4 ms·
I've been thinking about social media a lot lately and how it has changed my life. I'm only in my early 30's, but I think many others my age grew up online and
by godelski 4y ago
I've been thinking about social media a lot lately and how it has changed my life. I'm only in my early 30's, but I think many others my age grew up online and when the internet felt smaller, but in a different way. I made life long friends through these means. But something I've noticed is that as everyone has come online, I have made fewer friends. What I personally miss is the small niche communities. These don't seem to exist anymore. I made several friends on sites like What.cd and found many artists I would have never come into contact otherwise (even speaking with many). Even friends on sites like Imgur when it was smaller, but never once it grew. The global social media is cool and has aspects that are nice to it (e.g. being able to talk to power), but its same power is its greatest downfall (you can't speak to your audience when your audience is everyone, filled with different priors (how we interpret words), and different willingness to act in good faith).
I see everyone talking about Twitter and how it needs to be replaced. But I want to know how we remake these smaller communities. That's what I miss about the internet. There are clearly size thresholds for these. Finding them is often hard and word of mouth. But what I want to know is how we make these flourish and bring personhood back to the internet. We should have both types of communities. But I don't think methods like Mastadon or Reddit really facilitate this. I think many even have seen this change as HN has grown. There are several people that I recognize their names but as the community has grown we have too seen a change in content, culture, and how we speak to one another. For good or bad. But I do think it is nice to have small communities as well that do develop their own cultures. Maybe I'm just old now though.
- nathias 4y agothey still exist on the fringes, there are forums from early web, new forums, new types of tech (defi and crypto has a lot of that)
- kristianc 4y ago> new types of tech (defi and crypto has a lot of that) I’m sure crypto and Defi has some good people, but a huge proportion of them seem to be grifters and scammers who I’d want nothing to do with. That wasn’t really the case on the early web.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nathias 4y agogrifters and scammers are mostly on instagram and twitter, not irc or matrix
- k__ 4y ago"as everyone has come online, I have made fewer friends." Probably has to do with your age. I made many friends in my 20s, most through the internet. This got less and less as I grew older. But I know a bunch of people in their 20s who still make friends online.
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoMost of the old niche groups (IRC groups, imageboards, forums, etc) I used to spend time on just migrated into private spaces once social media became a de facto public space on the internet. These places usually live as Discord guilds, Matrix spaces, Telegram group chats, private fora, Patreon groups, alternate networks (such as: mailing lists, Gemini, Freenet, Urbit, etc.) I also feel like all this noise about Twitter is just the Twitter early adopters realizing what the old IRC and imageboard users knew long ago: social media is a semi-public space now that everyone is online.
- api 4y agoThe net was a very different place before, say, somewhere between 2010 and 2015. I saw a huge shift then. Everything got monetized, weaponized, optimized for addiction, or drowned in spam. There’s always been bad actors and criminals and trolls online too but in the past decade they have either gotten worse or become more empowered. The golden age of the open Internet was really between about 1996 when it started to go public and 2010. The net today feels like either a ghost town or a hellhole. The only remaining good places seem to be niche sites or groups and private forums. The fediverse is decent but I am concerned for its long term future if it becomes big enough to be a worthy target for spammers and trolls. As for the cause of the decline I can think of a few big factors: 1. Engagement maximizing algorithms give weight to the most inflammatory content. These hit the scene big starting around 2008. If you forced me to pick one root culprit I would blame this. 2. Thanks to monetized social media “Internet troll” is now a career option. You can make money. You can maybe even become the President of the United States. 3. Speaking of politics, I think something changed when enough people got online that the net became the major source for political opinion. There is now not just money but power to be gained by manipulating things online. This attracts a whole different level of scum. 4. Trolls have escalated to the point that people have died. Mass shooters post their manifestos on boards now before they go on killing sprees. Running a forum today is just not fun anymore, especially if it’s not narrowly focused and topical. Nobody in their right mind would set up something like Something Awful or 4chan today. What happened to optimistic online cyber culture reminds me a bit of what happened to the 1960s counterculture. In a few years it went from exploration and optimism and art to Manson and Altamont. There seems to be a pattern where whenever humanity seems to be making a cultural breakthrough we get naive and then things go real bad real fast.
- pbronez 4y agoWell said. I wonder if maybe It Can Be Different This Time. I think it will take focused work at the protocol level, because you’re right that the Fediverse is a juicy target. I worry that the next 6 months will be a war against spam and other attackers… one that instance admins are under-resourced and under-equipped to win. We need to get a governance structure going and iterate towards something like OcapPub https://gitlab.com/spritely/ocappub https://gitlab.com/spritely/ocappub
- kibwen 4y ago> But I don't think methods like Mastadon or Reddit really facilitate this. Reddit offers two features for supporting intentionally-small communities: first, you can restrict posting to accounts that have been manually approved (although I think voting is still open to anyone with a Reddit account), and secondly you can make the subreddit private such that only approved accounts can see its contents (which solves the aforementioned voting problem). As for Mastodon, that's a matter of setting up your own topical instance and restricting who can make an account.
- paulcole 4y ago> I'm only in my early 30's, but… [as time has gone on ]… something I've noticed is that as everyone has come online, I have made fewer friends Welcome to your 30s. You will make fewer friends than you did in your 20s.
- sincarne 4y agoUntil you have a kid in school, and then it’ll pick up again.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoThat's a helluva trade-off tho. Making friends isn't easy, but kids are straight up hard. And expensive. "I have three kids and no money... Why can't I have no kids and three money?"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shrubble 4y agoI think that you make an interesting point. Having recently become interested in vintage computers I have been spending time with the forums at vcfed.org . To be honest unplugging from the political outrage machine helped my mental state...and I might in time make some friends on that site...
- sph 4y agoI've been thinking about this problem a lot and I don't think there is an easy answer or solution to this. I think that world is gone. -- To recreate the feeling of a small group of people chatting like it was commonplace two decades ago, I created a Discord server for strangers to just hang out and chat whenever one feels like. No pressure, no overbearing rules, just a small island in the modern lonely internet. Its been going on for a little over a month now, there's about 15 people that are more or less regular. If you or anyone reading is interested, send me an email with your Discord name. -- Still, any attempt like this is still so unlike the Internet we had in the 2000s. Myspace died and with it the sense of community. The modern internet feels as lonely as standing in Piccadilly Circus on a Sunday afternoon. So many people, with so little time for anyone else.
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoI'd be interested! I'll email you. That said I think we forget that barriers to using the internet were the gates that kept it a cozy medium-sized community. I knew older programmers than me who were content learning languages and frameworks by buying books or renting books from the library, but only socialized with colleagues, friends, and family in purely offline venues. Only a certain type of person put up with the jank of the internet and the early Web and that's the kind of person who was writ large on it. Just how in real life we don't invite the world into our homes or grab lunch with anyone off the street, likewise our internet presences are now becoming circumscribed to specific groups. The trick is to make the barrier to entry just high enough as to select for compatible people but not so high that the group becomes a clique.
- amatecha 4y agoI completely agree, I think that scenario is indeed a relic of the past. I was talking about exactly this with a friend recently. Never again will worldwide instant chat (IRC) be an amazing new thing where only the lucky few get to try it out -- figuring out etiquette, lingo and customs along the way with "innocent" ignorance (not sure how else to word this). Same for all the "first" big protocols and platforms, and of course the early years of the internet altogether. The cat is long since out of the bag, and that universal wide-eyed surprise and awe cannot come again.