3 ms·
> Since when does copyright require permission to learn from the copyrighted material? Ah, but you are anthropomorphizing an algorithm. What is happening insid
by amelius 4y ago
> Since when does copyright require permission to learn from the copyrighted material?
Ah, but you are anthropomorphizing an algorithm. What is happening inside the computer you call learning, but it is just some mathematical function. Other people might not agree that this is learning, and might call it "mixing" or "copying".
- sebzim4500 4y agoFine then. Say I went through Star Wars and counted how many blue pixels there were in each frame and published a list of the counts. Would you claim that list would be infringing? Doing statistical analysis does not violate copyright, or Google would have to shut down tomorrow.
- notahacker 4y ago> Fine then. Say I went through Star Wars and counted how many blue pixels there were in each frame and published a list of the counts. Would you claim that list would be infringing? If you were instructed to counted blue pixels by somebody who used your lists for a SaaS product which could generate high fidelity representations of Death Stars, wookies and Harrison Ford (someone else probably counted the other colour pixels!) every time a customer of theirs typed in "Star Wars", quite possibly.
- johnthewise 4y agoThe algorithm itself tries to learn to remove noise. This part of algorithm is undeniably a learning process, evidenced by the fact that it gets better along the training process. It just happens to be that, in order to remove noise, you need to have an understanding of the underlying thing(probability distribution), so in order to learn to remove noise, it needs to learn the images. I don't understand how a mathematical function by definition can't learn, since it's just a language we use to describe what's going on.