5 ms·
This is downvoted, but the homepage really does say "hello i am maia arson crimew (it/she)". I'd feel uncomfortable referring to anyone as "it" though, as ther
by arp242 4y ago
This is downvoted, but the homepage really does say "hello i am maia arson crimew (it/she)".
I'd feel uncomfortable referring to anyone as "it" though, as there are some connotations with that :-/
- kazinator 4y agoWhy do we only get to choose our pronouns? I want to choose my prepositions: in, up and above. Also, my conjunctions are: however, moreover, and whereupon.
- _cenw 4y agoBecause we already arbitrarily assign different pronouns to different people, usually based solely on their appearance, and there is no harm in letting people pick which type of gendered (or less gendered, in the binary sense) association they'd rather have.
- yencabulator 4y agoThere's an easier fix for that, instead of having to memorize everyone's "unique" preference (xy/xor/xeps), change the language to avoid the issue. "They" for everyone is the only logical evolution. My native language doesn't have a he/she differentiation..
- mrguyorama 4y agoYou don't have to memorize shit. When you refer to someone and they tell you "I prefer pronoun X" just use that pronoun for the rest of the interaction. If you interact with them regularly or they are important to you somehow, you will remember, the same as you remember a pet name or nickname or screenname. If you forget and interact with them again they will remind you. They will likely not be angry if you forget occasionally, and using their chosen pronouns will please them and endear them to you. They only get hurt if you obviously do it on purpose. It's literally identical to the concept of learning someone's name, yet humans largely don't have a problem with that.
- yencabulator 4y agoI don't know about you but I mostly refer to people with they/him/her/his/hers when they are not present.
- kazinator 4y agoWhat? When you're interacting with a person, you don't need to know their pronouns. They are the first person in front of you, so the pronouns are "you" and "yours". The third person pronouns kick in when talking about them, to someone else, almost certainly in their absence. That may happen in writing.
- kazinator 4y agoWe also hurl prepositions at people based on their appearance. "He doesn't look with it": preposition and pronoun. Oh, and don't get me started on adjectives. If a 5-foot-tall Douglas wants to be called Giant Doug, just oblige.
- distortionfield 4y agoIf they ask for it :shrug: also their tld is literally .gay so I think they’re pretty aware of what they’re asking for with their pronoun preference.
- dehrmann 4y agoIf it asks for it.
- gambiting 4y agoThe page literally says the pronouns are "it/she" so you can call her "she" and no one should be offended, correct?
- thaumasiotes 4y agoDoesn't sound right to me. A normal clause of that form would look like "she/her" and indicate that the pronoun is "she" as the subject of a clause and "her" otherwise. This would indicate that maia wants to be referred to as "it" as the subject of a clause and "she" otherwise.
- gambiting 4y agoThat.....frankly doesn't make sense, or it breaks the English language in ways that I'm not familiar with(admittedly it's not my first language). Do you mean that instead of saying "it's her apple" you'd say "it's she apple"?
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> That.....frankly doesn't make sense, or it breaks the English language in ways that I'm not familiar with Correct; it is massively ungrammatical. > Do you mean that instead of saying "it's her apple" you'd say "it's she apple"? No possessive form is indicated. But instead of saying "I gave it a dress", you would say "I gave she a dress".
- karmaMeansCool 4y agoIt's not good that you are uncomfortable when it asks you to talk about it with its preferred pronouns. It's 2023, it's about time you try to do what it ask you to do. When it tells you its preferred pronouns, try as hard as you can to follow it.
- kazinator 4y agoMy pronouns are you/your. Whatever you have to say, say it to my face, and not in third person behind my back.
- niemandhier 4y agoWe are a first person singular we user, to celebrate our freedom from the aristocratic yoke.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RHSeeger 4y agoThere's a difference, though, between > This person is female and I'm not comfortable referring to her as 'it' because females are 'she' and > This person is a human being, and 'it' is used to refer to objects. It's demeaning to call a human being 'it' and makes me uncomfortable The later is, at least imo, much more defensible.
- komali2 4y agoIn the absolutely fantastic novel Too Like Lightning there was a character that is famous for the life-like dolls made of it. Eventually it comes to term with the fact that its preferred identifier is "it" because it feels more comfortable being referred to as a doll, or inhuman, i.e. literally objectified, than it does with being considered traditionally human. I also feel uncomfortable using "it" as a pronoun, luckily this person seems comfortable with "she/her" as well so we can just use those instead.
- mrguyorama 4y ago
- niemandhier 4y agoI can understand that feeling. When English got rid of ‘thou’ and “thine” those were replaced by referring to everyone with the more polite “you“, that surly helped adoption.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> the homepage really does say "hello i am maia arson crimew (it/she)". > I'd feel uncomfortable referring to anyone as "it" though In Five Children and It (published in 1902), the "It" of the title is a magical creature. However, one of the characters is a human baby who is always referred to with the pronoun "it". I glossed right over that reading the book as a child, but I found it pretty disturbing rereading as an adult. However, once rereading the book had called the phenomenon to my attention, I noticed that it's not uncommon for me to want to refer to a generic child as "it". I wouldn't refer to a specific child that way. So referring to a person as "it" is sometimes the normal thing to do. (And, of course, intensely inappropriate at other times.) On the other hand, the intro appears to specify that maia arson crimew wants people to use "she", an exclusively subject pronoun, as the object pronoun for she. That is deeply unnatural and virtually nobody will be able to comply; it's much worse than using "it" for a person.
- rightbyte 4y ago"Child" is gender neutral and was historically neuter when English had genders. I guess calling a child "it" is impersonal. Calling it "it" to its face is just strange since "it" is 3rd person.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> "Child" is gender neutral and was historically neuter when English had genders. By 1902, that time was several hundred years in the past. > Calling [a child] "it" to its face is just strange since "it" is 3rd person. Sure, but I haven't mentioned any such usage.
- rsynnott 4y ago> However, one of the characters is a human baby who is always referred to with the pronoun "it". I glossed right over that reading the book as a child, but I found it pretty disturbing rereading as an adult. While it's uncommon today (and I think uncommon even by the time that book was written), use of 'it' for babies was definitely A Thing at one point.
- selimthegrim 4y ago
- heavenlyblue 4y agoI think a similar case would be if someone black asked you to call them an n word. They may be comfortable with that, but I am afraid others probably won't.
- jrochkind1 4y agoI know someone who says... it's pronouns are "it"... and using that really does make me uncomfortable, I agree. I _think_ (it hasn't necessarily told me this directly) that the choice may be intentionally to make people uncomfortable... like, why shouldn't you be uncomfortable thinking about gender? Lots of people are uncomfortable with gender, why shouldn't you be too? I think of it as a sort of art project... I'm not sure if it would be comfortable with that characterization or not. It also understands that some people can't handle this and will accept "they" without being offended, but really prefers "it", so if you're its friend and want to make them comfortable.... (I still don't love writing it even here with anonymous referent!) I thought it was the right that accused the left of being precious snowflakes who aren't able to handle being uncomfortable ever? Why should you being uncomfortable be a blocker to referring to someone as they prefer, right? Being uncomfortable is part of life.