10 ms·
A flurry of new studies identifies causes of the Industrial Revolution
- zeristor 4y agohttps://archive.ph/o0LpH https://archive.ph/o0LpH
- pffft8888 4y agoHuge catalyst: massive colonialist profits from India (est. $1 trillion), Africa and later on the Middle East (oil, prior to nationalization)
- com2kid 4y agoLikewise, the silicon valley boom happened via massive ecological damage to the surrounding environments. The linked article seems to argue against itself in places, a surplus of labor is argued to be both good and bad. I've seen arguments that the Roman empire never underwent an industrial revolution because they had slavery, and thus never needed to automate. The Romans did the resource extraction part right, but never iterated on it to the next step.
- tyre 4y agoThe Romans never had access to coal, which was the energy-dense fuel that made the Industrial Revolution possible. Bret Devereaux has a (long) post on this, which I recommend: https://acoup.blog/2022/08/26/collections-why-no-roman-industrial-revolution/ https://acoup.blog/2022/08/26/collections-why-no-roman-indus...
- Manuel_D 4y agoIt wasn't just access to coal, it was access to coal coupled with the heat engine: heat engines used coal, but led to the production of more coal and in turn created more demand for coal. This positive feedback loop created exponential growth. The Chinese widely used coal in metallurgy, but did not have an effective heat engine.
- emmelaich 4y agoRomans had access to coal, even mines. That acoup article says it's the demand for coal that made the difference.
- com2kid 4y agoIncredible post, thanks! I'll no repeated the incorrect assertion that the Romans could have had any hope of their own industrial revolution!
- tekla 4y ago[flagged]
- tyre 4y agoThe British Raj in India came about roughly 100 years after the start of the Industrial Revolution in Britain.
- glorygut123 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company
- jcranmer 4y agoEven their rule in India starts after the revolutions in textile making starts getting kicked off.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dahfizz 4y agoThe industrial revolution predates Indian colonization. In fact, you have the causality exactly backwards. The British empire could not have colonized India without their force of industry (ships & machine guns)
- chimeracoder 4y ago> The industrial revolution predates Indian colonization The first British colony in India was established in 1608. The only way you can argue that the Industrial revolution predates British colonization of India is to use the date that the colonies were nationalized as the starting point, which is incredibly misleading, as most of modern-day India was already under British control long before direct crown rule, and Britain was already reaping most of the economic benefits of colonization long before that date.
- biorach 4y ago> The first British colony in India was established in 1608. These were trading stations established by the East India Company. You can't really talk about colonization till much later - arguably Clive's successes in Bengal in the 1750's marks the start of real colonization. The dynamic of colonization after that was very much caught up with the desire of English manufacturers and merchants to find export markets for finished goods, especially cotton.
- Jensson 4y agoThey legally started setting up trade offices in 1608, the Indian rulers accepted them, they didn't conquer India until 1757. There were some minor battles before 1757, but the major parts of the plundering happened after then, and at that point the industrial revolution had already begun rolling in England with the textile machinery. 40 years later they invented the steam engine, not sure what they could have gotten from India that would help them make that. Europe has plenty of Iron and Coal and extremely good metallurgy skill from making all those cannons, muskets and armours, those are the main ingredients for steam engines. Without the East India Company maybe the Industrial revolution would have happened in Germany first or something, but it is pretty clear that it would happen in Europe first, nobody else had that extreme scale and quality of ironworking.
- WalterBright 4y agoSpain had massive colonial profits from gold extracted from South America, but it did them little good.
- rayiner 4y agoIndia was ruled by foreign colonizers for the better part of a century before the British came. So it was clearly more than just that.
- barry-cotter 4y agoThat would predict Germany being much richer than Austria-Hungary or Britain being much richer than Sweden, or Spain being much richer than Italy. Industrialisation led to enormous power imbalances that made colonisation possible. Northwest Europe was pulling away from the rest of Europe starting in the 1300s. > This ‘Little Divergence’ is the process whereby the North Sea Area (the UK and the Low Countries) developed into the most prosperous and dynamic part of the Continent. Studies of real wages – the classic paper is by Robert Allen (2001) – and of GDP per capita (e.g. Broadberry et al 2011, Van Zanden and Van Leeuwen 2012, Alvarez-Nogal and Prados de la Escosura 2012) charting the various trajectories of the European countries in detail, demonstrated that the Low Countries and England witnessed almost continuous growth between the 14th and the 18th century, whereas in other parts of the continent real incomes went down in the long run (Italy and Spain), or stagnated at best (Portugal, Germany, Sweden and Poland). This ‘Little Divergence’ is also quite clear from data on levels of urbanization (De Vries 1981), book production and consumption (Buringh and Van Zanden 2009) and agricultural productivity (Slicher van Bath 1963a, Allen 2000). http://www.cgeh.nl/sites/default/files/CGEHWP46_depleijtvanzanden_0.pdf http://www.cgeh.nl/sites/default/files/CGEHWP46_depleijtvanz...
