3 ms·
There have been some military tribunals. But it is essentially impossible to conduct a civilian criminal trial of alleged illegal combatants and terrorists capt
by nradov 4y ago
There have been some military tribunals. But it is essentially impossible to conduct a civilian criminal trial of alleged illegal combatants and terrorists captured under battlefield conditions in a manner consistent with US federal court procedures. The circumstances at the time the prisoners were captured made it impossible to maintain proper chains of evidence and key witnesses are unavailable. And who could even serve as jury members?
- hgsgm 4y agoDoesn't matter. What matters is was there any system of justice, even military justice, or were people detained and absurd with reckless disregard for potential innocence. Detaining people as POWs, and treating them well, prevents them from causing harm without oppressing innocents.
- nradov 4y agoThose people were not detained as prisoners of war but as unlawful combatants. The Taliban, Al Qaeda, and similar terrorist groups were not signatories to the Geneva Convention on Prisoners of War and their fighters did not wear uniforms, therefore they have no legal rights beyond what the US government chooses to grant. (I am not making any argument about the morality of this situation, just explaining the legal reality.)
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The Taliban, Al Qaeda, and similar terrorist groups were not signatories to the Geneva Convention on Prisoners of War and their fighters did not wear uniforms, therefore they have no legal rights beyond what the US government chooses to grant. Incorrect – this issue was specifically litigated; they are entitled under international law, because the war is war where one of the belligerents is not a state, occurring in the territory of a party to the Conventions, to the protections of Common Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions of 1949, which applies to “conflicts not of an international character”. Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, 548 U.S. 557 (2006).
- ImHereToVote 4y agoWhat evidence is there that the prisoners were members of the Taliban or Al Qaeda?
- nradov 4y agoThe evidence varies by case. For some prisoners there is very little evidence, or at least none that would be admissible in a legitimate civilian criminal court. Some of the prisoners may be innocent. But as a practical matter the decisions aren't being made based on evidence. There is non-zero risk that the prisoners could be dangerous and no US state or foreign country is willing to take the political risk of accepting them. And the US federal government can't really force anyone to take them.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoI love democracy.
- cies 4y ago"Rules-based international order" my ass
- TomSwirly 4y ago> unlawful combatants. [...] therefore they have no legal rights beyond what the US government chooses to grant. "We'll make up this meaningless word, and this will allow us to keep people with NO EVIDENCE AT ALL and torture them for 20 fucking years!" The whole thing is horrifying. It makes a mockery of the law and of morality.
- TomSwirly 4y agoSo America rounds a large number of people based on tenuous evidence or no evidence at all, tortures them for 20 fucking years, and then says, "There was never even a way to give them a trial in the first place"? It would have been a lot kinder just to murder them. It's disgusting. America is just the shittiest place.
- cies 4y agoSee this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anwar_al-Awlaki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anwar_al-Awlaki The even recently killed US citizens (dad and his children) in several drone strikes without any due process. Obama first (dad and son), then Trump (daughter). Maybe he did commit crimes that deserve capital punishment, but he was given no trial. But still kinder than years of torture, i agree. > America is just the shittiest place. An understatement imho.