3 ms·
> Creating new life forms? Many people can barely raise their own children. Can you imagine if tech companies create advanced lifeforms? It's truly a disaster w
by adamsmith143 4y ago
> Creating new life forms? Many people can barely raise their own children. Can you imagine if tech companies create advanced lifeforms? It's truly a disaster waiting to happen.
I never said it would be a good thing per se.
>It's rather rude to call it pointless FUD. AI messing up our world is real and I have thought it through at great length.
The particular comment I was referring to was FUD about humans losing their humanity due to interacting with AI, which to me is indeed FUD. There are very real serious issues with AI alignment but this doesn't seem like one to me.
>Having the perfect friend is actually immensely scary. It will create a world where people interact mostly with their electronic AI friends and where people no longer rely on each other. It is very unlikely that there will be any fabric of society left at that point, and people will start to hate the existence of other people...
It's not clear that current society is that great and it's going to have to change to adapt a future AI or we will certainly disappear. From a purely utilitarian perspective if AI friends replace real ones but net happiness goes up this would be a fantastic success. Certainly relative to other possible AI dystopias.
>The best thing that could happen would be the dismantling of all these tech companies by physically destroying all their servers and backups, just as we have done with huge stockpiles of nuclear weapons.
You can't really think this a possible or reasonable undertaking. Luddism isn't going to save us. Not to mention your example is one where that process has completely failed and Nukes are still ubiquitous.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vouaobrasil 4y ago> You can't really think this a possible or reasonable undertaking. Luddism isn't going to save us. Yes, I do. I believe forsaking a lot of new technology and curbing technological innovation is an excellent way to further humanity. I blog about it and write a newsletter and talk to anyone who will listen.
- adamsmith143 4y ago>Yes, I do. I believe forsaking a lot of new technology and curbing technological innovation is an excellent way to further humanity. The problem is that the cat is out of the bag. We didn't pass laws saying you can't make chip foundries and now they are all over the world. Even a Nation State would have issues destroying all of them and now the reality is that even non-ideal architectures can be used to train models. So it's just not possible to stop progress. Even if you blew up every fab in the world some clever hackers are going to string together 100 Tesla Model S' or 20,000 smart fridges and train a Neural Net on them. Blowing up fabs to stop progress is just not going to work not to mention the devastating effects it would have on the rest of the economy.