6 ms·
Conservative group targets migrant cell phone data, raising privacy concerns
- lrvick 4y agoOne of the many reasons to not carry a cellular device, or at least leave it off or in airplane mode.
- exabrial 4y agoApple devices still operate when "off", FYI
- barbazoo 4y agoWhen the device is powered down or when location services are turned off?
- shapefrog 4y agoFind my network still operates in a powered off state (I assume not forever)
- subjectsigma 4y agoYes. I just purchased an iPhone and they tell you as part of the setup that if you activate Find My iPhone or sign up for their emergency services, your phone will continue to send and receive signals even when it is “off”, at least while the battery is not fully drained. I’m fairly certain that Find My iPhone works by other phones or devices scanning for Bluetooth MAC addresses. Before I turned the feature off my phone knew exactly where my Mac was without either being connected to Wi-Fi. The technology is seriously impressive but also deeply disturbing. I felt that Apple did a pretty good job of explaining the privacy concerns during setup, though.
- lrvick 4y agoTrue. That said, I do not know why anyone concerned with security, privacy, or digital sovereignty would own an Apple device.
- TechBro8615 4y agoThat's one approach, but perhaps more realistically applicable advice would be to stop granting location services permissions to every app that asks for it.
- lrvick 4y agoThe cell towers have your location at all times and will give it to anyone with money or a court order.
- TechBro8615 4y agoOk, so how do I get the location data of my Senator? Do I just need his cell phone number?
- lrvick 4y agoSadly, yes. I honestly encourage you to do it too. It is the only thing that will make them care. You will need to have access to the privately sold cell carrier lookup services. Ask your local bounty hunter, private investigator, cell carrier employee, or dirty cop. You can also anonymously buy lookups with bitcoin on darknet markets. Joseph Cox from Motherboard proved the above at Defcon 27 to raise awareness. https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=3e6n7jDDmj0 https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=3e6n7jDDmj0
- TechBro8615 4y agoThanks for the link. I'm surprised I haven't seen this - will be watching it later. Any idea if it's still applicable five years later?
- lrvick 4y agoTracking tech has only gotten better, and more profitable. There is no incentive for carriers to stop selling a product that is legal for them to sell.
- 4y ago
- pessimizer 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DLewisEE 4y agoI've kept a shielded bag in the car and house for a while now for that purpose. Rather than futz with settings, just drop it in the bag when I want some "off-grid" time. Apple's latest update clearly states that even when off, they can still location discover the phone.
- belltaco 4y agoDoesn't that mean one'd miss emergency calls or urgent texts from family and friends?
- csdvrx 4y ago> Doesn't that mean one'd miss emergency calls or urgent texts from family and friends? In case of emergency dial 911, not me: - If it's not worth calling 911, it's not an emergency. - If it's worth calling 911, I can't help with the actual emergency.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoI think you're missing the case where the hospital is trying to let you know about the state of your loved one.
- wongarsu 4y agoHow often is that happening out of the blue? Sure, if a loved one has a serious health condition try to be reachable. But it's not something most people have to be concerned about.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y ago> How often is that happening out of the blue? Very rarely, but I'd rather know that not. That's pretty much the idea of an emergency. I know I've had a handful of them in my life and I think they were worth it. If you don't want to be available for those, fair enough.
- pfisherman 4y agoWhatever your politics I think we can (mostly) all agree that widespread availability of location data from mobile devices is a population scale security threat. Today it may be someone you don’t care for. Tomorrow it might be you. It is always in someone’s interest to demonize whichever groups / tribe(s) we belong to.
- AlexTWithBeard 4y agoSometimes I feel like we're trying to stop the bulldozer by all this privacy regulations and rules. It can be slowed down, but cannot be stopped. Would a complete openness be an alternative? Everybody knows everything about everyone? You wanna know what did I watch on pornhub yesterday? Be my guest, but I know that you were looking at this information. And you know that I know it. Perfect society, innit?
- RangerScience 4y agoI don't know :/ Two pieces of content come to mind, tho: > We were born on this [slippery slope], and we will die on this slope. It spreads infinitely in all directions, and where we choose to scramble to on its face is the task of our lives SFP on "Slippery Slope" - https://strongfemaleprotagonist.com/issue-6/page-125-2/ https://strongfemaleprotagonist.com/issue-6/page-125-2/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gnomon_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gnomon_(novel) The setting is one like you describe. It's... well, it's such an absolutely incredible story that it's almost impossible to describe succinctly and accurately. I'd say one of the themes of the story is "what would it be like to live in a place like this, if it actually worked and worked well?". That isn't to say it's utopian, or that the problems and issues of the system don't exist or aren't talked about, but neither would I say it's about those issues.
- lrvick 4y agoEveryone opted into tracking, and we can opt out again too. I buy things with cash, and cash purchased prepaid debit gift cards. I do not own a cell phone. Anyone who wants to track me will have to pay someone to actually follow me around which would cost more than anyone stands to make from the data they would obtain.
- nerpderp82 4y ago> The Washington D.C.-based conservative think-tank then continued tracking the movement of the devices across the country over the course of at least a month in January 2022. How is that even remotely legal?
