8 ms·
Disney’s troubles show how technology has changed the business of culture
- LunarAurora 4y agohttps://archive.ph/EOv9l https://archive.ph/EOv9l
- rayiner 4y agoThe fragmentation of media exposure due to technological change is a really interesting phenomenon. I had small taste of what it must’ve been like in the US in the 1950s and 1960s because in Bangladesh we only had one television channel and aside from domestic news and soap operas the main draw was American network shows like Star Trek: TNG. Everyone watched the same thing because there was literally nothing else to watch. Even as a kid in the US in the 1990s, prime time was dominated by the four networks. Even kids knew what “Friends” was about because their parents all watched it. Today I couldn’t even tell you the prime time lineup of any network. The decline in attendance at movie theaters has had a similar effect. You can’t take for granted that everyone has seen the latest Bond movie.
- winReInstall 4y agoThe funny thing is, the companies themselves muddy the water significantly. By buying critic websites, critics and and raising there own numbers for cultural relevance and viewers. But money does not lie, and as soon as the audience has to pay for something, the real viewerbase shows some streaming empires naked.
- bluedino 4y ago> The decline in attendance at movie theaters has had a similar effect. You can’t take for granted that everyone has seen the latest Bond movie. You can count on most everyone seeing the hits, still. The recent Avatar and Top Gun sequels, whatever the latest pump and dump from comic book or Jurrasic Park franchises, for example.
- zwirbl 4y agoI know a lot more people who never go into franchise movies than those that do and even those are loosing interest in sequel trash
- pelasaco 4y agoParamount and Skydance's “Top Gun: Maverick” was the highest-grossing domestic release in 2022[0], generating $719 million in ticket sales.. I think there is more than that on this equation. [0]: https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/10/top-gun-maverick-disney-top-box-office-2022.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/10/top-gun-maverick-disney-top-...
- pessimizer 4y agoAt $10/ticket, that's 72 million people. About 1 out of 5 people if those are the US figures and not worldwide.
- danaris 4y agoAnd I dunno about you, but at least around here, tickets have been closer to $15-20 for a while. I haven't seen any movies in theaters since before the start of the pandemic.
- pessimizer 4y agoI haven't seen any of those. We know that most people haven't seen any particular one of those three, because we (vaguely, with a huge effort) know how many tickets they've sold.
- earthling8118 4y agoHow can you count on that? I haven't seen either of those nor do I know anybody that has. There's too many movies going through to be able to see them all. Maybe for people that are super into them but not everybody is.
- bavell 4y agoNope, haven't seen anything you listed.
- thathndude 4y ago"Today I couldn’t even tell you the prime time lineup of any network." This observation really hit home, and I'm not sure why, and I'm not sure what the implication is. But you're totally right with the observation. We've lost some societal glue.
- wussboy 4y agoWe didn't lose it, so much as we gave it away when we had the opportunity. The choice provided by the Internet -> streaming dissolved that glue as each of us chose what to watch according to our own preference. I think there is a larger phenomena at play here. We are learning that if every human has complete freedom to choose where they get the information that forms their intellectual environments, our society becomes more fragmented and the people in those societies become more separated from the people physically close to them. It's almost like humans need some constraints in order to form robust and resilient communities/society. Intuitively this makes sense, as our ancestors which gave us our society had (from our perspective) incredibly uniform intellectual environments.
- xen2xen1 4y agoThe same could be said of radio stations to Spotify, Bandcamp and the like. Once upon a time everyone listened to the same radio programs because that's all there was, then records came.. Technology has been splitting us into separate cultures hard for a good long while now. Probably even created the idea of a teenager.
- alexpotato 4y agoOne of my favorite media exposure statistics is that 105 MILLION people watched the series finale of the show MAS*H [0]. In fact, of the top 10 most watched broadcasts in US television history, the other 9 are Super Bowls. I also feel like we are in the middle stage of the fragmentation. Netflix etc meant that my set of shows might not overlap with your set of shows but some shows are still popular amongst a bunch of people. The next step, which feels not that far off, is where you tell Netflix AI: "Hey, I want a movie with Charlton Heston, Ariana Grande and Abraham Lincoln set on a space station, go." And it then generates it for you. With that level of customization and personalized media, I wonder if we will feel even more fragmented culturally as we lose these common narratives and touch points. 0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_watched_television_broadcasts_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_watched_televisio...
- mcphage 4y ago> With that level of customization and personalized media, I wonder if we will feel even more fragmented culturally as we lose these common narratives and touch points. The thing is, people like having these common narratives. They like talking with their friends about ongoing stories, they like telling their friends about new interesting things that they're watching. I don't think any sort of system without that would work. I just don't think it's what people want out of their media.
- tomohawk 4y ago[flagged]
- winReInstall 4y agoThe alternative was producing good products, engaging with creative people and pushing confrontational content. Its always safer to produce content for the current ruling dogmatic institution, aka working for the church.
- scarface74 4y agoYes also see DC choosing a black woman to play an orange alien from Tamarin /s
- hirundo 4y agoWhat's the objection to that? Who should play aliens?
- scarface74 4y agoWow. How much more obvious could I make it that I was being sarcastic than ending the sentence with “/s”. Yes there was such a “controversy” https://herapocrypha.medium.com/too-black-to-be-orange-or-an-alien-starfire-meets-the-21st-century-and-20th-19th-18th-a04c8a3102ce https://herapocrypha.medium.com/too-black-to-be-orange-or-an...
- hirundo 4y ago"I can't believe anyone could take that idea seriously, here's link about people that take it seriously."
- hestefisk 4y agoPlease elaborate?
