5 ms·
This is why the theory that companies will inevitably grow until they own the world is false. Companies grow to the point where they are throttled by their own
by WalterBright 4y ago
This is why the theory that companies will inevitably grow until they own the world is false. Companies grow to the point where they are throttled by their own bureaucracy, then they fall to smaller, nimbler competitors.
It happened to Standard Oil, IBM, GE, RCA, Kodak, Sears, all of them.
The same failure happens to government agencies attempting central planned economies. Except that government agencies are never allowed to fail, and we all suffer.
- michaelbrave 4y agoany kind of central planning creates a large bottleneck and creates a brittle system with a single point of potentially catastrophic failure. It's why dictatorships tend to be fragile compared to a more decentralized system.
- miohtama 4y agoSchumpeter's creative destruction will eventually clean up the companies if they are allowed to fail https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_destruction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creative_destruction
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoGoogle's monopoly over search, email, ads, Android and Youtube will be hard to beat by smaller and nimble competitors. It's far too entrenched and the moat it has built is too tough and impossibly expensive for newcomers to beat. And if newcomers do turn into a threat, they will be swiftly acquired and absorbed into the machine. If it was possible, it would have happened already. Everyone is waiting for a Youtube competitor, but nobody can afford to build and run one at Youtube's scale. Same for the likes of Nvidia. The only real threat to Google is government regulators breaking their products up into separate entities that will have to fund and fend for themselves without Big-daddy G's ad money.
- WalterBright 4y agoI heard the exact same thing about every previous giant that failed. It was always "this time it's different!"
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoMeh, if I had a dollar for every time someone said "this time Microsoft is gonna fail for sure", I'd be richer than Elon. People were singing Microsoft's funeral at every new Windows or product launch and assumed it would burry them for good. Turns out, despite many failures, Microsoft is still among us, still growing, buying new companies and IPs, branching in new areas and firing on all cylinders despite all the haters and doomers predicting otherwise for the past 3 decades. Maybe individual products will die, like Windows, but Microsoft as a company will survive, as it grew to be a lot more than the Windows/Office company. My point is, people are generally bad at making accurate predictions into the future and competent CEOs are good at turning things around.
- AlbertCory 4y agoThey had something like a near-death experience under Ballmer. Nadella brought them back from it. For a long time, people really did give them up for dead.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoMy point exactly. If they survived those harsh falls, I doubt they're in any danger anytime soon.
- AlbertCory 4y agoWell, there are no hard-and-fast rules to follow. If they'd stuck with Ballmer, he might have flown them straight into the mountain. Did they have unique advantages even in the bad times? To my mind, they still had the allegiance of the big companies, which can be pretty sticky.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- avidiax 4y agoMicrosoft produces critical infrastructure. Could it dwindle to become a sort of legacy supplier, keeping the lights on at thousands of industrial facilities? As soon as the millions of niche use cases on the low end of the compute market get absorbed by ChromeOS or MacOS, which is not likely soon.
- voisin 4y agoSearch is a disaster now, with the screen resembling a late 90’s teenager’s website with ads taking over everything visually. They’ve increased noise at the cost of signal and that itself will be the downfall. Now they are letting the ad cancer spread to YouTube with multiple unskippable ada before each video. Ads will go to wherever they are most effective. Google to Facebook, then Tik Tok, etc. Android - does anything about Android these days seem like it is a driving ambition for a company the scale of Google? And what does it contribute to their bottom line apart from ads via the platforms above that are eating themselves?
- nneonneo 4y agoThe unskippable ads are getting progressively more aggressive too. Two 30-second unskippable ads on an 8-minute video? It’s a disaster.
- runamok 4y agoThe 30% (or whatever it is) cut in the app store?
- karolsputo 4y agoKeep in mind that a lot of issues with search are oblivious to the general public. I don’t think I have ever heard a complaint, outside of tech circles.
- voisin 4y agoHow much noise can be introduced before the general public feels they aren’t getting meaningful results? It is just a matter of time, because Google shows no ability to restrain itself from selling out to advertisers.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoGoogle is so entrenched they're the default search engine on 3 major browsers and it even became a verb in the English dictionary. Do you think the average members of the public are gonna start Googling stuff on Bing anytime soon? I think most non-tech people don't even realize if they are or aren't getting meaningful results. They got conditioned that whatever is on the first results page of google is what's relevant for what they're looking for and if it's not there then it must not exist. I really don't see any major market shift away from Google search any time soon. Maybe if Apple launched their own could change things up a bit.
- mdasen 4y ago> Same for the likes of Nvidia I understand the logic behind Google's position. What's the logic in Nvidia being similar? Nvidia makes graphics chips and they are a large portion of the market at around two-thirds, but it's not like AMD doesn't exist. While Nvidia is doing very well, Intel looked to have an unassailable position and then they had some bad years and AMD caught up and Apple moved to their own chips. I'm not saying that Nvidia isn't a great company, but Intel was completely destroying all its competition for a long time and then found itself in a bad place it needed to recover from. Couldn't Nvidia find itself in the exact situation that Intel was in? Sure, it wouldn't be due to fabs, but it could be due to something else.
- jeffbee 4y agoI think these hypothetical "nimble" competitors don't exist, or would be overestimating their nimbleness with respect to Google. Google has spent decades becoming incredibly nimble in the way that counts in their industry: their foundation of software and systems is so refined that they can write and launch a product in no time flat. There are almost no technical hurdles standing in the way of anyone at that company. It's not some kind of abusive behavior by Google, it's just them being a tough competitor.