- scythe 4y agoThe Industrial Revolution started in the mid-18th century in England. The steam engine was introduced before the Seven Years' War (1756-63), where England and its allies won and the former essentially became the sole European power in India, though it still only controlled a small fraction of the territory. The Industrial Revolution was well underway before the Anglo-Mysore and Anglo-Maratha wars where England gained control of most of India. The Scramble for Africa was 100 years later. The American colonies were confined on the east side of the Appalachians. The amount of revenue derived from control of that amount of territory couldn't possibly have driven the largest economic transformation in the history of the world. Many empires of similar size have come and gone with no similar jump in the world economy. >In 1750 Britain imported 2.5 million pounds of raw cotton, most of which was spun and woven by cottage industry in Lancashire. The work was done by hand in workers' homes or occasionally in master weavers' shops. In 1787 raw cotton consumption was 22 million pounds, most of which was cleaned, carded, and spun on machines. What could have contributed to the Industrial Revolution, however, is the technology of Bengal, the first region of India that England gained control of. The economy of early-18th-century Bengal has been described as proto-industrial. The lazy "anti-imperialist" critique of the Industrial Revolution in fact undersells India as merely a source of resources. In fact, in the Anglo-Mysore wars, it was the Indians who had superior artillery (though English tactics carried the day) — designs adapted from the "Mysore rockets" were used in the siege of Baltimore, which gave us the infamous line "the rockets' red glare" in that song where they almost seem like an anachronism.
- alehlopeh 4y agoIt doesn’t sound like those rockets helped very much as that song only exists because the British failed to take Baltimore.
- pmayrgundter 4y agoThese seem more like accelerants than unqualified causes, which is how they're described. Why, each appears throughout history, and they're not making a perfect storm argument that integrates the necessary tech background. That said, very cool methods for reconstruction
- diego_moita 4y agoI find interesting these studies that compare the behaviour of similar cities that got different outcomes. Another one I saw years ago was made in Germany, to test the Max Weber hypothesis that the Protestant Ethics fostered capitalism. The study compared the growth of both Catholic and Protestant cities. It found no significant difference in the rate of growth. The factor that actually had the most impact on growth was the presence of a printing industry.
- klntsky 4y ago> The study compared the growth of both Catholic and Protestant cities This is misunderstanding of the thesis. Ideas make changes _possible_. It's not like there is simply more change in places where more people adhere to the new ideas.
- BirAdam 4y agoAs far as I know, the Industrial Revolution started with coal mining. As shafts got deeper there was a need to pump in water and air, and then to lift product out. These steam engines at the site could run on low quality coal allowing all of the good stuff to be sold. The Industrial Revolution really started with these mines in the UK. As regards slavery and other factors, once the steam engines were invented and began making the companies who owned them more productive, human labor was outcompeted. Slave labor is not free as humans are quite expensive in food, water, shelter, medical care, and support for these things. Humans also require rest, and restrooms. Given that humans prefer not be enslaved, there’s also a cost to capture. Once an economic replacement for slavery and/or indentured servitude is available, these practices tend to disappear. Even animal labor usually disappears when machines are available, as animals require the same basic care that machines do not. In the USA, slavery hung around longer than it did in Europe largely due to reward for the capture of runaways provided by government, as well as a late start to industrialization.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- perrygeo 4y agoExactly. We have plenty of examples of past civilizations experiencing similar economic conditions, slavery, etc. So why didn't e.g. the Romans have an industrial revolution of this scale? Coal (and exploitation of fossil fuels more generally) is the singular factor that differentiates the industrial revolution from everything before it.
