26 ms·
Universal flu vaccine against all known subtypes takes promising first steps
- oifjsidjf 4y ago[flagged]
- furyofantares 4y agoViruses and vaccines are very different things than bacteria and antibiotics, I'm not understanding why you think this is applicable reasoning.
- jjcon 4y agoIf there is selective pressure preventing spread, mutation would seem inevitable. Covid has mutated many times already. The question is will the mutations this selects for make a flu that is worse or will does it wall off all possible mutations with 100% (or close to) certainty?
- AlexandrB 4y agoMutations are inevitable no matter what. Many viruses mutate extremely quickly, probably because they are much simpler than a bacteria - that's why many vaccines stop working in a matter of months. While you're right about selective pressure giving preference to some strains, by limiting the spread of a virus you limit its potential to mutate since there are so many fewer viral particles around. For example if 100 people get sick vs 10, the number of viral particles and mutations you can expect increases tenfold and the risk of one of those mutations being dangerous increases as well.
- xcskier56 4y ago"Harms 0% non-old and non-weak population" -- completely 100% demonstrably false. One of my friends older sisters, in her late 20's came down with the flu at night, then in the morning didn't go to school (she was a teacher) b/c she was sick. She went to the hospital that evening and was dead before midnight from inflammation of the heart caused by the Flu.
- jjcon 4y agoThat is heartbreaking for sure. I think OP is trying to say or raise the possibility that the alternative could be much worse on a population level scale. I certainly have the same question but no background in this area to know myself.
- di456 4y agoOP is repeating misinformation and conspiracy theories. We already have flu vaccines. The article is about a different type of vaccine for the flu.
- jjcon 4y agoI think there is a good faith discussion though to be had about whether or not this could select for more deadly traits, no? That is certainly my first uneducated but good faith question that comes to mind after the past few years we’ve all been through.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> there is a good faith discussion though to be had about whether or not this could select for more deadly traits, no In the history of vaccination, has this ever happened? What has happened is resistance to medicine. Vaccines reduce the opportunity for pathogens to be exposed to drugs by reducing the incidence and severity of illness. It’s fine to take time to make informed medical decisions. But if your concern is resistance, vaccines are a friend.
- HPsquared 4y agoNot with humans, but it has happened in chickens. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marek%27s_disease#Prevention https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marek%27s_disease#Prevention It seems to be related to "leaky" vaccines.
- 4y ago
- greenyoda 4y agoDifferent flu strains have affected different age groups. For example, the 1918 flu pandemic killed 25-50 million people and disproportionately affected young adults: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_flu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_flu
- tedivm 4y agoIt really amazes me how anti science this website has become.
- goldenchrome 4y agoAnti orthodoxy isn’t necessarily the same as anti science. Questioning the established science is pro science provided it’s done in good faith and it looks like the parent is acting in good faith. What you’re witnessing is a great reckoning for the scientific community. We’ll see if the orthodoxy still has the faculties to deliver truth with time. I think the community has been corrupted.
- di456 4y ago> Questioning the established science is pro science provided it’s done in good faith and it looks like the parent is acting in good faith. I see the opposite here, it's another take of outrage porn based on misinformation. Good science would be having a hypothesis and doing scientific research on it. Science is based on hypothesis. It rarely gets to 100% but does work off of statistical significance. Whereas conspiracy theory regurgitation is based on opinion and story telling and does little to nothing to move science forward.
- goldenchrome 4y agoAsking questions is the start of the scientific process. If it turns out that vaccines cause undisclosed health problems then wouldn’t you be outraged too? Let’s see how it unfolds. Most of us can’t do the science ourselves, but we can ask questions and observe.
- AlexandrB 4y agoThrowing out a statement like: > Perhaps the only reason why flu is harmless is because we don't fight it? Without providing any evidence that viruses tend to become more dangerous when we combat them is anti-science. It's like saying: What if the earth is flat? Consider successful viral eradication campaigns like smallpox or polio. There's no indication that smallpox became "super smallpox" as it was about to be eradicated. Nor is there a reason to think this would happen based on what we know about how viruses work. It's pure fear mongering on the basis of nothing at all. Edit: There's so much wrong with the original post here. Not only is the flu sometimes deadly, as others have pointed out, but we already fight the flu with seasonal flu vaccines. Indeed, they seem to have a strong protective effect[1]. The flu doesn't seem to be getting stronger as a result any of this. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35132866/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35132866/
- di456 4y agoSo much misinformation here.. > Perhaps the only reason why flu is harmless is because we don't fight it? The flu has been fought with vaccines for decades. Still, it mutates constantly and the vaccine producers guess which strains will be dominant. Like s coin flip, they guess right or wrong. The topic of the article means that they may not have to guess. > ...antibiotic resistance issues we are facing due to dishing out antibiotics... Vaccines and antibiotics are two completely different things. One is preventative, other is for acute care of a bacterial infection. > Other than very old and frail people it's stupid to vaccinate against something that harms 0% non-old and non-weak population. Vaccine of a healthy person slows transmission to elderly and immunocompromised. And reduces the chances of feeling really shitty and missing school or work for several days. It's sad to dismiss something because it doesn't benefit "me", without considering how it may benefit "us" as a community.
