4 ms·
Well, there goes another line of work for actors. Great for people who long to publish their own audiobooks or produce their own radio plays or animated films
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Well, there goes another line of work for actors. Great for people who long to publish their own audiobooks or produce their own radio plays or animated films (the ability to give performance cues is surely not far behind).
Once again, while I'm very much in favor of AI and optimistic about what it can do technologically and the opportunities it creates (more so than most), it's extremely foolish to ignore the fact that it's going to throw a lot of people out of a job through no fault of their own. Vocal performance is a skill, and one that's not all that common. Its facile to blame voice actors for not being software engineers or computer scientists, as if that would have somehow shored up their career options. How is someone supposed to deal with spending years honing a very human expressive skill only to wake up one day and find it suddenly obsolete? I'd say people in that line of work have 1-2 years max before their industry is upended and 50% of them lose 50% of their income.
Also, good luck telling whether the corporate phone line you call is manned by an unhelpful human or an AI that is trying really hard but starting to hate its job.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewstuart 4y agoI find it hard to believe TTS could ever do a better audiobook than an of 10 great narrators who come to mind.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThat's because you are focused on the tiny number of famous performers vs the much larger number of competent-but-not-famous ones. And it's why I said that 50% of industry participants would potentially see a 50% drop in bookings. There will always be standout performers that nobody would want to see replaced by a machine. But if you are not already near the top of your industry/budget segment when automation comes along, you have a problem. Some of those people will be able to move sideways from performance into producing, but that's a very different skillset and many people won't be able to adapt, plus the competitive calculus is very different. I work part-time on the producing side, and I already use AI-based tools for stuff that would previously have required either a human assistant or many hours of editing work. I've been editing audio digitally for 25 years and on tape for 10 before that A lot of output from major producers (eg NPR) is automated as well. I am able to easily recognize the difference between something hand-edited and something automated for right now, but in another 2-3 years I doubt that I will be able to do so reliably.
- squokko 4y agoWhat about the ones other than those 10
- hacker_9 4y agoThey said this when computers were introduced too, now there's more jobs than ever.
- kasajian 4y agoHasn't this been going on since the dawn of time?
- anigbrowl 4y agoNo. This is an unusually abrupt change, because for previous technological changes there wasn't as much infrastructure in place that would allow the market to switch so rapidly. It's just like how we had celebrities and overnight successes in the past, but the phenomenon of 'going viral' wasn't talked about because exponential growth in popularity/notoriety was actually rare.
- woeirua 4y agoTTS has been around forever now, and it still can't replace a human, because to inflect the same way as a human does you have to _understand_ the context of what is being said and what _was_ said previously. We're still quite far away from a TTS synthesizer having the ability to completely replace human voice actors.
- anigbrowl 4y agoTTS was completely ass for a long time. The current models are extremely good, adequate for things like reading news reports or dry prose. I specified that future iterations would probably allow direction cues, in addition to general improvements. We're still quite far away from a TTS synthesizer having the ability to completely replace human voice actors. That's why I specified 50% of voice actors losing 50% of their business, not complete replacement.