11 ms·
Are you sure it's too little money? articles like this often report wages that sound small to a person living in western Europe or US, but when compared to peo
by dekhn 4y ago
Are you sure it's too little money? articles like this often report wages that sound small to a person living in western Europe or US, but when compared to people in the same economy, these salaries are often competitive.
And yes, somebody has to do the dirty work.
- godelski 4y agoThis is why I can never understand these articles. How much is $1.46/hr? Is it a little? A lot? Average? So I head over to Google and look up the answer[0]. But everything is in yearly wages so $1.46*2080 ~= $3037. Looks like it would be a lot in Sudan or Myanmar, an average in Egypt, and not a lot in Sri Lanka or Ukraine. But are these numbers even trustworthy? We had a post about this just the other day. But we don't even know the countries that are being used! So we're back to the original question: is it a little? A lot? Average? Honestly, when I see people spout out raw numbers alarm bells go off in my head. Doesn't matter if it is wage, number of car crashes, or number of murders. We have so many fucking people on this planet that a small percentage of a large number is still a large number. There are definitely people using this in deceitful manners. There are also dumb people, but idiocracy can still be accidentally malicious. The reason it is easy to lie with statistics and data is because it is actually really difficult to compare numbers and data across differing conditions. In this case, it really does not make sense to compare the wages of an American to the wages of a Sri Lankan. The price of an apple in both places isn't equal. Still, I don't know the answer to my question. [0] https://www.worlddata.info/average-income.php https://www.worlddata.info/average-income.php
- andrepd 4y agoThe fact that it's a lot in Egypt or Myanmar just means wages are low in those countries. It's easy to say "well that's just the way it is" while you're sat near the top of the pyramid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- godelski 4y agoYou're simplifying things too much though. There are important questions still. For example, how much does an apple cost? Rent? These are not equal in these countries. But also, let's say that they paid $3/hr in Egypt you could end up flooding the market. $15/hr and it could ironically be disastrous. We actually have seen stuff like this before when Westerners move in to other countries. The problem is that the local markets can't compete. Then we have a whole neocolonialism situation. If your goal is to actually help people in a country get out of poverty this is actually quite a difficult goal to achieve without taking over that country (implicitly or explicitly). We don't want to physically invade. We don't want to economically invade. But we also don't want them to sit in poverty so we have to do something right? So how do you do that and let them maintain their independence? They might not even want to work with us to begin with! Don't pretend that these are trivial problems and us westerners sitting at a computer just know what's best. That's how colonialism started in the first place.
- astrange 4y agoPaying extraordinarily higher than average wages in a poor country has downsides - most likely they'll be stolen (since most charity is stolen) but it also annoys the government when eg local doctors stop their practices to work for you.
- croes 4y agoOften competitive only means other jobs also pay too little money