- akiselev 4y agoThe Romans had coal [1]. The Greeks had even come up with a design that (remotely) resembles a steam engine [2]. What they didn’t have was the rest of the “tech tree” leading up to a usable steam engine, mostly metallurgy and the physics of work/energy. We can point to the first industry to truly mechanize as the beginning of the revolution but the technologies that got us there were legion. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_in_Roman_Britain#Coal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mining_in_Roman_Britain#Coal [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile
- 40acres 4y agoI’ve been binging A History of Europe, Key Battles podcast which traces European History from Alexander to WW1. It really gives a great overview of European history and allows for one to see broad trends. For me, the Industrial Revolution is a product of the Enlightenment, Centralization of states (decline of feudalism) and the competitive nature of Europe (no single hegemony on the power). Even without the overseas Empires Europe probably would’ve been the birth of the revolution.
- pdm55 4y agoCan it be argued that the cause of the Industrial Revolution was man's insatiable appetite for using our planet's resources? A recurring theme in our history! Great Britain was an island. By about 1500, its residents had denuded most of its forests for fuel for cooking and heating. So, they turned to using coal. This spurred the need to pump water out of coal mines. The Industrial Revolution represents the uses of these steam-driven pumps for other tasks, such as textile manufacture and steam trains. "[M]ost of Great Britain’s forests seem to have been cleared for agriculture in antiquity; by 1000 only about 15% of England (as a geographic sub-unit of the island) was forested, a figure which continued to decline rapidly in the centuries that followed (down to a low of around 5%). Consequently wood as a heat fuel was scarce and so beginning in the 16th century we see a marked shift over to coal as a heating fuel for things like cooking and home heating. Fortunately for the residents of Great Britain there were surface coal seems in abundance making the transition relatively easy; once these were exhausted deep mining followed which at last by the late 1600s created the demand for coal-powered pumps finally answered effectively in 1712 by Newcomen." https://acoup.blog/2022/08/26/collections-why-no-roman-industrial-revolution/ https://acoup.blog/2022/08/26/collections-why-no-roman-indus...
- vixen99 4y agoThis 'recurring theme' is common to every single organism on Earth. It's only capability that limits life forms other than mankind. It was man's insatiable appetite for survival that got factory workers into the 'dark satanic mills' described by William Blake. Awful conditions there indeed (in many cases) but they worked there in preference to starving to death in the fields. As you point out, they had used up natural energy resources (food & heating) and had no alternative.
- Jedd 4y agoPaywalled, and the https://archive.ph/o0LpH https://archive.ph/o0LpH link is 502'ing for me There was a fascinating article about 6 months ago on 'why no roman industrial revolution?' which dove into the convergence of requirements - and almost coincidentally convenient technological advances - that led to this happening when and where it did - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32607187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32607187 The 'we can't run counter-factuals' comment in the opening paragraph of TFA is the crux of course, though Bret Devereaux's article (via HN link above) provides some highly compelling arguments about the key 'causes'.
- woleium 4y agoin short: New market based economies on former church land that was reclaimed after the conversion to church of England, coupled with a lack of workers due to war set the scene for mechanization
- bsder 4y agoI can't replay to the archive.ph link, but I'm seeing some odd behavior. Firefox is throwing a "502 Bad Gateway" while Chome happily renders the page. Suggestions as to what is up?
- eternalban 4y agoCapitalism. What distinctly differentiated industrializing Europe from anything in its past and anything in its contemporary world for so long was its socio-economic model. Capitalism and the attendant far greater class mobility, much like dot com boom, attracted intellectual horsepower to industry in the service of seeking wealth and advancing up the social ladder.
- rayiner 4y agoUnderstanding the development of Western Europe is one of the most important things historians could be doing right now. Because those lessons can be applied to help developing nations follow the same trajectory to development. Unfortunately too much of academia is fixated on faulting the west for past injustices, which leads to an unproductive Eurocentric mindset. (Britain will never, and cannot, pay back India what it took, so no point concerning ourselves about that.)
- maxerickson 4y agoLots of developing countries currently have per capita GDP comparable to western European countries in 1980 (Like as an example, Netherlands vs Vietnam). Why not look at somewhat more modern lessons?
- refurb 4y agoNetherlands had a GDP per capita of $13,000 USD in 1980, equivalent to $49,000 USD today. Vietnam had a GDP per capita of $13,000 USD today. They aren’t even close.