- WalterBright 4y agoYou'll see. Give it 10 years. Those AI chatbots could be an existential threat to them.
- jeffbee 4y agoLike I've been saying for a while, if large language models are the future then Google is sitting pretty because they have the absolutely state of the art LLMs and so many training and inference resources to win that race running away.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> their foundation of software and systems is so refined that they can write and launch a product in no time flat They definitely have way more bureaucratic than even a few years ago. Part of it is regulations and the cost of complying with increasingly complex legal matters. Also, compared to 5 years ago they have almost twice the employee count. That means they’re even more herding to do. Yes, the underlying tech may be good, but if they spend extra time in meetings and complying with “extra” requirements that smaller companies can avoid, then they’re at a disadvantage. Especially since they’ve shared and open sourced or sold a lot of tech that makes them special (k8, grpc, protos, spanner, etc).
- jackcosgrove 4y agoI heard the same things about Microsoft in the 90s. MS still dominates the desktop OS, but newer platforms emerged that reduced the importance of the desktop. Even now the importance of the surface web, which is Google's bailiwick, is diminishing.
- femto113 4y agoGoogle gained their monopoly over search when they had only a couple hundred employees, competitors definitely do not need to be very big at all to be a threat to Google technologically. The government interventions that will matter will be stopping Google from bribing companies to use their software--no startup can possibly afford to pay Apple $15 billion per year just to be the default search engine on iOS.
- riku_iki 4y agoI think search alone is like 70 percent revenue, you win search - Google collapsed. And Google's search is old dinosaur vulnerable to innovation
- caseyross 4y agoOwning the world, and being slow and bureaucratic, are not mutually exclusive. In fact, I imagine they're highly correlated.
- coliveira 4y agoI may agree with this on technology, but Standard Oil is still the same: they only changed names, slitted and merged back due to government.
- WalterBright 4y agoThroughout the SO anti-trust trial, SO was losing market share steadily. It was being eaten away by smaller, nimbler competitors who had learned how to attack SO. "Titan" by Ron Chernow
- coliveira 4y agoMaybe in the short period during the lawsuit, but everyone knowns that pretty much all oil companies in the US are descendants of Standard Oil (do your research if you don't believe me).
- Dalewyn 4y ago>IBM, GE Are we living in the same dimension? That is to say, IBM and GE are still world-defining and -leading behemoths.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ghiculescu 4y agoIt a big stretch to say they own the world. When do you interact with IBM day to day?
- prng2021 4y agoYour insurance company, every bank transaction you make (ATM withdrawals , money transfers, check payments, etc), flight that you book, and countless other things run on IBM mainframes and and a huge catalog of IBM software. The world would not function without that company. Notice I did not call out any specific companies like a specific airline because it’s truly across the board. Mind blowing isn’t it?
- dilyevsky 4y agoIt’s like saying pg&e is world defining bc most of California depends on. I mean technically yeah
- Dalewyn 4y agoIBM still defines the backbones of information infrastructure, as already mentioned. GE is literally one of three major jet engine makers (alongside Pratt & Whitney and Rolls-Royce) in the world, to say nothing of their more mundane businessess (eg: household appliances). A company doesn't have to be a household name to be one of the foundations upon which the modern world depends on.
- justin66 4y ago
- plufz 4y ago> The same failure happens to government agencies attempting central planned economies. Except that government agencies are never allowed to fail, and we all suffer. As long as we are talking about democracies that is not true. In every election that particular planned economy can be replaced by another planed economy or privatization.
- slavboj 4y agoThis is also true for authoritarian states, many of which have greater ability to impose policy shifts than democratic states.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhy is the Department of Education still with us, constantly growing in scope and budget? It hasn't accomplished anything.
- vineyardmike 4y agoCitation please? But actually, the DoEd does things. If it’s growing in scope, then that “scope”… is a thing?
- WalterBright 4y agoI'm sure the DoEd does things. But what has it accomplished?
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoDon’t mistake motion for progress
- tsss 4y agoIn the case of Google their strive for world domination will fail at the very latest when an HR drone inevitably decides to ban the term "world" for some stupid reason.
- tdeck 4y agoDidn't Standard Oil get broken up by the government?
- chrismcb 4y agoI'm not saying you are wrong, but the United States happened to Standard Oil. And IBM is still a contender. To 50 company and one of the largest employers in the world.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago#99 by market cap: https://companiesmarketcap.com/ibm/marketcap/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/ibm/marketcap/ Profit, profit margin, and number of employees has been in steady decline for many years: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/net-income https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/net-income https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/profit-mar... https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/number-of-employees https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/number-of-... The decline is especially meaningful for them because the field they used to compete in (tech) exploded over the last 15 years. It has long been turning into a body shop where you would not expect to see any advancement, surely not like the old days.
- nunez 4y ago_Disney, Unilever, and Amazon angrily enter the chat_
- WalterBright 4y agoAmazon is a young company. It has been sputtering recently, ever since Bezos left. Take a look at the stock. I sold my Disney stock a few years ago because the company seemed to have lost its way.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoI actually see this as a feature rather than a bug. It's good that giant companies get too bloated for their own good and lose market share to new upcoming competitors. If this didn't happen, there would be no point in trying to innovate because you would never have a chance against the huge established companies with their money and influence. It's already pretty tough, but at least this natural tendency for bloat and dysfunction as they get older gives the newbies a fighting chance.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoPerhaps you’ve read Coase’s Theory of the Firm? He basically argues this point, that there is a “sweet spot” for company size.