- unshavedyak 4y ago> It's sad to dismiss something because it doesn't benefit "me", without considering how it may benefit "us" as a community. Really seems a problem with many areas of modern society.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI’d note this isn’t a modern concept. Selfishness evolved when our mutated giant brain dna expressed itself and has been poisoning us all since.
- SamPatt 4y agoPursuing self interest isn't poison. There are many examples in history (and in our modern world) where doing the "selfless" thing is just manipulation for serving someone else's interests first. Religious leaders maintained power over society for ages by determining what was selfish behavior. We likely cannot agree on a rule which always properly distinguishes between pursuing self interest for survival's sake versus crossing the line into harming others. Since we are forced to inhabit the same world, it's best to not disparage others for pursuing their own self interest as long as they aren't hurting you directly.
- vikramkr 4y agoThe Antibiotic resistance issues were seeing are orders of magnitude less problematic than the deaths caused by bacteria pre antibiotics. And - the flu isn't 100% safe for non old and non "weak" - no clue where you got that impression from. The 1918 flu pandemic (the origin of the still circulating h1n1 strain) was among the deadliest pandemics ever exactly because it was most likely to kill yound, healthy people
- generalizations 4y agoThe problem isn't the current state of resistance - the problem is the growing state of antibiotic resistance. What happens when the trend continues and we no longer have useful antibiotics? Then we're right back to square one.
- jccooper 4y agoBut what does that have to do with vaccines? An effective vaccine reduces antibiotic resistance pressures, since fewer people are taking antibiotics.
- generalizations 4y agoThey were drawing a comparison. Overuse of antibiotics can lead to antibiotic resistance; and similarly, in some cases we get similar results with antivirals.
- vikramkr 4y agoSure, but an antiviral is not a vaccine, so I'm not sure what the comparison is there. And it's not like there's no technological path on the horizon to deal with Antibiotic resistance- its probably an underfunded area of research but the situation is very very far from apocalyptic. The bubonic plague was apocalyptic- but antibiotics are pretty effective against that
- awb 4y agoDo you agree with fighting deadly diseases through vaccination?
- jabthedang 4y ago[dead]
- colechristensen 4y ago[flagged]
- lwhalen 4y ago...prepare yourself for massive downvotes. I'm in the same boat - how can I possibly be 'anti vax' if I've gotten pretty much all the PREVIOUS ones (based on the older tech), and I'm just skeptical of the utility/necessity of this new tech that appears to have non-trivial risks of debilitating or fatal side effects?
- nathanaldensr 4y agoThat's because the phrase anti-vax is not meant to be an accurate descriptor; instead, it's meant to be a label applied to you to cause others to attack you without thinking. You can see many examples of this here in this thread. Be comfortable in your control over your own body and don't engage with those who would destroy you because you don't submit to their collective will.
- grey-area 4y agoWho ‘would destroy you’ because you don’t take a flu vaccine?
- lwhalen 4y agoEmployers (mostly in Blue strongholds) were EXTREMELY EAGER to fire people - even remote employees - who did not want to submit paperwork showing they took the vaccine. If you refused, they marked you 'refusenik' and you were let go anyway.
- matthewmacleod 4y agoAt the time I wrote this comment, there are literally two occurrences of the term “anti-vax” in this thread and they belong to you and the grandparent.
- 4y ago
- reedjosh 4y ago[flagged]
- thallium205 4y agoWhy do you hate gramma?
- actuallyalys 4y agoThe other challenge of a flu vaccine is getting people to take it. This past year, just over half the population received a flu vaccination [0]. But maybe a more effective vaccine would be more appealing, so this vaccine might also address that part of the problem. It’s unclear whether from the part of this article not paywalled, but if it eliminates the need for annual shots, that would also help, too. [0]: https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/flu-vaccination-rate/?currentTimeframe=0&sortModel=%7B%22colId%22:%22Location%22,%22sort%22:%22asc%22%7D https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/flu-vaccination-ra...
- epicureanideal 4y agoAll vaccines have small risks. I’ve had family members get lifelong painful complications from I think two different vaccines, neither related to the recent ones. So it makes me a little hesitant when I know that I’ll survive the flu like I have many times before.
