4 ms·
1. After what happened to Russia every planner in China has "the US government seizes our assets" as a plausible in the next 50 years. 2. It is implausible th
by roenxi 4y ago
1. After what happened to Russia every planner in China has
"the US government seizes our assets" as a plausible in the next 50 years.
2. It is implausible that the US will ever pay back its foreign debts in real terms. Anyone who lends to them will end up with less stuff in total.
3. We live in an age of computers and pervasive digital communication; things can happen a lot more quickly these days than in the 50s.
4. There is a consistent trend of dropping energy security in Western countries.
This is no time to be forecasting assuming things will happen at a comfortable pace. People should have contingencies ready in case something unprecedented happens. It is tense out there.
- the_doctah 4y agoWhat kind of contingencies? Money in mattress?
- roenxi 4y agoI've got no particular clue. But if the plan is to assume things happen slowly over 50 years then that is a risky plan. If things play out like in the 1900s, we could see an entire world war play out over 5 years and that'd likely break the US dollar. Or some similar shock. We still don't really understand the impacts of the COVID pandemic and what that is doing in China. > Money in mattress? The response to every crisis the US has had for the last 3 decades is to print and borrow increasingly large amounts money. And they are probably the most responsible fiscal controller around at the moment. If you see that changing for some reason then sure, maybe money under the mattress could help. I don't expect that strategy to change myself, and the last thing I'd want under my mattress is money.
- bee_rider 4y agoWhat does investing with possible WW3 taken into account look like? Heavy on canned food, bullets, and remote real estate I guess? Assuming nuclear weapons don’t just magically vanish.
- nonethewiser 4y agoThe problem is that you have to pick an alternative. The default is probably cash, because that's how you get paid. If you can't even make an argument for an alternative then I think the overwhelmingly historically best option is the obvious decision. Gold is something people often make an argument for in this case but it's historical returns are pretty bad.
- roenxi 4y agoI can make an argument for anything being better than cash including a massive tinned baked bean stockpile. It is quite hard to do worse than cash. > Gold is something people often make an argument for in this case but it's historical returns are pretty bad. I don't follow, gold has been making pretty reasonable returns for about 20 years now and has been a far superior option to cash. What don't you like about it?
- kudokatz 4y ago> People should have contingencies ready in case something unprecedented happens. > What kind of contingencies? Money in mattress? The right to live in multiple countries on a permanent basis (foreign permanent residence and/or passports) and investments that automatically balance as world markets shift over time (e.g. the worldwide equivalent of VTI: VT)
- nonethewiser 4y agoIf a world war causes the US stock market to crash you can be damn sure that the rest of the world is going to have bad time starting from a worse place. Not only are other countries so connected to the US's global economy, but many literally cannot secure trade without US security and US lead organizations.
- cwal37 4y agoActually, over nearly the past two decades, in the US, it has been the opposite of a “consistent trend of dropping energy security.” Considered like a trade balance, since 2019 the net energy balance in the US is positive.
- roenxi 4y agohttps://ourworldindata.org/energy https://ourworldindata.org/energy -> Chart per capita primary energy use -> pick the US -> observe steadily dropping per capita energy use per person since 2000. Down ~20% from peak. That is not a country drowning in cheap energy, that is a coming under a lot of pressure. Not a time to be going "eh, long term trends take a while to kick in". The long term trends have been around for a while, we're well in to the part where we start reaching tipping points and step changes. What is going to happen? Who knows. But it could happen quite quickly.
- lolinder 4y agoSo your argument in support of the claim that the US isn't secure in its energy supplies is that we're using our energy more efficiently than we were before? I can imagine how that could be a second order effect of energy insecurity, but there are other explanations that seem more likely, like: * The move from incandescent to LED lighting * Improved insulation and heating technology * Energy efficient appliances * Removal of inefficient vehicles in favor of more efficient vehicles You're going to have to do better than "per capita energy use is dropping" to convince me there's a looming threat to US energy supplies.
- roenxi 4y agoThe US political situation isn't remotely consistent with it being a country that has just freed up 20% of its energy for alternative uses. It is acting like a country that is being squeezed and has an increasingly desperate underclass that has gotten quite disgruntled. 20% is like having no energy on half of Saturday and all of Sunday. The improvements you listed are not comparable.
- 4y ago
- nonethewiser 4y ago> After what happened to Russia every planner in China has "the US government seizes our assets" as a plausible in the next 50 years. Only if they plan on doing something akin to starting a war against Ukraine.
- patrick451 4y agoI'd rephrase this as only if they plan on doing something the Americans have done themselves many times in recent memory. Which makes predicting what will set off western ire difficult to predict.
- ahyattdev 4y agoThose lending to the US government are doing so by purchasing US Treasury bonds, which have due dates and earn interest. Based on the credit rating of the US government, they will certainly not end up with less in nominal terms.
- gumby 4y agoAlmost all wrong, except #1. #1 is a definite risk, and a more interesting one than just Russian and Chinese "planners." Otherwise your note is nonsense. 2. No sovereign government debt is paid down in real terms over the very long run (this doesn't have to be so, but the data). So why should a non-national buy it? If you buy US debt you get an asset that is supremely liquid and extremely unlikely to default. Over shorter terms from right now it appears likely to outperform other sovereign assets. In very short terms at various times you can make money trading marginal countries' debt (even Argentinian!). But you take on a big risk premium for that! 3. There is so much analysis of technological advances of the 20th century that I won't even bother to try an summarize. WWII began with horse drawn artillery and ended with jet aircraft and ICBMs. My own grandmother was alive from kitty hawk to moon landings and robots spread out through the solar system. Things move frustratingly (for me) slowly these days. 4. Arrant nonsense, with the trend pointing the other way.