- treeman79 4y ago
- codazoda 4y agoWhat I suspect, and we’re starting to see a bit, is that they need to massively cut budgets. Hundred million dollar budgets per movie don’t seem like they make sense. Instead, I think we’ll see more movies made on a shoestring budget. Some good, some bad. Disney has started to go this direction by building expensive technology they can reuse, like the set of Mandalorian. I just saw a trailer that the set has now been used in a new movie (but I don’t recall which). If you haven’t seen the set, go find it on YouTube. Pretty interesting tech. It’s expensive but will probably reduce budgets long term. Anyway, I think cheaper productions is the only thing that will work with so many options today. Cheaper movies like The Blair Witch Project are what I expect to see more of. I, personally, prefer paying for all the independent services I care to watch. I can pay for one or I can pay for 10 and have a cable like bill. But, I get to choose.
- looseyesterday 4y agoI think its harder to do then it seems. There is still a massive race for talent.
- jonathanlydall 4y agoThe technology product for the the Mandalorian set is called “The Volume”. Essentially, instead of filming in front of a green screen and digitally adding in the backgrounds post filming, they now have a huge seamless array of video screens behind the actors and a small set which has pre-rendered background scenery video playing and post filming changes to the background are generally not necessary.
- LegitShady 4y agoThe problem with the mandalorian is the writing not the effects of set dressing. I never watched past the first season because the writing was very poor.
- cooperadymas 4y agoThe streaming numbers would disagree with you.
- pelasaco 4y ago"A series based on “The Last of Us”, a post-apocalyptic game, seems to be a critical success. Sonic the Hedgehog was among last year’s biggest films and Mario is likely to be among this year’s. Nintendo is opening a new Mario theme park next month—in Hollywood, no less." For a second, I just imagined how bad would be the Disney version of Mario or Rocky Balboa. Disney is one company that probably few of us were going to miss if they go broke... unfortunately.
- pessimizer 4y ago> "A series based on “The Last of Us”, a post-apocalyptic game, seems to be a critical success. It was announced to be, long before it was released. It's very very bad. In the future, no one uses a broom or cleans up their room.
- dymk 4y agoYou think the TLOU TV adaptation is bad because a zombie apocalypse is cluttered?
- bluedevil2k 4y ago> Disney is one company that probably few of us were going to miss if they go broke What on Earth are you talking about? Disney is one of the beloved companies in the entire world. Tens of millions of people would be crushed if Disney would go broke. Provide some real facts instead of making baseless opinionated claims.
- dragonsky 4y agoTens of millions vs population of even just the US let alone the entire planet == few of us.
- pelasaco 4y agowell, you could maybe provide us some facts about "Tens of millions of people would be crushed"? Based on their numbers, looks like less people are wanting to watch Disney content or visit Disney park.. Otherwise they wouldn't be in trouble at all.
- haunter 4y agoThey got too big for their own good. 7 Marvel movies will be released in the next 19 months. Peak capitalism but I guess there is always a crowd for that. Also I'd assume the whole production is basically so streamlined now they can "just do it". Put out as many movies as possible and the meantime lower production costs, I guess in the future AI will be a big help here too especially in the CGI part.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoLower production costs also means competitors will have an easier time producing content. Hollywood studios have been the gatekeepers of culture but that's going to be more and more difficult for them to enforce as the limiting factor on movie making becomes more about creating desirable storytelling and less about wealth. These hugely expensive CGIfests seem to be the last ditch attempt at setting a bar that only the incumbent studio can meet. Someone will come along with a compelling story and a meager budget and end up showing up the nth iteration of whatever comicbook character they're pushing at the moment.
- chii 4y agounfortunately, streamlining these movies made them really bad. There's no soul in these movies that come from the love of the comic book characters. It's like a meat factory, rolling out identical, tasteless meat in a can that's cheap and easy to consume, but lack depth of flavour.
- LegitShady 4y agothey often purposely hire people who are not fans of the originals whose remake they are making. what those kinds of people makr are always hit and miss, and often miss.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoI guess I'll go to bat for the multi-billion dollar megacorp since nobody else is doing it Avengers: Endgame was great. They did a heist through time that was basically a speed run of all the other movies. Ant-Man preserved the "F You" energy from Hank Pym while keeping things just grounded enough to be fun. Thor: Love and Thunder was basically an action-packed version of a "Flight of the Conchords" episode and they ended up solving their problems by talking instead of just smashing heads in. So far as big budget movies go, these are the best I've ever seen
- dr-detroit 4y ago[dead]
- tlogan 4y agoTechnology is often used as an excuse for poor business decisions, but it is not always the sole cause of a company's troubles. In the case of Disney, the company's success is largely based on its ability to create and produce compelling movies and characters. Since they stop doing so, Disney is in trouble. The old CEO forgot that and focused on operational part of the company (parks, streamline online delivery) and completly ignored talents. It is important for companies to adapt to technological changes, but they should not lose sight of their core strengths and what has made them successful in the first place.
- autoexec 4y ago>In the case of Disney, the company's success is largely based on its ability to create and produce compelling movies and characters. > Since they stop doing so, Disney is in trouble. Weird live action remakes and recycled franchises are lazy. I'm still hoping disney will rediscover traditional animation and give us more original content.
- pigtailgirl 4y ago-- Disney research hub - still one of my fav youtube channels -- https://www.youtube.com/@DisneyResearchHub/videos https://www.youtube.com/@DisneyResearchHub/videos
- 5looking 4y ago[dead]
- gibsonf1 4y agoTechnology is not the issue for Disney, its that they have alienated half of their audience with their current ideology.
- deterministic 4y agoI don’t know what people are complaining about. The amount of quality entertainment available today is breathtaking. From Breaking Bad to The Wire to excellent series from France, Denmark etc. the choices are amazing! Just don’t watch the super hero crap (except The Boys of course!)