4 ms·
I find this reasoning incredibly hard to believe. My moderate income neighborhood with lots of people who don’t have college degrees has tons of kids. By contra
by rayiner 4y ago
I find this reasoning incredibly hard to believe. My moderate income neighborhood with lots of people who don’t have college degrees has tons of kids. By contrast many of the people I know who have very high incomes don’t have kids.
I think the truth is that being a dual income no kids professional couple is a pretty fun life and lots of people don’t want to sacrifice that by raising kids.
- rafaelero 4y agoI agree. GDP per capita is inversely correlated with fertility rate, so it looks like the richer people are the less likely they are to have children.
- scottLobster 4y agoAs a single income family, he's more right than wrong. My wife and I have one infant, and want another. I make around 117k/year pre-tax. Rent for a 3 bedroom townhome is 2500/month, that's roughly half my monthly take-home pay. Everything else comes out of the other half. I contribute enough to my 401k to get my employer match, but no more. I'm putting $250/month into my daughter's 529 based on similar calculations for what a decent 4 year degree will cost (a little north of a 100k). I max out our HSA to make the high deductible health plan worth it. We don't eat out that much. I drive a 23 year old hand-me-down Toyota. Things still add up fast if we don't keep track. There's not much left over at the end of the month. And there's going to be another $250+/month when the other kid comes along. We're not living in poverty by any stretch, have no debt, and can afford some minor luxuries. But it's a lot tighter than it was for my dad working essentially the same job at the same age. I'm curious as to the levels of credit card debt in your moderate income neighborhood, and how prepared they're going to be for retirement at their current savings rates. Or perhaps they just don't expect to pay for their kids' college at all, and are just hoping they don't get sick. We've already sacrificed the vacations and expensive restaurants. Should we sacrifice our HSA and kids' college funds as well so we can have 3 instead of 2?
- xyzzyz 4y agoYes, sacrifice college fund, obviously. Why do you feel this is a requirement? Your kids can get a loan for college in their due time, and 20 years from now, you will be in a much better position to help them financially anyway. Saving your wealth to give it to your kids when they older is good and noble, but not having kids just because you cannot furnish them with enough wealth for when they are adult, is really silly and counterproductive. Similarly, you might reconsider maxing HSA, depending on how much you spend. HSA has two benefits, a direct one which is tax savings, and the indirect one being actually forcing you to save money, which is useful for many people who are bad at planning and looking ahead. The latter doesn’t apply to you, obviously, if anything you’re overthinking it. On the other hand, with your earnings, and assuming two kids, using HSA gives you around 20% discount on actual healthcare spend. Take account as to how much you actually spend on healthcare, and consider whether saving 20% on that is worth not having extra kid.
- scottLobster 4y agoIt may have been silly and counterproductive before the cost of tuition went through the roof, and a 4 year degree became a de-facto requirement for almost all well-paying careers. My dad paid his own way through his PhD working part-time at Friendly's (fast food chain) while my mom was a public school teacher. Good luck doing that these days. It is my responsibility as a parent to ensure my children are as equipped to prosper as possible. They should not have to endure decades or potentially a lifetime of un-forgivable debt for what has become an almost fundamental requirement to be middle class. Expecting 18 year olds to get a job and pay their own way is no longer realistic unless you are fine with your kids being shut out of most economic opportunities. I hope it'll be more realistic in 18 years, but I can't count on that. Call me silly if you want, I'm just adapting to the way things are. I'd rather have two kids with full opportunities than four kids with 20% opportunities. As for the HSA, having seen my mom fight cancer for over a decade I'm well aware of how much healthcare can cost. Even with out-of-pocket max limits, it'll be a while before I feel comfortable not maxing it out.
- xyzzyz 4y ago
- camgunz 4y agoI agree, and I think it's pretty bad news. Governments are generally trying to increase incomes, and as this happens you can see birth rates declining. I think there are other things that factor in (basically reproductive rights and literacy--both of which decrease as you descend the income scale), but governments are--mostly--trying to improve those too. I'm not really mollified by liberals arguing that we need more immigration to address this. I'm not anti-immigration by any stretch, but it feels less like a policy to fix low birth rates and more like a bullet point on a list of "good things about immigration". The EU has generally tried to incentivize getting pregnant and having kids with social programs, but if it's having an effect it's pretty slow going, and my guess is that spending will have to increase pretty significantly to get back up to replacement rate. Even so, I think this is the correct policy because I buy what the World Economic Forum wrote about this [0]: urbanization and women having careers puts pressure on having kids. Your choices here are: make it even harder for people to live in cities and for women to work so they give up, or make it easier so they feel less pressure. The US politics here are weird. Liberals are trying to do things like write a right to day care into the Constitution, conservatives are doing the same with the 50s housewife dynamic, no one's sure urbanization is an unqualified good but it seems unstoppable. I think the EU is making progress because they have broad agreement on socialism; the US can't move forward because they have this mostly unresolvable argument about what kind of society the government will invest in. But, and now I'll get on my partisan horse for a second, the kind of social engineering conservatives are engaging in is pretty odd. In a liberal, democratic society your government ought to support your lifestyle unless it's demonstrably damaging, and I don't think things like being a same-sex couple or being a woman in the workplace are demonstrably damaging. I guess someone somewhere might make religious arguments or something, but being gay is super accepted in the US as is working as a woman, so those arguments seem pretty fringe. Consequently, I don't really see any justification for trying to achieve this kind of social engineering through public policy. It feels deeply anti-liberal, and downright homophobic and misogynistic. [0]: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/06/birthrates-declining-globally-why-matters/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/06/birthrates-declining-...