3 ms·
If open source code authors (and other content creators) don't want their IP to be used in AI training data sets then they can simply change the license terms t
by nradov 4y ago
If open source code authors (and other content creators) don't want their IP to be used in AI training data sets then they can simply change the license terms to prohibit that use. And if they really want to control how their IP is used then they shouldn't host it on GitHub in the first place. Of course Microsoft is going to look for ways to monetize that data.
- b112 4y agoAnd if they really want to control how their IP is used then they shouldn't host it on GitHub in the first place No. It's called copyright, it is enforceable, and that's the control. GPL source code is available everywhere, in all formats, in textbooks, on CDs, on websites, but it is still gpl. And Microsoft doesn't get to scrub the license.
- b3morales 4y ago> they can simply change the license terms to prohibit that use GitHub's argument* is not that they're following the license but that the license does not apply to their use. So they would continue to ignore any provision that says they can't use the material for training. Previously discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27740001 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27740001 Moving off GitHub is a better step at a practical level. But again they claim the license doesn't matter, so even if it's hosted publicly elsewhere they would (presumably) maintain that they can still scoop it up. It just becomes more work, for them, to do so. *Which is completely wrong in my opinion, for the record