- namdnay 4y agoThat’s the thing isn’t it? Is the risk of the vaccine higher than the risk of a future flu? I strongly suspect it isn’t
- watwut 4y agoIn my case, I had actual flue exactly once in my life. It was super unpleasant, but no big deal and ended in exactly one week. I got flu shot three times and got sick with (not flu ordinary sickness) right after three times and it took two weeks to feel good after. I guess the issue is that I am rarely entirely healthy during cold season and flu shot pushes me over the line. Not really work it. I would take it if I had reason to - like a relative with super weak immune system or had to go to hospital whatever. But other then that, it is not worth it.
- toast0 4y agoAt least for me, the first several times I got the flu shot, I had a fairly strong immune response; this is probably good, but still two to three days of disruption. The last couple shots haven't been so bad (or I also had a covid shot at the same time, so who knows). But after the first two flu shots it was: known couple of days feeling sick plus very low chance of major complication vs unlikely several days of feeling sick plys low chance of major complication ... and there's a decent chance of getting the shot, feeling sick, and then getting the flu and feeling sick again. Now that I've gotten the shot enough times that I don't have a strong response, it's easier to just get it. The very low chance of major complications with no family history of such isn't enough for me to worry about. But the US has different policies on this intervention than other countries, so reasonable people can differ, I guess.
- nonameking2026 4y ago[flagged]
- ape4 4y agoThey probably shouldn't over promise by calling it "universal". Inevitably there will be a new variant it cannot handle.
- Izkata 4y ago> Inevitably there will be a new variant it cannot handle. Current flu vaccines target a whole strain (of which there are only a dozen or so and it's very rare for more to show up), not individual variants like the covid vaccines (just enough mutations to be called different).
- sdo72 4y agoI get flu vaccines yearly, and every time I still get sick. My kids got the vaccine this year, and all of them got sick because of the flu, 3 times. I really don't know if the flu vaccine does anything, but it definitely gives me lots of doubts. Then we had a family member who got very sick a month or two ago because of the flu, he was sent to ER, ICU, and eventually didn't make it. That sent a shock wave to our family. He planned to get the flu vaccine a bit later but got sick right before. Please get vaccinated, if it doesn't work well, it may give us the second chance to survive.
- Entinel 4y agoThanks for sharing this. It's not about not getting sick. It's about getting less sick than you would have if you didn't get vaccinated.
- poszlem 4y agoNo, it's also about not getting sick. The "vaccine is not about preventing the infection" meme got really annoying since COVID, since the COVID vaccine while very useful turned out to not be as useful for infection prevention as we'd thought. That does not change the fact that the role of a "vaccine" is mainly to prevent the infection, and the "getting less sick" fact is a second class effect.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> it's also about not getting sick You’re correct [1]. The vaccine mainly aims to reduce the frequency and intensity of illness. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/flu/vaccines-work/vaccineeffect.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/vaccines-work/vaccineeffect.htm
- woodruffw 4y agoYou're describing sterilizing immunity, which is a property that only some vaccines provide. More generally, vaccines are just a mechanism for acquiring immunity. Immunity doesn't mean "you don't feel sick," it means "your immune systems responds better and faster to the real thing."
- p1mrx 4y agoIt seems that mRNA vaccines are becoming like antivirus software updates: inject the whole "database" and your body scans for currently-known threats. Does the immune system have a capacity limit? I wonder if the technology will reach a point where we can print mRNA on demand. Could we build a database of bacteriophage viruses that target various strains of bacteria, and use custom-printed mRNA to produce the correct virus when someone has a bacterial infection?
- warning26 4y agoIIRC, “printing mRNA vaccines on demand” was pretty much Moderna’s original startup pitch. Their idea was to create custom cancer vaccines for each patient.
- ITB 4y agoThis. I worry we will exhaust our genetic engines and deteriorate our bodies by overuse.
- grey413 4y agoWell, worry not! Research suggests that the human body can produce up to a quintillion unique antibodies! A vaccine is a drop in a solar-system. https://www.scripps.edu/news-and-events/press-room/2019/20190123-burton-antibodies.html https://www.scripps.edu/news-and-events/press-room/2019/2019...
