5 ms·
" the enormous economic gap between the capitalist system of the United States and the centrally planned economy of the Soviet Union was clear." This isn't ent
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
" the enormous economic gap between the capitalist system of the United States and the centrally planned economy of the Soviet Union was clear."
This isn't entirely fair and is actually pretty flippant and tone-deaf given the situation of the time after the war.
In 1948 the US had been industrialized for much longer than the USSR. It was a destination for immigration, and had a vibrant young population. The two world wars it participated in were fought on foreign soil, far away from the homeland. After (and even during) WWII it benefited from a massive influx of European scientists and intellectuals. Industrial capacity from the war was redirected back to consumer goods.
The Soviet Union on the other hand bore the brunt of losses in WWII. It suffered massive deaths in the war, especially among its young men of working age. It was invaded by NAZI Germany, and some of its largest cities occupied or put under siege. Its agricultural and industrial lands were ravaged by war, its people by wartime famine.
While the Soviet planning system was a failure, and Stalin an evil tyrant -- in 1948 a working class person in the USSR not being able to afford a car had very little to do with the different economic models, but with the completely different situation of the two countries.
(Even if the movie/book was set in the 30s, the context it was being look at was post-war USSR. And even in the context of the 30s, the USSR had only just come out of civil war, revolution, and WWI)
- pxmpxm 4y agoThat's not exactly accurate, Stalin's famine and economic contraction happened in the 30s. Turns out that shooting people is not the long run solution that induces businesses to sell below their cost.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoMost statistics I could find showed the USSR had modest economic growth during the interwar period. The famine was seemingly intentionally inflicted to speed industrialization which makes it evil rather than incompetence. https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/soviet-economy-1917-1991-its-life-and-afterlife https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/soviet-economy-1917-1991-its-... I mean you send millions of farmers to factories and yes farm output declines, these things are related.
- lmm 4y agoI don't see anything in your link to claim that the famine was intentionally inflicted. For a country trying to rapidly industrialize, redirecting available labour from farming to factories and hoping that your productivity increases will make up for the reduced labour supply seems like it could be a good faith best effort to uplift the lives of as many people as possible as quickly as possible. Sitting back and letting the economy continue to be agrarian means passively killing many people through lack of access to medicines etc..
- pessimizer 4y agoNothing good can come from getting into this conversation. I'm pretty sure there are one or two countries that would imprison you just for posting this.
- Retric 4y agoThis wasn’t redirecting available labor, it was forcing people off farms without any offsetting attempt to increase efficiency.
- chii 4y ago> had very little to do with the different economic models, but with the completely different situation of the two countries. but both germany and japan had great recovery, despite also having lost a lot in the war due to bombings and population deaths. The difference is the economic system - USSR always felt that they're under threat from western powers, and devoted a lot of work in heavy production (which translates to military production), and very little civilian production. And even technological growth was kept militarily separate - e.g., they actually had computing but did not "give" that tech up for civilian use, after expending the R&D on it. Mean while, the US's defence spending on R&D does spill over into civilian use (often due to profit seeking motives, but still this produces good results). Like the internet, GPS, etc. The thing is that centrally planned economies means those that aren't "central" to the planner's mind will be forgotten. But everyone in the country is important in reality - so those who get forgotten will decline.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoWest Germany had massive amounts of American capital dumped into it in the post-war period as part of the Marshall plan. Japan as well. Again, not comparable. FWIW I'm no expert on Germany post-war, but from a personal POV my father was born in 1944 and grew up in post-war Germany (Mainz) and my Opa worked for the city in post-war building reconstruction (knew the story of every building in the centre of the city by heart and when I visited told me everything he knew). So I've some interest in the topic. As for the rest of your points, plenty of valid observations for the period of the 50s, 60s, 70s but we are talking 1948. The war had barely ended. It's ridiculous to compare a country recently ravaged by brutal total war which lost 26 million people, millions of which were civilians -- to a country which lost just 400,000, almost all in the armed forces (and, again, was a destination for immigration both before and after).
- rayiner 4y agoThe Marshall Plan was under $150 billion for all of Western Europe (in today’s dollars). The US has spent more than that in civil development in Afghanistan. The effect of the money shouldn’t be overstated.
- 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y agoCompare East vs West Germany. North vs South Korea. Postwar Britain vs postwar West Germany.
- woodruffw 4y agoPlaces that the US (reasonably!) dumped money on, in most cases to highlight and contrast a US-supported domestic system with the Soviet one. In other words: the GP is saying that the Soviets didn't have the money or human resources to do the things the US did, and you're responding with "look at all the things the US did with its money and human resources." It's true, but not really a response.
- Natsu 4y ago> The Soviets didn't have the money or human resources to do the things the US did SK is one of the biggest economies in the world, NK is literally starving to death right now. I don't think some US intervention decades ago really explains why NK isn't able to build much of anything, or why their allies still can't help them even manage to feed themselves.
- woodruffw 4y agoNK doesn't have that many excuses in 2023, but that wasn't really the point (or even claimed) anywhere in the comment. The claim is much simpler: if you're looking to compare the US and USSR during the postwar period, you need to consider the raw resources they had available. The US triumphed, and achieved a wide range of humanitarian successes in the process, but the why of that boils down to an intact workforce and a roaring industrial base, not some definitive dustup between Communism (tm) and Capitalism (tm).
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoIndeed this was my original point way above, though I would postfix it by saying, as I did also, above, that the Soviet planning system was a failure and Stalin a tyrant. The original claim of TFA was just pure nonsense. You can't explain a Russian's lack of a car in the rubble of 1948 Stalingrad based on "Soviet communism bad, American capitalism good" You can probably make that claim in 1975, though. Unfortunately people are not reading that far down into my comment to get the distinction.
