3 ms·
That's not really a thing, despite what David Graeber [1] would have you think. The reality is that business owners always want to make as much profit as possi
by crazygringo 4y ago
That's not really a thing, despite what David Graeber [1] would have you think.
The reality is that business owners always want to make as much profit as possible, so they're never going to intentionally or knowingly pay labor for something that is useless, money that would otherwise go straight into their pocket. Sure there are some inefficiencies in the chain and a subset of managers trying to expand headcount unnecessarily because of office politics, but owners and board members are incentivized to eliminate that as much as possible because, you know, profit.
The only plausible spots for "bullshit jobs" are in government and in endowment-funded academia, where for various political reasons, effective oversight of costs is missing in certain scenarios. Usually that's a temporary phenomenon, as eventually a "nosy" journalist (or whistleblower) reveals a bunch of money is being wasted, and political pressure builds to reform that and stop wasting taxpayers' or donors' money.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_job https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_job
- z3t4 4y agoThe larger a company is the more out of touch the owners are, so they are not knowingly leaving money on the table. And larger headcount usually mean higher valuation, so they don't mind. And it might only take a few hours to do the thing the boss hired you for, so the time need to be filled out somehow. Good luck asking your boss if you could go down 50% in time, and keep 100% of the salary.
- Spivak 4y ago> Good luck asking your boss if you could go down 50% in time, and keep 100% of the salary. That’s just the lizard brain mode of thinking. The person you paid $5k to redo your roof isn’t more deserving of the money because they spent two weeks on it instead of one. You’re both better off if they get it done faster. My company went down to 80% time for 100% salary and every metric we use for productivity didn’t change one bit. I have no doubt we could drop another day down to 60% and still have hit all our targets. And anyone who actually works knows why, because the time off isn’t cutting into working time, it’s cutting into bullshit time.
- crazygringo 4y agoTo the contrary, the larger a company is, the more professionalized management becomes, and the more inefficiencies can be eliminated. Lots of economies of scale to be found. And valuation has nothing to do with headcount, that's not how stock market analysts work. They look at revenue and costs and growth. The higher salaries are because of increased headcount, the higher costs are and therefore a lower valuation. If it only takes you a few hours to do the thing the boss hired you for, you can bet they're going to find some more productive work for you real quick. In any business, there's virtually always more profitable work to be done that there are employees to do it, so it's not difficult.
- kweingar 4y ago> The only plausible spots for "bullshit jobs" are in government and in endowment-funded academia You should read Graeber’s book sometime. There are jobs that are useless but still benefit business owners financially. Graeber gives the example of a receptionist at a small firm. The firm had so few callers and visitors that the receptionist was totally unnecessary and sat idle most of the time. Why did they hire her? If the members of the firm answered the phone themselves, they would not be taken seriously. Every serious firm has a receptionist to answer the phone, so they felt they had to hire one. She was essentially there as decoration.
- chii 4y ago> Every serious firm has a receptionist to answer the phone, so they felt they had to hire one. She was essentially there as decoration. looks are sometimes not unimportant nor useless. It's only the hacker mindset that thinks otherwise. "Normal" people do put some importance on appearances. Therefore, it's not useless.
- cton 4y agoI think “useless” is the wrong aspect to focus on. Having someone sit at a desk doing nothing except answer a couple of phone calls sounds terrible. It’s good from the firm’s perspective because they get their receptionist, but the person in that role likely doesn’t get anything more than a pay check out of it.
- chii 4y ago> the person in that role likely doesn’t get anything more than a pay check out of it. but why is there an expectation that they get anything more than a paycheque out of it? It's called a job for a reason.
- cton 4y agoBecause people spend a large portion of their lives at work. I think it’s sad that so many people have to work these kinds of jobs because their talents aren’t monetisable. A person shouldn’t have to justify their need for shelter or food.
- z3t4 4y agoYou can also define bullshit jobs as creating little or no value for society, yet enabling the emplyer to make money.
- deterministic 4y agoBusiness owners usually don’t run companies. They hire “professionals” to do that. And those “professionals” usually care more about their personal gains and personal grandiose feelings than maximising profits long term.