2 ms·
The military members consented to this when they joined (along with mandatory vaccinations and many other things) voluntarily. DNA is public data (you're shedd
by dekhn 4y ago
The military members consented to this when they joined (along with mandatory vaccinations and many other things) voluntarily.
DNA is public data (you're shedding it everywhere) although in many research situations, many pseudonymous genomes are available.
Heck, there are even ones tied to individuals; for example, https://my.pgp-hms.org/profile/hu80855C https://my.pgp-hms.org/profile/hu80855C
That's my genome. Google paid for it to be sequenced. I'm David Konerding. Have fun with it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thewebcount 4y ago> The military members consented to this when they joined Did they clarify what time period the DNA covers? We’re all military subjects able to give reasonable consent? If it includes samples from before ~1953, did they even know the significance of what DNA was or how it could be used? > voluntarily I have uncles who served in the military via conscription in the Korean and Vietnamese wars. Is their DNA included? It certainly wasn’t voluntary.
- hilbert42 4y ago"The military members consented to this when they joined..." Even if they did, I'll bet they didn't anticipate the raiding of their DNA and medical records by a pariah corporation. Moreover, I'd lay money that many in the military would strongly object to such collection. If the military were to go ahead with this then it deserves to lose recruiting numbers. — Edit: re your DNA. It's fine if you make a conscious clearheaded decision to put your DNA on line. The fact is that many people will have an absolutely antithetical view about this to you and their views must be respected. Problems arise when people like you who really don't care about privacy are put in charge of making decisions for those who do care. This is not a criticism of you per se but those handling personal data on behalf of others are less likely to value it to the same extent as the owners of said data. That's why rules should be set up at the outset and they must be inviolate. A final point, even though you have put your DNA on line you should do so anonymously as your DNA is a link to your relatives and it's highly likely that some of them will have antithetical views to you about the matter—you need to respect their privacy and wishes.