- maxerickson 4y ago~13000 in "Current US$". You don't adjust for inflation and then adjust for inflation again. Vietnam is considerably lower today on that measure (3750), but if you use PPP the comparison isn't quite as stark (but ends in 1990). https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=NL-VN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?location... https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.PP.CD?locations=NL-VN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.PP.CD?locat...
- refurb 4y ago$13,000 USD in 1980 isn’t adjusted for inflation. And if you’ve ever lived in Vietnam you’d realize the comparison doesn’t make sense. Vietnam is still very poor today. Netherlands in the 1980’s was a developed nation.
- krona 4y agoCenturies of political stability before and after the Glorious Revolution (1688) (constraints on the monarchy by parliament and strong political institutions) led to a large merchant and wealthy landowner class. Property rights and unique legal framework (common law) enabled many economic and legal innovations that created the conditions and incentives for industry, and allowed inventors and entrepreneurs to operate and cooperate freely. Without the unique legal, political, financial frameworks and enlightenment philosophy, the revolution wouldn't have happened in Britain. Technological developments were an emergent property of the fundamental structure of the country at the time.
- Merrill 4y agoThe industrial revolution was enabled by the rapidly declining price of first iron and later steel. Making iron requires bringing together iron ore, coal, and limestone in a furnace. These are heavy, and transporting them by horse drawn wagons any distance is expensive. England was fortunate in having coal mines, iron mines, and limestone quarries either co-located or on the same river so barges could be used. So once charcoal was exhausted and coking developed as the reducing agent, England had a distinct advantage in producing cheap iron. Once cheap iron was available, it could be used for rails, wheels for mining carts, mining tools, pumps, and eventually steam engines, one thing feeding another in a virtuous cost cycle. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferrous_metallurgy#Transition_to_coke_in_England https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferrous_metallurgy#Transition_... https://www.nmrs.org.uk/mines-map/coal-mining-in-the-british-isles/ https://www.nmrs.org.uk/mines-map/coal-mining-in-the-british... https://www.nmrs.org.uk/mines-map/iron-mining-in-the-british-isles/ https://www.nmrs.org.uk/mines-map/iron-mining-in-the-british...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Thermosetty 4y agoChattel slavery not only fueled the industrial revolution but laid the foundation for our modern world. Capital accumulation, investment of capital, private ownership of the means of production (people), high levels of wage (free) labor and efficient (non-paid) use of the factors of production (people) - are all mechanisms of capitalism that reach their maximum potential under the conditions of chattel slavery.
- thworp 4y agoYes, what a great point! This is why Mauritania had all of the world's richest men until 1981 when they outlawed slavery. If they hadn't done that Bezos and Musk would have nothing on the founders of Mauritanian SlaveTrade Corporation. Similarly it's why southern plantation owners where by far the richest people in America until the civil war. Carnegie and Vanderbilt had nothing on them. Strange though that nobody knows their names, must be censored by the Neo-Confederacy.
- jldugger 4y ago> Strange though that nobody knows their names, must be censored by the Neo-Confederacy. Wikipedia has a small list for your perusal[1]. Several actually[2][3][4][5]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_at_American_colleges_an d_universities#Columbia_University [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_presidents_of_the_United_States_who_owned_slaves [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_vice_presidents_of_the_United_States_who_owned_slaves [4]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_members_of_the_United_States_Congress_who_owned_slaves [5]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:First_Families_of_Virginia
- JanneVee 4y agoChattel slavery still exists around the world, why aren't they the richer than the places where chattel slavery is outlawed? Where ever machines replaced human labor slavery has been outlawed and is richer than the places where labor is done manually and still allows slavery. The whole point of industrialization was to replace human labor with machines and obviate the capitalist need to own slaves!
- nathanvanfleet 4y agoApparently it was Elon Musk who deserves the credit, at least he says so.
- college_physics 4y agoPeople focus maybe too much on the supply side of things. Resources, means of production, capital etc A puzzle that seems to floating above all this is the role of demand, what people want. An instance where it seems a key factor is the US consumer revolution. But maybe it was instrumental before. Also today, you get a distinct feeling that many parts of the world do not stay underdeveloped (using conventional GDP etc) because they cant do otherwise, but because they dont want. Developing a knack for wanting more goods or services does not seem to be trivial or uniform.
