7 ms·
Headline implies there’s something negative here, but I’m not seeing it. Was OpenAI supposed to hire high-skill workers in developed countries to do this work?
by brookst 4y ago
Headline implies there’s something negative here, but I’m not seeing it. Was OpenAI supposed to hire high-skill workers in developed countries to do this work?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIt's just the dichotomy of using $2/hour labor to build a product that makes you obscenely wealthy. As another poster said- in Kenya a job is a job and they still paid above average. Money going to Kenya is a good thing. They are doing the work so it must be worth it.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoThis also seems like a much better service job than the horrible scarring moderation jobs at facebook or factory work for apple. Heck maybe even better than most Amazon US jobs at the warehouses
- satvikpendem 4y agoWell, maybe not quite: > Almost more interesting in that article I found that Sama, the Kenyan company, was also asked to collect CP and brutal/gore images for OpenAI. After delivering 1400 images, Sama cancelled the contract as this was even too much for them. OpenAI then talked about "miscommunication" and they actually did not really want those CP images. Well, they made its own category for it and asked Sama to collect images of several other categories, but somehow it was lost in communication that for one of theses categories, no images should be collected. Because they are illegal. OpenAI swears they never opened the images they received (and paid for). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34427118 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34427118
- truculent 4y ago"I think maybe there is no borderline between countries now because we all live in the same country, it’s called capitalism."
- gowld 4y ago> The San Francisco–based A.I. startup is projecting $1 billion in revenue by 2024, as was first reported by Reuters and independently verified by Fortune. OpenAI only generated approximately $35 million in revenue in 2022, sources say, and the company is heavily loss-making at the moment.
- key_stroker 4y agoRead up on the company mentioned, people have mentally suffered working for them. But these days the human cost is just another cost.
- tomhallett 4y ago"But these days the human cost is just another cost" - this is where I think you, "key_stroker", and the GP, "brookst", might agree on something, in my opinion. If someone agrees with your premise that "these days the human cost is just another cost", then it seems logical that a newspaper editor/author will shape the headline about economic suffering, instead of mental suffering. By adding more information to the headline about "$2 per hour", it might make the discussion more confusing by much of the comments discussing the economic part. BUT, a clickbait-y title might increase the reach of the article.
- rsynnott 4y agoAt the very least you'd hope that they'd provide proper mental health support for people doing that; from the article that appears not to have happened.
- brookst 4y agoThat's a serious problem and seems worth an article no matter what country the people are in or what typical wages are in that country. Funny that "$2/hour" struck Time as more newsworthy than "exposed workers to horrific material without training or counseling."
- impalallama 4y agoIts interesting that no matter how magic and impressive the technology its still built on paying countless people as little as legally possible.
- gowld 4y agoArticle literally says the opposite.
- xdavidliu 4y agoDidn't headline just state the fact objectively, and any negative implication comes from the mind of the reader? If not, how could the headline be less editorialized (in order to reduce the negative implication)?
- somedude895 4y ago"OpenAI hired Kenyan company to make ChatGPT less toxic" "Kenyan workers helped make OpenAI's ChatGPT less toxic" "OpenAI paid Kenyan workers minimum wage to work on ChatGPT" Many different things are objectively true, but of course they mention the pay, because they know that to most of their "Western" readers it sounds outrageous.
- __derek__ 4y agoThe pay is not even close to the most outrageous way to headline this article: it uses "toxic" as a euphemism for, e.g., not generating CSAM, rape, and other sexual violence.
- Dylan16807 4y agoA computer cannot generate CSAM. Please do not misuse that phrase and diminish its impact.
- __derek__ 4y agoIf an AI uses source images to generate novel reproductions, wouldn't that still count as CSAM? Regardless, I should have included the phrase "depictions of" or similar.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIf an AI is generating novel images, I wouldn't call them CSAM even if they fall under a rule that makes them illegal. If they're not properly novel then it depends on what the source images were, I guess? But it's not like you'd need to train it on anything obscene for it to figure out how to combine bad things with nudity.
- __derek__ 4y agoIMO, the headline ignores the crux of the article: that OpenAI contracted with this company to collect and label data for "a safety system" that would classify and filter out "child sexual abuse, bestiality, murder, suicide, torture, self harm, and incest." In the course of doing that, workers were (naturally) exposed to source data in those categories from the internet until the contracting company cancelled the contract.
- rtev 4y agoDid you read the article?