18 ms·
Amazon loses bid to overturn historic union win on Staten Island warehouse
- monero-xmr 4y agoOhh, hrmm, ya know we have so many warehouses and this one simply isn't profitable. We need to close this warehouse as part of a cost cutting measure. It is sad everyone is out of a job.
- noobermin 4y agoI believe that is illegal. See[0] [0] https://qz.com/2191767/are-starbucks-and-chipotle-union-busting-by-closing-stores https://qz.com/2191767/are-starbucks-and-chipotle-union-bust...
- monero-xmr 4y ago> Even if Starbucks and Chipotle are eventually found to have committed unfair labor practices by closing stores, the legal and financial repercussions for the companies will be comparatively light. > “The nature of our labor law now, it actually makes financial sense for companies to break the union law, stifle the drive, and be found guilty,” says Joe McCartin, a history professor at Georgetown University and the co-author of Labor in America: A History. “The most they have to do is pay these employees back wages minus whatever they’ve earned in the intervening time” if the employees got other jobs after the stores closed. “That’s hardly much of a penalty.”
- causi 4y agoI will never understand why there isn't something on the order of an article of the Constitution requiring the penalty for any criminal act must meet or exceed the unlawful profits generated thereby.
- mathieuh 4y agoBecause the ones who have the power to make and change the rules are the ones who would lose out from making them stricter. They're hardly going to legislate against themselves.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoI lost one of my most convenient Starbucks because it unionized and shortly after that became suddenly and completely unrelatedly needed to close because it had become unprofitable. I assume it'll be back in a few months because the economy has recovered and it looks like a good place to open a nice, union-free Starbucks.
- distances 4y agoIs it common to have single location unions? Seems to me that this does not add very much negotiation power for the workers. In my country large unions negotiate for a whole sector, so all café workers regardless of their employer are covered by a collective agreement. You don't even have to be a member for the negotiated benefits (such as minimum wage) to apply: the collective agreement covers everyone in the sector nonetheless.
- renewiltord 4y agoThey're all under Workers United which is under SEIU. It's a big union.
- mtsr 4y agoWhat I don't get is why these unions need to be limited to a single shop/warehouse/whatever. Why not have a statewide/country-wide union instead? That's how you force a company to talk to you, by ensuring they cannot go around you. I thought the US used to have profession-based unions, such as the teamsters union, who can have members all over the US?
- cherioo 4y agoUS still have that, but it’s way easier to bootstrap a small union then expand, as intense lobbying resource (money) is required to have a successful union drive.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe union could have bought that closed Starbucks and reopened it, and run it as they saw fit.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mouse_ 4y ago[flagged]
- jpk 4y agoHi, and welcome to Hacker News. For good reason, comments like this don't do well here. Please read the site guidelines, and use them to make comments that encourage curious discussion. :) https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- granzymes 4y agoFor those following this saga, today the Phoenix office of the National Labor Relations Board adopted the recommendations the hearing officer made back in September (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32690937 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32690937). To recap: Amazon alleged that the union made illegal bribes (including distributing marijuana) and that the Brooklyn office put a thumb on the scale during the election (which is why the case was transferred to Phoenix). Today, the NLRB certified the election over those objections, which was the expected outcome. The next step is an appeal to the full NLRB board, which like the regional office is unlikely to be receptive (particularly for the charge against the NLRB itself). Only after that can Amazon appeal to a neutral body - the Federal Courts of Appeal. It has now been a little over 9 months since the election took place and it could easily take another year before the legal process runs its course.
- theGnuMe 4y agoAmazon will push this all the way to the Supreme Court if they have to. I suspect they will deny the union for some made up reason.
- xracy 4y ago<s> Labor is way too powerful in this country. Businesses are really taking a hit from all the power that labor has. </s>
- xracy 4y agoIn all seriousness, it's messed up how strongly Amazon can fight this, and not have to put up until they've wasted more money than it would've cost them to just accept it in the first place.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- silisili 4y agoI wonder if they'll take the Kroger route. As I remember it, which may be a little fuzzy, Kroger warehousing and distribution was unionized. They got around negotiating with them by outsourcing to a third party, non union warehousing company, called Zenith, and promptly sold off their own distribution centers to...Zenith. It read a lot like they just made a sweetheart deal to get rid of the union.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoThis kind of thing is technically illegal, but happens all the time. We should definitely expect to see lots of tactics that are technically illegal as companies fight back against this unionization push. But it does mean giving up direct control of their warehouse operations, which strikes me as unlikely, at least with only one shop having unionized so far.
- silisili 4y agoThat's the fun/smart/evil thing about how Kroger did this...Zenith was regional. Only 2 or 3 state area, KY/IN/OH if I remember right. And Kroger due to its sheer size became their only customer. Or perhaps the company didn't even exist prior, it's hard to actually research. So of course, in reality, Kroger still has direct control. They can do this in every region, of course, to keep any company from getting too big for its britches.