- LatteLazy 4y agoSurely demand is the easy piece: people with one set of cloths and one piece of furniture, want more stuff. When you have a lot of stuff already, then people demand things like leisure time, freedom, justice, etc which conflicts with production of goods. But when you are basically a subsistence farmer you just want more stuff first and foremost. I find the idea that some places have not developed because the people there don't want things quite alien to be honest. Who is cold and doesn't want an extra blanket?
- college_physics 4y agoYou are thinking about very basic needs. Most of the world is (thankfully) beyond that stage. You need to explain why while industrial capacities are available for centuries now, there is a very varied picture in terms of development. Its precisely this assumption that "demand is given" that questioned. Demand seems to be a more complex beast.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI actually think it's the other way around. I can plausibly explain differences in development levels by pointing to 1001 different factors from colonial legacies to geography to corruption to infrastructure etc. It is your conjecture, that people just don't want things in some of these places (sorry if that is reductionist?) that requires a lot of justification. What makes people in some places lack demand while rich westerners like me demand so much? Why did my poor ancestors living with similar levels of poverty have demand when these people do not?
- LatteLazy 4y agoPeople think you can find a "cause" for social processes like this in the same way you can find a cause for a materials tensile strength. But you can't. They are complex events, lasting decades, with technological, social, political, economic, and other factors. That means (1) there is NO single cause and (2) nothing can be quantified, so everyone just picks the cause that suits their world view and gives it oversized importance. This is why subjects like history differ from physics. We should not try to apply ideas from the latter (simple cause-effect chains, reproducibility, fixed true answers) to the former.
- jldugger 4y ago> (1) there is NO single cause and (2) nothing can be quantified Fortunately causal analysis supports 1 and contradicts 2. With good data, models and algorithms you can _quantify_ the strengths of various causal factors, and confirm or discredit models. Time scales don't matter, complexity can be overcome, and even unobserved causes can be modeled. > This is why subjects like history differ from physics. We should not try to apply ideas from the latter (simple cause-effect chains, reproducibility, fixed true answers) to the former. Anthropologist Richard McElreath[1] applies bayesian statistical models to a variety of social situations, and teaches others how as well. People have won Nobel prizes for this kind of work[2]. In a sense, you already agree: the foundational component of bayesian data analysis is updating your beliefs as new data comes in. [1]: https://xcelab.net/rm/statistical-rethinking/ https://xcelab.net/rm/statistical-rethinking/ [2]: https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2021/card/facts/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2021/car...
- LatteLazy 4y agoI am afraid your citations don't support your claim. Those works are about using natural experiments and large sample sizes to estimate causes and effects. But that isn't possible for single, large events like "the industrial revolution" because there is only one such event. This is why no one can say "industrial revolutions are 8% caused by geography and 12% caused by social structures" with any actual basis for that.
- pedro2 4y agoPaywalled; Didn't Read. I'm not engaging in illegal behaviour by using the archive.ph link, in fact, I'm reporting it to The Economist as it shall be DMCA'd (I will not, but I stand by my reasoning).
- nimro 4y agoTurn off javascript on the page. The server sends the full article to your browser.
- hansjorg 4y agoTerje Tvedt has some ideas how differences in water systems might have played a big role. "Why England and not China and India? Water systems and the history of the Industrial Revolution": https://terjetvedt.w.uib.no/files/2017/03/TVEDT-2010-Why_england_etc.pdf https://terjetvedt.w.uib.no/files/2017/03/TVEDT-2010-Why_eng...
- i_am_proteus 4y agoI recommend two additional texts: Civilization and Capitalism, Vol 1 by Braudel[one], and Energy and Civilization: A History by Smil[two] A combined read yields a picture of the "industrial revolution" not as a single event- industrialization preceded the use of the steam engine; renaissance Europe was substantially more industrialized than early medieval Europe due to increased use of water power and animal power. Exhaustion of wood as thermal fuel (largely for blast furnaces), exploitation of peat and coal, and development of steam engines followed. [one]https://archive.org/details/BraudelFernandCivilizationAndCapitalism/Braudel%2C%20Fernand%20-%20Civilization%20and%20Capitalism%2C%20Vol.%201/ https://archive.org/details/BraudelFernandCivilizationAndCap... [two]https://vaclavsmil.com/2017/05/08/energy-and-civilization-a-history/ https://vaclavsmil.com/2017/05/08/energy-and-civilization-a-...
- phone8675309 4y agoThe Industrial Revolution, and its consequences, have been a disaster for the human race.