not both. Polls have shown that young people are no less interested in starting families than they were in decades past. It’s simply not responsible to do so in the case of an increasing number of couples’ situations, and so they don’t. The only way to turn this trend around is to pay actual living wages and mandate a better work-life balance on a national scale.
- Aeolun 4y ago> Children are massively financially costly… daycare, clothing, food, medical care, education, etc. Except Japan has made nearly all of this absolutely free. So the financial cost argument falls a bit flat.
- midoridensha 4y agoHuh? Where did you get this idea? Daycare, clothing, food, medicine, and education are not free in Japan. They're mostly not as horrifically expensive as in America, but definitely not free.
- 4y ago
- hotpotamus 4y agoI believe Israel is generally held up as an example of one modern country that has raised its birthrate.
- twelve40 4y agomore like kept it from sliding in the last few decades, but yes, still pretty high, and it's an achievement. They were also helped by having a very young population to begin with (just look at that perfect age pyramid), and the whole country currently has population of Nagoya metro area, Japan is much bigger and harder to change.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoDoes not look like a meaningful increase, and I wonder what the stats look like without the fertility rate of the Haredi group. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/ISR/israel/fertility-rate https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/ISR/israel/fertility-r... https://www.jns.org/israeli-birth-rate-on-decline-government-data-shows/ https://www.jns.org/israeli-birth-rate-on-decline-government... >The Jewish fertility rate surpassed the Arab rate for the first time in 2020, with Jews having three children on average compared to 2.99 in the Arab sector. >At 6.64 children per woman, haredi women had the highest fertility rate among Israel’s Jewish population, compared to 1.96 among secular Jewish women. Looks close enough to women not belonging to super religious groups in other developed countries.
- hotpotamus 4y agoI've never understood statements to the effect of, "if you take out the group causing the effect, then the effect is no longer present". I remember discussing a buggy application once with another engineer (I could reliably crash the server with a mis-configuration on the client), and I was taking a fairly apologetic stance that after all the workarounds I had to make it work, it worked OK. His response was, "yeah, if you take out all the parts that suck, then it doesn't suck". And now I can never unhear that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]