6 ms·
No startup is going to do didly-squat about the climate. If you want to reduce CO2 you will need nation-state commitment to nuclear power. Nothing else matters.
by SoftTalker 4y ago
No startup is going to do didly-squat about the climate. If you want to reduce CO2 you will need nation-state commitment to nuclear power. Nothing else matters.
- izzydata 4y agoI bet if you spent $70 billion on planting trees it could do something.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI bet you could also do 70 billion on planting trees and do nothing or worse, spend a lot of money and carbon and have a negative impact. The devil is in the details
- vasco 4y agoYeah, destroy those ecosystems. Most tree planting projects are either scams or leave the local area worse off than when it started, unless it's replanting efforts on burned areas. And even then when done at a large scale to accommodate the feel-good goals of some startup, tree diversity is also not valued, and so again the ecosystem gets worse than when it started.
- Fervicus 4y ago"In the last week I've started to receive inquiries from people running tree planting programs wanting my help. I am suggesting that they shut down their programs. Here I will explain why:" - [0] [0] - https://twitter.com/ForrestFleisch1/status/1444008823350603780 https://twitter.com/ForrestFleisch1/status/14440088233506037...
- jmschlmrs 4y agoThey could if there was a (nation state) enforced price for carbon and hence a market to operate in.
- malux85 4y agoWe should try though, for example did you know that 1% of humanities global energy production (that is, our civilisations entire output) is sunken into producing nitrogen based fertilisers, That’s why my startup is working on catalysis models, so that we can get some catalysts to dramatically decrease the energy requirements of these enormous industrial processes. Also things like green chemistry (another project we are working on) is going to remove the need for a petroleum based chemical and replace it with an organic one that comes out of discarded orange peels. Yep sure, I’m not going to have a nation-state level of impact, but the discovery of the right catalyst can often change entire industries. So I’m trying as hard as I can, every day, to push towards a sustainable future, if enough people do it, we might be able to start to move the needle
- boppo1 4y agoHow much chemistry knowledge does one need to contribute to such an effort?
- malux85 4y agoIf you want to do fundimental new discoveries like this, then a lot - there's not a lot of open source code out there - most of what's on github is just students re-hashing methods from > 5 years ago. If you want to push the boundaries the best way is to read papers, practice implementing yourself, and befriend quantum physicists and computational chemists around the world that you can ask when you get stuck. Chemistry is an enormous field too, you would have to concentrate on a much smaller section, I have been self studying for about 8 years now, (+ I have 20 years software development experience) and I think I'm getting to the point where I have complete understanding of the current SOTA and am pushing at the boundaries -- most of the ideas I am implementing are coming out in papers weeks or months later, so I feel like I'm at the edge. Self study requires an enormous amount of discipline though, which is partially why universities exist - because most people do not have the discipline to stick at something for 3-8 years, and I am doing it 7 days a week, almost every day of the year - because I just love this stuff, it's not tiring, it's exhilarating!
- overview 4y ago> Nothing else matters. Not if you’re a for-profit VC firm looking to invest in an area with changing regulation, which could lead to trillions of dollars of economic opportunity.
- kilroy123 4y ago“For every complex problem, there is a solution that is clear, simple, and wrong.”
- einpoklum 4y ago[flagged]
- random314 4y agoThis is an old rehashed PR coached reaction. https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-perspec-indian-crying-environment-ads-pollution-1123-20171113-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-perspec...
- danhor 4y ago"Big Industry" matters a lot, but personal transportation is also a large part of emissions. Especially for people that fly intercontinental more than once a decade. It's wrong to assume that you can just convince people to give up their fossil fuel SUVs, but that means another mechanism has to be used to make them, not that aggregated personal choice doesn't have a huge impact. This campaign promoted an inefficient mechanism, fully knowing it wouldn't work, but that doesn't mean that peoples lifestyles don't matter. Arguing that only industry needs to change is also a cheap cop-out, belying the scale of the problem.
- random314 4y agoThe point is simple. CO2 emissions suffer from tragedy of the commons. The person taking individual positive action can only suffer from it. Tragedy of the commons requires government action like carbon taxes and subsidies. This is easy to implement. Making snide comments on online forums does nothing, nor does making individual personal sacrifices that obviously don't scale. I bought an EV not because I have any delusions that my purchase of an EV would save the planet. I bought it because California offered me free car pool lane access that would get me back 20 minutes every day on the commute. With the subsidies etc, TCO worked out to be the same as a Camry. When 100 million EVs are sold we will see some meaningful impact.