- lrvick 4y agoYou give your cell phone carrier your location at all times, and you consent for them to sell it to anyone they want. Cell phones providers are private companies, not utilities. You can just choose not to have one.
- paxys 4y agoPlenty of stuff in this country is de facto legal if you have an (R) next to your name (and to a lesser extent D as well), simply because no one is going to prosecute them.
- TechBro8615 4y agoI'm not sure why the reaction to the news that a citizen organization that is non-law enforcement is tracking user data should be "well, it's legal if you have an (R) next to your name." The better question is, why is this data available in the first place? If senators were actually interested in fighting "big tech" beyond making a show of "banning TikTok" and "investigating Twitter," they would spend the time to craft privacy legislation making it illegal to collect, store or transmit this location data in the first place. Perhaps someone should start a non-profit to buy and publish the location data of anyone who spends time in the Capitol building. Maybe then we would see some movement on reasonable legislation to curtail this practice.
- anigbrowl 4y agoPart of the reason for the impasse is that there is no explicit Constitutional right to privacy in the US (other than that provided by the 4th amendment, which has arguably been hollowed out in its own right). But the first amendment does confer protection for publication of information, notwithstanding that it may be published for sale to other businesses and abused for everything from irritating robocalls to complete surveillance. So that makes legislation a steep hill to climb, as interested parties are likely to immediately challenge the constitutionality of anything that makes it through the (often dysfunctional) legislative process. There's also the less formal reality that business is culturally privileged in the US, and the trope of busybody lawmakers interfering with honest business people who are creating jobs and prosperity is easy to market.
- fallingknife 4y agoObviously this sort of data collection should be banned. Not sure why it's particularly relevant that it's happening to illegal immigrants as opposed to everyone in general, because obviously that same data is available on anyone. Also weird that there is so much secrecy around the government activity here. Seem like something that should be completely public
- lettergram 4y agoWait until I tell you how anyone can buy cell phone data... I really dislike the "conservative group" in the title there. Particularly, as everyone's buying / collecting the data. For years, there are companies that sell your GPS coordinates. Search "2000 mules" they (group interested in proving the 2020 election was "stolen") used GPS coordinates combined with video to find who were "mules" collecting ballots and dropping them off ballots in multiple drop boxes (legal in many states btw). Those same "mules" likely work for NGOs who buy GPS coordinates, web history / social media data / voter records to see areas who haven't visited a drop box, so they know tho to visit. Everyone's buying the data. Everything is tracking you if it can.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoEveryone is buying the data sure. But not everyone is buying the data about a specific vulnerable and demonized group and that does make it a different thing. The fact that a right wing organization is doing it is relevant in this specific case. The wider case you can make about the dangers of data collection and selling is certainly valid. But there are specifics here that should not be ignored.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI don't think this comment should have been flagged, and would encourage others who can do so to vouch for it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34316709 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34316709 I don't agree with the comment, insofar as I've submitted and commented on many stories about the collection and sale of cellphone location data over the years, and submitted this one because it was about the issue rather than the Heritage foundation (although it does happen that their politics are anathema to me). I can't speak for the consistency of objectivity of the source website on this topic, though public radio outlets stereotypically skew liberal. I also disagree with the notion that this is the best possible application of the data, since it was gathered non-consensually and used to disparage the subjects in the Heritage Foundation report (eg assumptively labeling detected phone users as 'illegal aliens' although the statutory term is 'nonimmigrant person/alien' and has been for ~25 years). In my view it fails to meet any recognizable standard of academic research and is pseudoscientific at best. Nevertheless, I think that the poster's arguments would have been better discussed than disappeared.
- ecommerceguy 4y agoAnd in other news the FBI has been doing the same tracking on Conservative Groups, without warrant, for the better part of a verifiable 6 years. What really blows my mind is Democrats/Far Left Progressives siding with neocons, deep staters and warmongers. Is that what is meant by "side switch"? I just want to be left alone.
- r00fus 4y ago[cite needed]
- yucky 4y ago> What really blows my mind is Democrats/Far Left Progressives siding with neocons, deep staters and warmongers. Is that what is meant by "side switch"? If you look into the origin of the Neocons you may be surprised to find they were Marxists[1][2][3]. More specifically, Trotskyists, who simply found a different path to achieve the goal the COMINTERN once sought - globalist revolution using "democracy" as their weapon/tool. Understood in that context, a lot of seemingly incongruous things start to make sense. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/daily-dish/archive/2010/06/neoconservatisms-marxist-roots-are-showing/185857/ https://www.theatlantic.com/daily-dish/archive/2010/06/neoco... [2] https://theweek.com/articles/528827/rise-neocons https://theweek.com/articles/528827/rise-neocons [3] https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2003/05/shac-m23.html https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2003/05/shac-m23.html
- readthenotes1 4y agoA long time ago I was outraged to find that prison inmates were given TVs better, much better, than the one I owned (because I couldn't afford better, much less much better). I'm not as outraged that we're giving illegal aliens cell phones because the whole immigration policy fiasco is a tool of the political parties to keep us outraged...