7 ms·
It's freaking annoying that you can't use an Apple device without being connected to Apple. There should be a law against that sort of thing, for hardware that
by amelius 4y ago
It's freaking annoying that you can't use an Apple device without being connected to Apple.
There should be a law against that sort of thing, for hardware that you fully paid for.
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoWhile not specifically that, the EU's Digital Markets Act is moving things in that direction. I recommend reading the full text of the legislation, it has many gems.
- whiddershins 4y agoYou can wipe it and install Linux and use the hardware you paid for unencumbered. So do you mean use the software you paid for? (Fair) Or am I missing a nuance. Edit: Or are you referring to iDevices.
- amelius 4y agoRunning Linux on it is not the solution, as there is no documentation. Volunteers have been reverse engineering the GPU, but they still don't know whether their assumptions are all correct. Also, is the Linux support actually official? Considering the above, I think not. I can't vote with my wallet for a company that has no clear map for the future, for my particular usecases. Yes, iDevices are another problem. And yes, paying for the software when you use only the hardware is a problem too. Too many problems with this company. I honestly can't understand why so many other hackers are happy being tethered and parent-controlled by Apple.
- cassianoleal 4y ago> I honestly can't understand why so many other hackers are happy being tethered and parent-controlled by Apple. Obviously it varies from person to person. Some just don't care about this at all and/or don't consider it an issue. Some are just really used to it, or invested in the platforms, and don't want to waste time moving. Some will just find much worse experiences for their taste anywhere else. There are likely other personas in this story, these are just off the top of my head.
- shanebellone 4y agoI haven't used Apple in 5-8 years. I prefer to build my desktops and don't use my phone much, so Android is sufficient. Frankly, I do not understand the disdain for Apple. They built their stack. That should be admired. Also, it's one ecosystem in the market. Don't like it? Buy something else.
- EricE 4y agoAmazing, isn't it - people love to act like if you don't buy an Apple device they will send jack booted thugs to confiscate your non-Apple tech. Sigh...
- amelius 4y agoYes, fair, thanks for the reminder.
- cassianoleal 4y ago> You can wipe it and install Linux and use the hardware you paid for unencumbered. Not all the hardware, or at least not yet if you're on Apple Silicon.
- snazz 4y agoAsahi Linux works decently well on Apple silicon Macs today.
- EricE 4y agoBetter than Linux on the vast majority of Windows laptops due to hardware stability and less variability.
- cassianoleal 4y agoI was responding to this: > You can wipe it and install Linux and use the hardware you paid for unencumbered. My point is, it works. In fact, it works fairly well. Some people use it as a daily driver. Not all drivers are finished though, which is what I meant by "not all the hardware". By installing Asahi you are deliberately choosing to not use the GPU, not having brightness control and a few other things are missing. With that in mind, my point stands: by installing Linux on an Apple Silicon machine, you cannot "use the hardware you paid for unencumbered."
- Gigachad 4y agoApple doesn’t place any restrictions on doing this, in fact they have set it all up to make install Linux as convenient as possible without directly adding drivers to Linux. Mainline Linux can now run all the critical features of apple silicon laptops and the remaining stuff like power management is really just waiting on someone to work out what the best way to modify Linux to support it would be.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI agree, that's why I don't buy them. All of my computers are 9+ years old and run fully up to date Linux or Windows.
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoI’m not sure what would make you think that Windows is even in the slightest better. In fact it is proven that not only is Microsoft deeply in bed with the whole US Government, but the amount of vulnerabilities and flaws and outright back doors that have been publicly exposed in Windows is wildly larger. I don’t even understand this immense focus on criticizing Apple, as valid as it is, when people use Android and Windows and Google services that are all shown as clear hangar door sized vulnerabilities. It really kind of boggles my mind. Apple is constantly being out under pressure by the government and is constantly pushing increasing security and privacy features, as imperfect as they may be, but that is in comparison to Windows and Android, folks.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI use Linux but have a barebones Windows 10 install for one stupid stressful game that doesn't work on Linux due to anticheat. I audibly groan when rebooting to Windows to play. With that said I can still use Windows without a Microsoft account.
- daf203723087 4y ago> With that said I can still use Windows without a Microsoft account. Only because you are a power-user and know the magic trick to perform when installing Windows to avoid signing in with a Microsoft account.
- CharlesW 4y ago> With that said I can still use Windows without a Microsoft account. It sounds like you may not realize that you have never needed an Apple account (i.e. an Apple ID, which might call an "iCloud account") to use macOS. No magic tricks are required, although some Apple services will naturally not be avaiable.
- themitigating 4y agoI don't think more government regulation for such a specific reason is a good idea. Just don't buy their products.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoAt some point this "voting with your wallet" argument gets ridiculous. How realistic is going through life without one of these slaveware devices? (defining slaveware as hardware or software that treats you as a slave to the corporation that made it) Most people are coerced to using it, not even knowing the difference, forcing you to use the slaveware as well.
- oneplane 4y agoDo you really think the general consumer knows about any technical details of the products they buy, and if they did, they would care enough to chose the less-comfortable option for no perceived gain? This almost never works, and I think you know that.
- themitigating 4y agoDo you really think the general consumer knows any medical details of the vaccines they buy? Should we regulate misinformation?
- LarryMullins 4y agoWe regulate vaccines, don't we? If you're so opposed to government regulation, vaccines are a very strange example to bring up.
- dotancohen 4y ago> There should be a law against that sort of thing, for hardware that you fully paid for. Why? That sounds like exactly the type of issue that the market will fix, by buying from a different vendor.
- oneplane 4y agoIt seems the market isn't what you tink it is. At the same time, people also don't understand that the issue isn't what they think it is. There is a vocal minority on most of these things: - Powerusers and "learnt just enough to be dangerous" users complain about products not being targeted towards their wishes - Privacy alarmists don't like what they can't control - Commercial interests don't like having to pay for things, but do like getting paid for their own things Technically all correct, but in practise this is nearly all in the same bucket as fastfood, sugar, air pollution etc. It's something that affects everyone, but it's much easier to deny it, ignore it, and just go with the nice, easy, comfortable, and profitable paths.
- dotancohen 4y ago> It seems the market isn't what you tink it is. Then what is it? I think that the market is an opportunity for companies to compete on features, price, service, and quality. Is that incorrect? If Apple is not competing on features, then shouldn't the market provide an alternative company that does? Specifically, Apple requires a network connection to its servers to used basic functionality yet consumers do not like this. Other companies provide devices that do not require a network connection to its servers to used basic functionality, though possibly at a higher price (doubtful) or lower quality, or worse service. But the opportunity does exist. I'm happy to hear where either my understanding is wrong, or where the market is failing.
- oneplane 4y agoJust look around you, do you see any critical mass on both the vendor or consumer side that does something the way you describe it? Every time someone comes up with some confident theory on markets or how things should be, or how bad the things are as they currently are, they forget that the reality is 'the market' (whatever their definition happens to be at that time) did not, in fact, change due to either supply or demand. So when you were to say "the market demands offline devices, and the big companies are failing because they don't deliver that", you're either talking about a theoretical market, or about a different market, but not about the mass consumer electronics market. Because the big companies aren't failing, and regardless of the demand, no significant portion seems to be supplied.
- Someone 4y ago> There should be a law against that sort of thing, for hardware that you fully paid for. So, if Apple were to say you didn’t fully pay for the hardware, it would be OK?
- EricE 4y agoYou can. It's just if you do disconnect from Apple entirely, then certain features like Visual Lookups break - unsurprisingly. Not sure why there is this persistent myth that you can only use Apple tech if "connected" to Apple.