5 ms·
This is why high deductible insurance offers the best hope for cost control. Too bad it becomes illegal in 2014.
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
This is why high deductible insurance offers the best hope for cost control.
Too bad it becomes illegal in 2014.
- _delirium 15y agoIt depends on what you mean by "high deductible", but the Affordable Care Act specifically includes a circa-$6000 deductible option that would satisfy the individual mandate. See: http://www.kff.org/pullingittogether/What-Conservatives-Won-In-Health-Reform.cfm http://www.kff.org/pullingittogether/What-Conservatives-Won-...
- yummyfajitas 15y agoFirst dollar coverage of many things is mandated by the ACA. It's not clear yet which things (HHS and other agencies need to first "recommend" the required services), but first dollar coverage is mandated. http://www.healthcare.gov/law/resources/regulations/prevention/regs.html http://www.healthcare.gov/law/resources/regulations/preventi... The fact that high deductible coverage may be possible for the non-"recommended" chunk of services is a good thing, however. (I say "may be possible" since 3 actuarial firms couldn't read the law and come to an agreement on what it says.)
- skurry 15y agoCurrently, every plan I've come across also covers preventive care (immunizations, cancer screenings etc.), because insurance companies realize that this saves them money in the long run. The ACA just standardizes and regulates this. This is actually in the interest of the consumer, because every plan has to have a common set of preventive care services it has to provide for free, which makes plans much easier to compare.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- yardie 15y agoI think it only delays the inevitable and ends up making things worse. If people don't have the money for surgery (and really how many of us can pull ou $5000, right no). They'll delay it. Delay it too long and that $4000 surgery becomes a $50000 intensive care, emergency operation.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe RAND experiment disagrees with you. It shows that cost sharing induces people to use 30% less medicine with no significant effects on health. http://www.rand.org/health/projects/hie.html http://www.rand.org/health/projects/hie.html Unfortunately, we never repeated the rand experiment, so it's a bit dated. For some reason we never tried repeating it before pushing massive changes in the law.
- afterburner 15y agoDid they use 30% less surgery too?
- _delirium 15y ago"No significant effects on health" isn't entirely accurate; the "average" participant had no negative effects on health, but several of the subgroups did, mainly poor people with chronic conditions who had better compliance with treatment regimens, and better outcomes, in the free-care case. Here's the abstract: http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM198312083092305 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM198312083092305
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI'm familiar with this paper. Unfortunately it's deeply flawed. The RAND health experiment studied 30 measures of health. Two of them were statistically significantly improved - vision (due to free eyeglasses, p=0.001) and blood pressure (p=0.03). Simple math shows that 0.97 ^ 30 = 0.4. This means that the RAND experiment had a 60% chance of showing an effect in at least one particular submeasure even if there was no effect in any of them. (The result on eyeglasses is strong enough to avoid this effect, however. So we can conclude that free glasses help people see better.)
- afterburner 15y ago"Too bad"? You like thinking about a $5000 bill when you're headed to the OR, perhaps straight from the ER? You think this is feasible for the vast majority of people?
- tomjen3 15y agoYes, because you have that amount in HSA. That is the entire point of the high deductible.
- afterburner 15y agoSounds like it's still your money being spent. Do poor Americans typically have HSAs? Could people afford multiple hits? Where does the money come from after the HSA has run out?
- ipince 15y agoOf course its still your money being spent (though you get some tax benefits). People should be able to afford one deductible per year. Not sure what you mean by multiple hits. I agree with yummyfajitas, but bottom line is, you should only get a high deductible plan if you can afford it. Thinking about a 5k bill as you head to the ER shouldn't be a problem then. If you can't afford it, d;not get it. Of course, therein lies the problem: people who can't afford it choose it because its the cheapest. Its a problem, but banning high deductible plans for everyone is certainly NOT the solution.
- afterburner 15y agoMultiple hits meaning more surgeries per period that the savings can be refilled. Like, say, if you get into a major accident requiring multiple surgeries, or get a condition that requires multiple surgeries or extensive treatment. People can get seriously ill, not just "average" sick.
- tomjen3 15y ago
- astrodust 15y agoHow does that help anyone in any way?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIt creates a downward pressure on health care costs.
- astrodust 15y agoIn what hypothetical world? It sounds like the hospitals in the US couldn't care less how much they charge people since they'll just sue you into oblivion if you don't pay. What's the difference between a $1K deductible and a $10K one? How's that going to make one bit of difference? Consumers have no say in how much the procedures cost. There's no "price pressure" from anyone but the group buyers, those being the insurance companies and Medicare.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIn what hypothetical world? In the world joezydeco lives in. Apparently high deductible plans have already caused hospitals to change their procedures. Consumers have no say in how much the procedures cost. Consumers now have an incentive to shop around or try alternate treatments. With a low deductible plan, their only incentive is to find the doctor they like the best or the hospital closest to their house.
- georgieporgie 15y agoConsumers now have an incentive to shop around or try alternate treatments. When I'm rushed to the hospital after a taxi runs me down on my motorcycle, I'm not in a position to shop around. When I'm sick with a flu and subsequent sinus infection, barely able to perform basic daily tasks without mental exhaustion, I'm in no position to shop around. The wannabe-libertarian ideal doesn't work for healthcare.