- jojobas 4y agoIt didn't help that the USSR kept devoting up to 25% of their economy to the military. Improving the standards of living just wasn't a priority, the planning system was set to "just enough to avoid riots" and failed at even that.
- pessimizer 4y agoThe USSR's economy grew massively and quickly after WWII. It's a country that went from literal feudalism to modernity in one generation, becoming one of the two superpowers largely dictating world politics.
- whendoyoushrink 4y ago"Massively and quickly" seems optimistic. USSR grew at or below the rate of most European economies post war: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cc/Soviet_Union_USSR_GDP_per_capita.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cc/Soviet_U...
- pessimizer 4y agoA bit hyperbolic, but this is a thread claiming that the USSR grew far more slowly than the rate of capitalist Europe post war.
- jojobas 4y agoIt went from feudalism to more technologically advanced feudalism, and remains there today.
- mannerheim 4y agoDevoting 25% of their economy to the military was how they stuck around to begin with. You need a pretty big military to keep half of Europe under your thumb for half a century. Operation Danube involved about half a million men at its peak.
- jojobas 4y ago
- TMWNN 4y ago>This isn't entirely fair and is actually pretty flippant and tone-deaf given the situation of the time after the war. [...] >The Soviet Union on the other hand bore the brunt of losses in WWII. It suffered massive deaths in the war, especially among its young men of working age. It was invaded by NAZI Germany, and some of its largest cities occupied or put under siege. Its agricultural and industrial lands were ravaged by war, its people by wartime famine. All that and not a word about the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, of course. When two criminals fall out with each other after a joint robbery and murder, one ordinarily does not overly mourn the one whom the other killed in a dispute over the spoils.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoNot a word -- because it's irrelevant to the discussion of the comparison of the economic situation of the two countries in 1948. How or why the war happened, or what parties were to blame matters little when discussing the material circumstances.
- TMWNN 4y agoOh, come now. You wrote: >The Soviet Union on the other hand bore the brunt of losses in WWII. It suffered massive deaths in the war, especially among its young men of working age. It was invaded by NAZI Germany, and some of its largest cities occupied or put under siege. Its agricultural and industrial lands were ravaged by war, its people by wartime famine. "bore the brunt of losses" "suffered massive deaths" "invaded by NAZI Germany" "ravaged by war" "wartime famine" I.e., "Soviet Union = victim", as opposed to "Soviet Union = one of two criminals that together committed a crime, was attacked by the other criminal, and barely survived and killed the attacker with the help of others"
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoYou talk about a whole country like it's a single, morally culpable, person? And those 26 million dead, they all should suffer because Stalin signed the pact with Hitler? So you can wave away massive death -- justified? And all conversation about the matter must be redirected to this allocation of blame. "Mommy, Johnny hit me first." I think you need to give your head a shake. The way you're talking about war and death, it's like you don't really grasp the level of tragedy at all.
- ak217 4y agoNot fair to whom? The Soviet apparatchiks who enabled Stalin's purges and banned the movie to avoid hard questions? I remember getting a ride, as a kid, in the back of my great-uncle's Volga and my uncle's Zhiguli. They lived in Moscow while we were in a suburban town (akademgorodok) where a Zaporozhets was a luxury that less than 10% of households could get. The reason I remember is the ride was a yearly treat. This was during perestroika, in Moscow oblast (one of the two richest regions). A few years later glasnost allowed people to see enough movies to conclude that the system was unworkable. The Soviet Union was an evil empire start to end, built on the bones of its "brother nations" as much as their own citizens. Its troubles can't be explained away by WWII.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoOff-topic. We're talking about a specific place and time. 1948, not 1970s, 1980s USSR.
- ak217 4y agoThe fact that the situation had not improved after 40 years of peace is about as on topic as can be.
- pessimizer 4y agoThere weren't 40 years of peace between 1945 and 1948.
- dragonwriter 4y agoOr, for the USSR, between 1945 and 1985, either.
- ak217 4y agoRight. After 1945, the Soviet Union didn't suffer war on its territory - it exported it abroad instead, from Korea to Hungary, Czechoslovakia, Vietnam and Afghanistan. Proletariat of all countries, unite! Meanwhile, the economic conditions in 1985 were just as broken as in 1945. I know because I was there, as a brainwashed oktyabryonok, being sent to stand in a bread line with a talon (a rationing ticket for bread). In Moscow Oblast, the most prosperous in the country. The level of naivete and pedantry in this whole discussion is amazing to me, on so many levels.
- ch4s3 4y ago> It suffered massive deaths in the war, especially among its young men of working age. Largely because Stalin refused to listen to anyone and didn't defend his western borders and wouldn't admit the Germans were invading until they were practically half way to Moscow, and the Soviet system didn't allow for any other path of action. > It was invaded by NAZI Germany Who Stalin foolishly allied with, knowing at the time that Hitler would betray him. > Its agricultural and industrial lands were ravaged by war Was that before or after collectivization caused a famine and the purges wrecked all of the engineering talent?
- nl 4y agoIt is a fair comparison because Soviet propaganda explicitly said the opposite: that the Soviet system was superior to the West, and that people in the Soviet Union were better off than in the West.
- jackcosgrove 4y agoI think the economic gap between the US and USSR in the late 1940s had more to do with the czars and distance from northwestern Europe than the Nazis or Communists. Russia was very far behind the industrial countries before the revolution, and remained so thereafter. If anything, the Soviet modernization efforts accelerated what would have been possible under the czars. Because of Soviet growth during the Great Depression, communism was seen by many in the industrial world as a viable alternative during the 1930s. Command economies are great at catching up (just ask Park Chung-hee) and terrible at expanding the economic frontier. Not a fan of command economies by any means, but history is more nuanced.