4 ms·
95% of the 100+ comments on this business are fake, presumably from a comment/review farm that was paid by the business owner (though I don't know that). The s
by troydavis 4y ago
95% of the 100+ comments on this business are fake, presumably from a comment/review farm that was paid by the business owner (though I don't know that).
The same commenters - some of which Google Maps describes as "Local Guides" - also have commented on dozens or hundreds of businesses that don't exist at all.
The fake business entries are basically using Google Maps place locations for SEO and presumably, referral lead gen. Create dozens of business places with random addresses throughout a metro area, name them after a service that someone might enter ("Heating repair"), and list a Web site or phone number. Wait for less-savvy consumers search or stumble across them and call.
Among the dozens or hundreds of fake Google Maps businesses that this network has touched, here's two:
"Top Grade Rolling Firm": https://www.google.com/maps/place/Top+Grade+Rolling+Firm/@38.8978075,-77.0083002,17z/data=!3m2!4b1!5s0x89b7b826ca5d1dab:0x7edf0a3ada1943bc!4m11!1m5!8m4!1e1!2s115552064819640275340!3m1!1e1!3m4!1s0x89b7b9f1a5debf7d:0xda5ea90e9be8da15!8m2!3d38.8978033!4d-77.0061115?hl=en-US https://www.google.com/maps/place/Top+Grade+Rolling+Firm/@38...
Some of the fake reviews for nonexistent businesses even include photos:
"Santiago Appliance Repair Service": https://www.google.com/maps/place/Santiago+Appliance+Repair+Service/@30.0832771,-95.4214459,17z/data=!4m13!1m5!8m4!1e1!2s117702732813342964966!3m1!1e1!3m6!1s0xa0075ec325743949:0x9478f4d4e30e4fe7!8m2!3d30.0832725!4d-95.4192572!9m1!1b1?hl=en-US https://www.google.com/maps/place/Santiago+Appliance+Repair+...
That address is actually a random suburban house, not an appliance store.
Some of the fake businesses have gone undetected for years, and in that time, have collected a few real reviews from people who called and didn't receive the service. Here's one from "Heating Cooling Repair Services": https://www.google.com/maps/place/Heating+%26+Cooling+Repair+Services+Edmonds/@47.8302265,-122.3395246,17z/data=!4m7!3m6!1s0x549015c5808353f3:0x5f5fd9a8ce6e8610!8m2!3d47.8302229!4d-122.3373359!9m1!1b1 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Heating+%26+Cooling+Repair... :
> If i could give them zero stars i would, don't waste your time.. I scheduled an appointment to fix my broken AC unit and was pleasantly surprised at getting an appointment the same week. I took off early from work to ensure I was home before the scheduled time. Nobody ever showed up, nobody called, and I called their number multiple times to see if maybe something came up and they never answered their phone.
Here's a Web site for one of these networks of fake businesses: https://nationalacservices.com/ https://nationalacservices.com/ . In that case, each fake Google Maps business links to a subdomain, like: https://lake-forest-park.nationalacservices.com/ https://lake-forest-park.nationalacservices.com/ .
Another: https://santiagoappliancerepairservice.us/ https://santiagoappliancerepairservice.us/
The fake Google Maps reviews are as generic as you'd expect. For example:
> I have been a patient at this medical laboratory for several years and have always had a great experience. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the facility is clean and well-maintained. I appreciate the quick turnaround time for test results and the ability to easily access them online. Overall, I have always received top-notch care at this facility.
The comments come from hundreds of Google accounts like these:
https://www.google.com/maps/contrib/102638895982367652158/reviews?hl=en-US https://www.google.com/maps/contrib/102638895982367652158/re...
https://www.google.com/maps/contrib/111709777137583909632/reviews?hl=en-US https://www.google.com/maps/contrib/111709777137583909632/re...
Google Maps doesn't have a way to report an entire account as a bot; one can only flag a specific comment. There's also no way to provide enough information for Google Maps' trust & safety team to understand what's happening and figure out how they're evading Google's bot detection. So, it continues unabated.
- nkurz 4y agoInteresting. Something is up. A few more things that seemed odd: 1) It looks like most of the reviewers have only reviewed a few businesses. Maybe this is to avoid suspicion, but if the accounts are fake they seem underutilized. I didn't see any fakes with over 6. 2) On the page you linked, several of the reviewers (Thaddues Kelly Parks, Darren Meyer, and Adilson Vierra) gave a standard glowing review but only awarded 3 stars. Also to avoid suspicion? Others gave 4. 3) All (almost all?) the fakes are within the last month. All of the extremely negative reviews are "a year ago". They are so negative I almost wonder if they might be fake too, and it might be extortion.
- troydavis 4y ago1. My guess is the same as yours - it’s to avoid suspicion. And maybe creating new accounts is easy enough that there’s no reason to over-use one account. 2. Yes, I imagine this is either to avoid suspicion or because the person writing/pasting this comment wasn’t paying attention and chose the wrong rating. Even fake reviews will have an error rate above 0 :-) 3. I was curious about that too. Another possibility is that the service really does suck, that’s reflected in the old negative comments, and eventually these businesses resorted to paying for reviews. All guesses though.
- luckylion 4y ago> 2) On the page you linked, several of the reviewers (Thaddues Kelly Parks, Darren Meyer, and Adilson Vierra) gave a standard glowing review but only awarded 3 stars. Also to avoid suspicion? Others gave 4. The alternative explanation is: they're real people who are terrible with technology and the internet. I've run a site where people could rate their experience with others, and the correlation between stars and text was only so-so. Lots of people considered 1 to be best, even though clicking on 1 showed a text "Terrible" just below it. 3 Stars was actually pretty common for glowing reviews. Everybody keeps forgetting that lots of people write reviews, especially when you ask them to ("hey, if you liked it here, please recommend us on Google Maps"), and some of those people will be the kind who gets these Amazon questions from other customers and reply "I'm sorry, I don't know how well they fit, I bought these pants for my son but he blew up the chicken coop and hadn't had time to wear the pants yet".