4 ms·
>What makes it so that Asians are underrepresented, Their physique. Fact of the matter is, black peoples' bodies are far more suited for strenuous physical ac
by Dalewyn 4y ago
>What makes it so that Asians are underrepresented,
Their physique.
Fact of the matter is, black peoples' bodies are far more suited for strenuous physical activities than asians'. For the NBA specifically, the average height of blacks compared to that of asians is a significant factor; the taller you are the more advantageous you will be.
For a more in-depth example, over in Japan (note: I'm Japanese-American) athletes who have some foreign blood in them tend to perform better in sports compared to 100% Japanese athletes. Not to mention 100% foreigners who moved to Japan who will, in general, perform better than anyone with Japanese blood.
The reality is asians aren't as physically capable as other races, generally speaking.
>and would the games be more interesting if these causes were addressed ?
No. I think I speak for the majority when I say we watch sports matches to spectate top-of-the-class athletes doing their best, regardless who or what they are.
If there are obvious diversity quota players in the mix, that would /reduce/ the overall fun and interest because the sport stops being about the best athletes performing their best.
- di456 4y agoDepends on the sport. Table tennis?
- Dalewyn 4y agoI'm not at all familiar with the finer points of table tennis, but I would presume any race predispositioned to more stamina would have an easier time in general.
- jwond 4y ago> black peoples' bodies are far more suited for strenuous physical activities than asians' > […] > The reality is asians aren't as physically capable as other races, generally speaking. Do you apply similar logic to explain why black people are underrepresented in technical fields while Asian people are over-represented? Would you say that Asian peoples’ minds are “far more suited” for strenuous intellectual activities than black peoples’?
- kesor 4y agoI wouldn't say they are less intellectually capable. But the number of black people who grow up in an environment of computers, engineering, etc... is much much lower than the comparable number of white or asian young men who grow up in such environments. This is also the reason why there are far few women software engineers than men. It is not about their capabilities, physical, intellectual or otherwise. It is about their environment where they grow up in - some people grow up with programming computers from very early age because their parents do something similar, most of these (by a wide margin) are white or asian boys.
- zztop44 4y agoBut most early computer programmers were women. If it’s just the environment they grew up in, then why did programming computers shift over the 20th century from being a job dominated by women to a job dominated by men? For the record, I also don’t think it’s about “differences in capabilities”. I think that amongst other things, as personal computing came of age different types of men became attracted to computing, and changed the culture around computing to one which excluded women (in most cases probably unintentionally). If that’s true, there might be parallels with the software industry today and race.
- gruez 4y ago> But most early computer programmers were women. If it’s just the environment they grew up in, then why did programming computers shift over the 20th century from being a job dominated by women to a job dominated by men? Early computer "programmers" were doing something more akin to data entry than churning out CRUD apps using the latest js framework. Comparing the programming jobs of the 70s or whatever to the jobs today therefore makes little sense.
- kesor 4y agoEarly "computers" were also women. Because the engineering work was done by men and the computational "menial work" was done by women. These same women were replaced by digital computers later on, and some of these women felt "at home" with the new medium since they had better familiarity with what is going on in there than men did. But that was the 60s and 70s, and the women at the time were in their 20s and 30s. Many of those women remained "computers" and did not go into "engineers", and there is a big difference between the two. A computer is great at solving equations and doing the menial work of data calculation, similar to what we use spreadsheets for today. Engineers on the other hand is a more creative approach to problem solving, when presented with various problems (not just of math) that need some solutions, an engineer would try and find that solution by being creative. About 20-30 years ago, there was a large population of engineers around the world who are the parents of today's engineers who are 20-30yo right now. Those engineers were white men, and women, and asian men and women. Not many of them were black families, so today's 20-30yo black men (and women) are not only a small portion of the world population, they are also heavily underrepresented in engineering. That is not to say they are incapable, as I mentioned above, it is more influenced by the "environment" where these people grew up in. Also, early women programmers does not mean that today's women had the same upbringing and attraction to the same professions as the women in the 60s and 70s. Back then being a "computer" was similar to being a secretary, it involved a lot of menial work and precision. Today's secretaries might be required to be good with spreadsheets and document writing software, quite a leap away from programming. The above are generalizations, since there are absolutely definitely amazing women software engineers today, as well as black men software engineers. It is just that they are barely a minority in the software engineering industry, there are just very few of them - which makes sense why the software engineering jobs don't have any significant representation of these people working there.
