4 ms·
Amazon Smile Gets a Frown
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- m348e912 4y agoI know this is awful, but I always doubted the benevolence of the Amazon smile program and figured they viewed at as a nice tax write off. That being said, I am sure there were plenty of non-profits that benefited from the program.
- jcadam 4y agoMaybe too much money was going to non-profits Amazon doesn't approve of?
- tass 4y agoThe thing that keeps coming to mind is that they dealt with tens of thousands of charities, with the potential of requiring expensive customer service. The cost of running the program is surely a good fraction of the total amount donated.
- int_19h 4y agoDid they actually deal with the charities directly, or through one of well-established platforms like e.g. Benevity?
- tass 4y agoCouldn’t tell you, but who would ultimately have to answer for payouts being incorrect, etc.? I’m imagining hundreds or thousands of questions like “why am I only getting $2 this quarter when I got $10 last quarter”
- Spooky23 4y agoYou’d get a check once or more a year based on how much you had coming. Our little league would make a few hundred bucks a year off of it. About half was board members buying stuff for the league. You really had to push it to make anything - the most successful example I found was a league that used the same logo as a college sports team across the country. They made a “store” for parent gear that just went to Amazon Smile links. Amazon was super easy to setup, but there are many companies with better programs in the space.
- guestbest 4y agoIt’s effective altruism
- ornornor 4y agoAh come on, it’s amazon and Bezos we’re talking about here… hardly paragons of virtue.
- frollo 4y agoThat's exactly what "effective altruism" means. It's just philosophical marketing to dress the basest selfishness as altruism. Google the phrase up the next time you feel you have too much faith in humanity.
- derefr 4y agoFiguring out which charities 1. aren’t scams; 2. aren’t wasting 90% of your money on on overhead; and 3. are doing something impactful rather than something frivolous with your money, is “the basest selfishness”? If that’s not how you personally define Effective Altruism, then what name would you give to the concept I just described?
- cogman10 4y agoThat's not what "Effective Altruism" is. [1] Effective altruism plays the game where you can say "What's better, to give $10 today, or should I invest that $10 and then give it away when I die?" It's all about coming up with scenarios like this where you can justify selfishness because "eventually, the amount of good I'll do will pay off". It's popular with the rich and famous because they can justify building huge empires and hording large amounts of resources (while spending a bit on themselves of course) because, some day, they'll give back what they made. It's quiet literally the philosophy SBF used in the FTX fiasco to justify setting up a ponzie scheme. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism
- 4y ago
- IshKebab 4y agoHow would it be a tax write-off? Or are you one of the many many people who think "tax write-off" is some mysterious financial trick to turn a loss into profit?
- swyx 4y agothe venn diagram of "corporations are always evil no matter what" people and "haha i cannot do math but i know whats right and wrong" people has a huge overlap
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- m348e912 4y agoYou don’t think Amazon can say “we donated x dollars of our revenue to 501c charities based on amazing smile contributions and we’re deducting it off our gross revenue”?
- cmeacham98 4y agoOf course they can, but Amazon would have made _more_ money if they just kept the money and didn't donate it to anyone. However on the internet, people seem to believe "tax write-off" means Amazon is coming out equal or even net-positive compared to not donating the money.
- RheingoldRiver 4y agoI read somewhere that it was a way to get you into the habit of going directly to Amazon rather than searching for the product on Google and then clicking the first retailer. That's why you had to type smile.amazon.com directly into your browser. So in that way, it earned them a huge amount of customer loyalty.
- gnicholas 4y ago> Well, we’re paying our affiliates 5% for referrals. If we pay charities a tenth of that and call it a donation, it’ll be great PR and we’ll also make a profit on every sale because we won’t need to pay a full commission…” This is a very good point. When a customer goes to the Smile URL it supersedes whatever other referral link they might have come through, or might be lingering from a prior search/click. Given this framing, it's hard to understand why they would have eliminated it. My uninformed guess is this is about simplicity and saying 'no' to things that are not core to the business. This is something that makes money, but after factoring in the dev time that goes into it, the total incremental revenue is probably not large enough to justify. Amazon says 'no' to lots of new things that would generate revenue, so at some point it makes sense to cut existing programs that aren't making a big enough impact.
- fortituded0002 4y agoI often wondered why it was a different URL and that it wasn't enabled by default. This is explains it really clearly why it always felt disingenuous. Thanks.
- barnabee 4y agoI always assumed that Smile was about making customers who might have clicked an affiliate link switch over to the Smile site so they could avoid paying that referral rather than trying to make charities into affilites as the article suggested. I know I always did it. Perhaps more people were moving from the base, affiliate-less Amazon site to Smile than from affiliate links, by a large enough margin that the payouts were a net cost even after factoring the savings on those that had come via affiliate links. This is believable: I bookmarked the Smile site and very rarely click affiliate links. Would be hard (but not impossible) to believe the cost of developing or maintaining this programme was a significant factor at their scale.
- password4321 4y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/10ft5iv/amazon_discontinues_charity_donation_program_amid/j4znb8y/ https://old.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/10ft5iv/amazon_... >Internally, Amazon thought that if they could force users to go straight to Amazon, offer a small but obviously less amount of money to charity from each customer than would have been paid to google, it would help kill customers going to google, save Amazon more money than paying google >The intent of the program was to be cost neutral - the amount Amazon donated to charities was about equal to the costs it saved by not having to pay Google for advertising clicks. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34435338#34447006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34435338#34447006 >smile was invented as a way to bypass having to pay Google for the referral link
- metadat 4y agoAlso discussed 2 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34435338 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34435338 (560 comments)
- hourago 4y agoMy best guess is that Amazon have just moved the Amazon Smile team to do something else that may bring more money. Sometimes someone may want to do something good in companies like Amazon, but in the end, corporate structure will optimize for achieving maximum bonuses.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- skybrian 4y ago> I used to send you, my esteemed readers, to Smile links, but when I realized how little each donation was, I switched to geni.us, and so our donations went up 10x. How does that work? Is there some way for other charities to use it that they should know about?
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: Amazon Closing AmazonSmile - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34435338 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34435338 - Jan 2023 (550 comments)