12 ms·
Something I find fascinating is how a game can have a… I dunno… “Viability Curve” that isn’t just a line. For example, my kids rarely draw in Tic Tac Toe. At t
by Waterluvian 4y ago
Something I find fascinating is how a game can have a… I dunno… “Viability Curve” that isn’t just a line.
For example, my kids rarely draw in Tic Tac Toe. At their skill level, it’s a very winnable game and therefore fun game and therefore viable game. But it’s not even a viable game for two adults who have studied it for a bit. All draws all the time.
Less expert players of chess also don’t draw often. The game is sufficiently complex where practiced adults still win and lose a lot.
But then you get to grand masters and draws become common. The game, as designed, seemingly becomes less “viable.”
But I’m curious if there’s a U-shaped game out there: viable for beginners, viable for experts, tedious for intermediates.
- hapidjus 4y agoBackgammon perhaps
- adenozine 4y agoPoker definitely seems to fit the bill here. There’s a lot of half decent players who never seem to stay up for long or for very much. Might have less to do with the game and more to do with play style and discipline, though.
- ralfd 4y ago> But then you get to grand masters and draws become common. The game, as designed, seemingly becomes less “viable.” This is why Blizz/Rapid got popular in the chess world. Btw: Magnus Carlsen has a life time win rate of 42%, draw rate 42% and losses at 15% https://www.365chess.com/players/Magnus_Carlsen https://www.365chess.com/players/Magnus_Carlsen
- ipv4dhcp 4y agomagic the gathering? or perhaps really most trading card 'games'.
- atdrummond 4y agoI’d say many “grind” games today, such as Valorant, League of Legends, etc fit that U-shape as described. You get hooked with a fun game in the early weeks, then become addicted - while no longer enjoying the game nearly as much - as you futilely attempt to reach the upper echelons, where fame and glory (supposedly) await you.