3 ms·
> If we were at carrying capacity the idea would be ludicrous because you not working would result in one of us starving to death. That doesn't make sense to m
by Dylan16807 4y ago
> If we were at carrying capacity the idea would be ludicrous because you not working would result in one of us starving to death.
That doesn't make sense to me.
You seem to think that if we hit carrying capacity, that means everyone is working full time to sustain that? Why?
Let's say all the farms in the world could sustain 100 billion people. Can't we run those farms with only 1 billion people? Why would non-workers cause starvation?
- HideousKojima 4y ago>Let's say all the farms in the world could sustain 100 billion people. Can't we run those farms with only 1 billion people? Why would non-workers cause starvation? Why should the non-workers steal the surplus value created by those who work via taxation? Or is it only theft when filthy business owners do it via contractual agreements to trade labor for wages?
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhy are you replying to me? That has nothing to do with what I was saying. But I don't think either one of those is theft. I don't think the article was calling anything like that that theft either. It was complaining about how land ownership works.
- Sevii 4y agoIf 1% of the population taking a day off would cause billions of people to starve why do you think you would have the option of not working? You would starve because at carrying capacity nearly all of your income would go to food. There wouldn't be any slack. Admittedly, you'd have to be one of the 'farmers' to have a non-marginal effect on food production. Why would 1% of the population that creates all the food allow you to have 'free' stuff if them working 1% less meant millions of people would die? They could make you do anything.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThis scenario is insane. A reasonable operation would have enough workers to cover sick days and the fact that people don't put in 100% every day. If they start running low on labor, they will hire more people. And those nightmares of food supply shrinking by 1% are going to be there whether or not you have UBI. Like, I agree that we shouldn't get close to the planet's carrying capacity! That's not the subject at hand.