- danhor 4y agoIndividual sacrifices (I would rather say individual lifestyle changes) do scale somwhat (for example meat consumption has gone down in germany by almost 10% over the last 10 years and it's not because meat is expensive or had disincentives attached to it), but not to the degree needed. Saying we only need nuclear power is obviously not true and in this case the snide comment points to the fact that the lifes of individuals will also need to change and pushing all needed change away to the industry is wrong. Peoples lifes will need to change, encouraged and enforced by legislation. And I do think people also hava a individual responsibility (especially for stuff that can't be decarbonised in the near future with good alternatives like meat consumption or flying, but also for buying unneeded large cars or wasting energy), even though it doesn't work for change on a larger scale.
- pshc 4y ago"Only my pet solution will work (which is in political gridlock) so give up and don't try to innovate or change anything."
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoNot just political gridlock. Is a political identity. Oh wow, what an amazing coincidence that the only thing that will work is directly tied to keeping the specific people in power and universally subscribing to their tax plan.
- arnaudsm 4y ago+ energy storage with density comparable to oil. Once we have these two, full electrification become possible
- nharada 4y agoI totally agree that a large commitment to green energy (which will have to include nuclear) is necessary. But not sufficient, imo. > Nothing else matters I assume you're writing this as hyperbole, but for readers who may not realize, this is definitely not true. Even if the entire grid was nuclear, there are still lots of other greenhouse emitting sources that need to be decarbonized. For example, building materials (like concrete) and livestock emissions account for ~10% of emissions alone [1]. Not to mention that many sources of transportation (16.2% of emissions) are currently not capable of running on just electricity (i.e. aviation) and need technology innovation. This problem is too complicated to be fixed by one single thing. [1] https://ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector https://ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector
- vlovich123 4y agoIt’s actually worse. Even if we dropped our emissions to 0, global warming still keeps going because we’ve pumped so much greenhouse gasses into the air already. I think OP is correct that we have to get behind nuclear in a big way. A way that we haven’t even started going down. You’re also correct that it’s not sufficient. However. If you have a lot of nuclear capacity (and I’m talking a massive overbuild in capacity), suddenly spending gobs of it on CO2 recapture isn’t a big deal. That’s probably why OP is saying nuclear at this point is the only viable path forward. Because if you want to do recapture at scale (and you have to go try to even try to arrest the growth), nothing other than nuclear can provide the capacity needed.
- pojzon 4y agoEven if we started building thousends of new nuclear power plants: - we dont have enough trained staff to build and operate them - it takes 5-10years to build one - we dont have infrastructure to supply them all with fuel and dispose waste (even new ones that can run on previous waste MSR) - we are too divided as a spiecies and too occupied with worthless disputes (are you pink or blue? Yada yada) Ppl at the top realized that they cannot stop changes, so instead are preparing for alternatives. We cannot stop it nor reverse, so all we can do is adapt. There is not much place left to run to, so better get trained now to defend yourself and your family. Ps. Yes, millions if not billions of ppl will die. Top does not care. It wont be them. Ps2. To recapture CO2 we have all energy we need provided by sun. All we need is to reforrest half of the land globe.
- guelo 4y agoOnly nuclear? That seems more like a political attitude than a considered stance. Especially with the amazing progress that has been made with wind and solar.
- almost_usual 4y agoThere needs to be amazing progress with energy storage, otherwise wind and solar improvements don’t mean much.
- melling 4y agoHow many times have solar and wind proponents been told this? It never seems to sink in. We’ve been waiting decades to replace all the coal power plants. 30 years of “it takes too long to build nuclear power plants” and “solar is almost ready” and now we’ve got what looks like an unavoidable problem.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoSounds like a need for a climate change startup that makes it easier for constituents to contact their politicians?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Schroedingersat 4y agoYes. Commit to a method that will run out of fuel in under a decade before even solving half of the problem and has had well over half a century of work spent on it instead of the thing that has already eclipsed it after a decade of actually trying.
- gersh 4y agoIf there are going to big investments in nuclear, then it'd make sense to invest in R&D to improve nuclear power. The same goes for any other renewable energy technology.