3 ms·
That's one of the beautiful things about share-based compensation (from a shareholder angle). When the share price falls, the CEO and other executives take an
by sokoloff 4y ago
That's one of the beautiful things about share-based compensation (from a shareholder angle).
When the share price falls, the CEO and other executives take an automatic pay cut that's pretty directly linked to that (linear in the case of RSUs, superlinear in the case of options).
- rcme 4y agoThe pay cut is affine in the case of options, not super linear.
- dmitriid 4y ago> That's one of the beautiful things about share-based compensation (from a shareholder angle). The problem with shares is that they have become (or maybe have always been) a purely speculative asset. They rarely reflect the reality, and are always expected to just rise rise rise in price. Even if literally nothing changes, the company remains stable and profitable, the shares will take a dive because continuous unlimited growth is always expected.
- djbebs 4y agoExcept that's not true. At the end of the day all stock market returns come from one's of 3 things: Dividends Earnings per Share growth Multiple expansion Over the long run the speculation that you so decry ( which amounts to Multiple expansion) has a negligible impact (less than 1%). Sure you have plenty of short term booms and busts, but over the long term they are really irrelevant.
- dmitriid 4y ago> At the end of the day all stock market returns come from one's of 3 things None of which really reflect reality, and rely on basically pure speculation. They also depend on the stock to go up up up up. > Over the long run the speculation that you so decry ( which amounts to Multiple expansion) has a negligible impact (less than 1%). Over the long run stocks are just speculation.
- sokoloff 4y agoI disagree that the others are 100% pure speculation, but let's just look at the case of dividends. Dividends (especially for companies with a long track record of paying and increasing them) are reality as far as I can tell.
- matwood 4y agoDividends and EPS are real and don't rely on stock movement at all. It's the exact opposite where they drive stock movement.
- therealdrag0 4y agoHuh? How do dividends depend on “stock to go up up up”? That’s opposite of my experience. How does EPS have anything to do with stock price? I think you have it all backwards. Stock PICKing is speculative because we can’t predict the future. But that doesn’t mean that the future is unhinged from underlying fundamentals.
- crispyambulance 4y agoOn the surface, it's of course "fair" that compensation be tied to performance. The problem is that we're talking about an ASTRONOMICAL sum of money when it comes to people like Tim Cook. After the 50% pay cut, he's still making $49 million. Beyond a certain level of wealth, the numerical value of one's compensation becomes effectively meaningless. It's just theater for him to say he's taking a "pay cut".
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>Beyond a certain level of wealth, the numerical value of one's compensation becomes effectively meaningless. Depends on your lifestyle inflation. Even for the high earners in the US, 49 million per year is FIRE money, but if you're used to the life of an oil sheikh with luxury clothing, jewelry, art, exotic private parties, dozens of rare supercars, private jets and yachts, McMansions/penthouses in London, Paris, Geneva, NY, Tokyo, etc., some private island where it's nice and warm, and also want to leave a similar lifestyle for your kids and their kids and their kids' kids, then 49 million per year is basically poverty money.
- athorax 4y agoI'll make sure to pour one out for our oil sheikhs tonight
- KptMarchewa 4y agoOf wealth, yes, of income, maybe a level below sheiks but still can afford all of this. He is still worth like 1.7 billion USD.
- lp0_on_fire 4y agoPerhaps with the 49 million per year they can purchase the world's smallest violin.
- mistrial9 4y agocheck out the European Nobility for about 500 years, before the Napoleonic-era for conspicuous consumption. (some of the modern sports-moguls lack taste, from my chair). Of course, that EU Feudal system was powered by serf labor and oversea Imperialism.. think of serfdom as similar to an AWS job with a difficult boss, but with the serfs had more job security.
- jiveturkey 4y agosuper linear how? comp is still a fixed number of options, no? other than clawbacks or threshold function awards, which i don't think we're talking about here.
- sokoloff 4y agoIf you have 10K RSUs and the shares are worth $100, they are worth $1M right now. If the shares then go down by 10%, your RSUs went down by 10% (are worth $900K). If you have options on 50K of those same shares at a strike of $80, the options are in the money by that same $1M. If the shares go down by 10%, the in-the-money amount falls by 50% (to $500K) rather than by 10% (to 900K).