- FeistySkink 4y agoDo you have some data to back any of this up? I feel that reducing the wast amount of people to a single variable based on skin color, doesn't add up. Even from my completely uneducated perspective I couldn't generalize people from different parts of Africa, let alone other places.
- CMCDragonkai 4y agoYou picked one ethnicity "Japanese" to represent all "Asians". Regardless of the veracity of your claim, Japanese physiques don't represent all Asian physiques. And even Chinese historical records often mentioned who short the Japanese were.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI did say the Japan example is an "in-depth" example rather than a general one, so it would not necessarily apply to other asian locales. I merely used Japan because I'm actually qualified to talk about them with some degree of specificity, and the rest of the comment is hopefully written in a more generalized manner.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> we watch sports matches to spectate top-of-the-class athletes doing their best, regardless who or what they are. Then wouldn’t be more interesting if a variety of players with different top-of-the-class physical profiles moved the game through strategies optimized to their strengths and weaknesses ? To take a concrete example, the addition of the 3 point rule expanded the category of players that could have a critical impact on the game. I personally wouldn’t see that rule addition as a dilution of the game or a pandering to physical diversity, it genuinely makes the games more interesting. We could imagine other rules that bring in even wider physical profiles and change the game in interesting ways.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI watch sports to see athletes performing their best; I couldn't give a rat's rotten ass what they are. As such, diversity quotas would not be appealing to my interests and demands in the first place. I /don't fucking care/ what they are, I care if they are good athletes. If a sport presents me with diversity hires, I'm just going to go watch or do something else.
- makeitdouble 4y agoYou’re still focusing on quotas. The original article might be tangent to affirmative action, but that’s not what this thread is about.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI was originally responding to an inquiry by another commenter, not the article.
- nradov 4y agoThe other side of that is that there are sometimes opportunities to innovate within the existing rules that no one else is exploiting. For example, Boyd Epley revolutionized the whole game of gridiron football when he introduced a rigorous strength training program to the Nebraska Cornhuskers. https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/13175331/how-former-pole-vaulter-sparked-college-football-training-revolution https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/13175331/ho...
- RestlessMind 4y ago> The reality is asians aren't as physically capable as other races, generally speaking. What about baseball then? MLB has only 3% asians[1]. However, asians have demonstrated excellence at a very similar sport (Cricket), so physique should not matter. [1] https://routine.com/blogs/press-box/mlb-player-demographics https://routine.com/blogs/press-box/mlb-player-demographics
- Dalewyn 4y agoDisclaimer: I'm only intimately familiar with America's and Japan's baseball scenes. That comes down to MLB play being on an entirely different plane of existence from Japanese (and I would presume other asian locales') professional league baseball. Japan has two of their own professional leagues, and a handful of players manage to move over to the MLB in their careers. But only a handful make it, because the minimum skill and performance levels demanded by the MLB are several orders of magnitudes higher than Japan's leagues. This isn't about racism nor discrimination, the reality is the vast majority of Japanese baseball players simply don't make the cut for MLB. Players like Nomo, Ichiro, and Ohtani were among the cream of the crop in Japan's baseball leagues when they moved to the MLB. They make it all look mundane, but they quite literally busted several asses to get in the MLB. Conversely, MLB players who move over to Japan's baseball leagues tend to wipe the floor with Japanese players because the performance floor is so much lower. This is all to say physique, and also attitude, very definitely matter. That shit ain't easy; mad respects from me as a baseball fan. Baseball is as meritocracy as it gets. P.S. Kudos to Jackie Robinson and the Dodgers for making the MLB one of the pioneers and forerunners in true equality for mankind.
- RestlessMind 4y agoMy point was that some of the best Cricket players of all time are Asian (India, Pakistan, Srilanka etc), which is a very similar sport to Baseball.
- nradov 4y agoJapan finished 3rd in the medal count at the last summer Olympics. China and South Korea also did well. So the data doesn't seem to support your hypothesis.