- lamontcg 4y agoThe immune system has already been dealing with the problem of finite resources for the past 500M years or so. The biggest issue is that circulating neutralizing antibodies take up a finite fraction of the blood. One of the reasons why neutralizing antibodies fade over time is to literally make more space for other antibodies. One of the reasons why you need a boost of a vaccine at least 6 months after the first dose is that somatic hypermutation takes time to develop high affinity neutralizing antibodies that are effective in much small fractions of the blood. Even after that though neutralizing antibodies still tend to fade and what is left is just the memory T-cells and B-cells in lymph tissue. So the immune system naturally activates and deactivates. But this is more like a book on a bookshelf. It isn't really consuming "energy" and there's a massive amount of them that are available. You also need to be much more worried about all the naturally occurring viruses and antigens that you're being exposed to--including the ones that don't actually get you sick at all. You're worrying about the sparring partners of a heavyweight prizefighter "sapping their energy" and ignoring the real opponents. If you've read something about COVID and lympocytopenia ("T-cell exhaustion") then that only happens in severe COVID and shows up in autopsies and is studied as an indicator of how mild (unhospitalized) COVID turns into severe life-threatening COVID. The people who talk about that on social media are literally ignorant idiots who don't know what they're talking about.
- osigurdson 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Influenza#Epidemiology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Influenza#Epidemiology
- karol 4y agoWouldn't do that. Just a gut (bacteria) feeling.
- alonmower 4y agoHaving just got over the hump of a pretty bad flu I picked up traveling over the holidays this can’t come soon enough. I got a flu shot earlier this year so I either picked up a different variant or shudder to think that this experience could have been even worse than it was (three days of 102+ fever). It’s pretty disheartening to see so many comments here questioning the flu vaccine. So much anecdotal fallacy happening here. I would expect numeracy of this audience to be relatively high…
- PaulHoule 4y agoThe flu has always had the strange attribute of being familiar enough that people are not afraid of it, but every 100 years or so it might kill a few million people. On top of that there have been incidents where the risk was oversold (Swine Flu in the 1970#] and the vaccine is problematic. Thanks to a perverse reaction (you tell me to do this so I will not do it) we are going to see uptake of all kinds of vaccine drop. Myself I got the quadrivalent flu shot, my wife didn’t, she got the flu for thanksgiving and was off her feet for three days. I slept next to her the whole time and did not get it. If I had, watching her suffering, I would have called my doc for antivirals at the first sign.
- lamontcg 4y agoThe problem is that most people call a mild cold or even an abortive infection "flu". Actual influenza doesn't happen that commonly to healthy adults and is really unpleasant. Cooking your vitals at 103F for 3 days is also probably not without risk of long-term damage, and there's always some risk of hospitalization even in healthy adults.
- subharmonicon 4y agoCalling every sniffle “the flu” is a bit of a peev of mine. I hear it from people all the time. Based on the descriptions I have read of influenza, I’m relatively certain I have either never had it or have had it maybe once in my adult life. Most years I get a bad cold that lasts 5 days or so (plus some time for my sinuses to completely return to normal) and maybe a couple lesser colds. None of these are “the flu”. I get the flu vaccine every year, but only started that around age 35 or so. I’m in my early 50’s now.
- sfusato 4y ago[flagged]
- consp 4y agoSo the population stayed the same as well?
- susodapop 4y agoThat makes sense to me. The population has increased since 1980 but flu deaths remain constant, which means a lower mortality rate. Presumably there is some correlation between increased flu vaccination rate and decreased mortality rate.
- sfusato 4y agoThe overall better care didn't improved as well though? Are flu cases treated the same way today as 40 years ago? The number of flu shots increased by a factor of x16 over a 40 year period. With these numbers I would've expected a serious dent on the flu deaths graph regardless of population.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The number of flu shots increased by a factor of x16 over a 40 year period. With these numbers I would've expected a serious dent on the flu deaths graph regardless of population. It went from negligible to about 2/3 the population, but the population increased by about 50%. If the vaccine was 50% effective in preventing flu deaths, and there were no other changes (or if better care was exactly offset by increased vulnerability due to aging population) you would expect no change in total deaths. Your intuition just looking at the multiplier on vaccinated population just seems to be a bad intuition.
- sfusato 4y ago> the population increased by about 50% > (or if better care was exactly offset by increased vulnerability due to aging population) Why are you counting the old people twice?
- archsurface 4y agoI don't trust the pharmaceutical industry. I'll take the natural sickness. My perspective has enhanced since seeing my covid vaccinated colleagues regularly miserably sick, and the unvaccinated merely suspect they might have had covid, but barely noticed. I'm not convinced the industry are entirely clear on what they're doing, only approximately. I understand psychiatric drugs are similarly "seems to work, ish". I'm generally unimpressed with the medical industry's progress.
- snshn 4y agoPerfectly said. Medicine is too new of a science, and it's already corrupt beyond repair.
- Terretta 4y ago> I'll take the natural sickness ... unimpressed with progress. If we're going back in time, which would you prefer first: measles, mumps, or rubella? Polio's all natural too.
- archsurface 4y agoYou seem to have lost track of the topic.
- onetokeoverthe 4y ago[dead]
- snshn 4y agoDon't fuck with nature.