- tialaramex 4y agoThis is part of what Europe has Transfer of Undertakings laws for. Transfer of Undertakings laws basically say if an employee was working for X, and then supposedly they're now working for Y, but actually it's the same fucking job, then since those employees are doing the same job that's the same contract, any rules about that contract still apply. Under Transfer rules, Unions transfer too, unless the "same fucking job" is actually integrated somehow as might happen after a merger, so that the group of employees being represented by the union are just some fraction of an otherwise indistinguishable workforce. So the warehouse situation wouldn't trigger that, but e.g. if Walmart bought Kroger, closed all the Kroger stores, but kept 10% of the workers, moving them to a nearby Walmart as employees of that store, those employees lose their distinct nature and any Kroger union doesn't come with them.
- deltree7 4y ago[flagged]
- roenxi 4y agoThe US now has nearly a century of union activity. Over that almost-century, labourers have been completely rolled by people who own capital, who have become fabulously wealthy. I don't think the unionists have assessed the situation correctly. A strategy of co-ops and legal structures to let workers take on more economic risk (like what shares allow) would have gotten much better long term results. A union is basically a 2 step plan - first, identify the person willing to pay you the most. Second, pick a fight with them. This might be a locally OK strategy, but it isn't workable in the long term.
- hgomersall 4y agoExcept that unions typically form the other way round: workers feeling aggrieved by their employers unionize to apply leverage to improve things. You're probably right that the lot of workers as a whole could be done better, but for an individual that's irrelevant.
- WalterBright 4y agoUnions always treat their employers as adversaries. This does not make for a win-win relationship.
- LightHugger 4y agoEmployers often treat their employees as adversaries. Thus the need for unions in those situations... You appear to be placing blame for the situation on the party with less power in the situation, the employee, rather than the one with more power, the employer. this is a bit silly!
- WalterBright 4y agoConsider the union negotiating tactics. They don't negotiate, they demand. They carry signs and verbally attack the company. They threaten. They offer nothing in return. It's entirely framed as win-lose by the union. How do they expect the company to want to deal with them? Consider how businesses negotiate. Each side offers something in return for better terms. They come to a mutually agreeable win-win solution. That's what I do when I've negotiated with employers. I frame it as a friendly win-win negotiation, and both parties go away pleased with the result.
- karlkloss 4y agoWhat happened to respecting the will of the voters? Why do we take it for granted that we live in a democracy, but tolerate that businesses are directed like dictatorships? That's insane.
- WalterBright 4y agoDemocracy and freedom are not the same thing. Don't I, as a free man, have the right to negotiate as I see fit with my employer? Why should that right be taken away by a vote of others? Or let's put it another way. The Dems are for purple cars, the Reps are for yellow cars. We all get to vote on what we get! Is that freedom? What if I want a purple car, and the vote went yellow? What if I want a red car? That isn't freedom.
- lopis 4y agoAren't unions opt-in?
- WalterBright 4y agoWhat's the point of the vote, then?
- mdpye 4y agoThose who have opted in choose to be bound by the vote in exchange for the increased bargaining power that a consistent position affords, right? In the car analogy, you're missing the "free to not have any car at all even though you would like one" option.
- WalterBright 4y agoAgain, what's the point of a vote to form a union, if you can be in a union or not as you choose? The ones who want a union can just make one.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoHow easy is it for current workers to un-unionize? Kind of like dark-pattern subscriptions, some things are much easier to sign up for than to get rid of.
- shellfishgene 4y agoWhy would they want to do that?
- Frost1x 4y agoI always find the anti-union stance interesting. Unions are, by and large, typically in your self-interest if you're an individual and sell your time for compensation in anyway. It doesn't matter if you're a Hollywood screen writer, professional athlete, or warehouse worker. As an individual you have significantly less power/leverage in negotiations than whomever is employing you with rare exceptions where you're quite close to irreplaceable. Yes, unions can run amuck and like any structure can be abused, but the abuse is typically (not always) in the direction that benefits you as a laborer. This is counter to the current state of affairs where most all abuse in the labor market is one sided, against you. Typically your only real leverage is irreplacability and mobility across the labor market (or overall financial independene to stop working entirely). Outside of that you're at the mercy of whatever level of business manager sets atop you and take whatever they can legally (and sometimes illegally) get away with.
- advisedwang 4y agoPretty easy and the exact mirror of the unionization process. You petition the NLRB and they run a "decertification" election. E.g in Nov 2022, there were 15 decertification elections (vs 108 certifications) and 87% of them resulted in decertificaton [1]. [1] https://www.nlrb.gov/sites/default/files/attachments/pages/node-8814/november-2022.pdf https://www.nlrb.gov/sites/default/files/attachments/pages/n...
- LatteLazy 4y agoI think it will be interesting to see if the union can actually make any progress on pay/conditions...
- kjsingh 4y agothat's a common doubt we all have - union jobs definitely pay more than non union jobs for same level and business area
- LatteLazy 4y agoI sort of hope it works out. I think anyone working for a living gets ripped off (we pay all the taxes and get none of the benefits). That said, I doubt the causation between unions and pay etc. I hope these guys get rewarded for all their efforts.