6 ms·
Ah I was wondering how something like this could go ahead when it's pretty obviously a terrible idea to engineers. > SSPP got its start in 2011 after philanthr
by IshKebab 4y ago
Ah I was wondering how something like this could go ahead when it's pretty obviously a terrible idea to engineers.
> SSPP got its start in 2011 after philanthropist Donald Bren, chairman of Irvine Company and a lifetime member of the Caltech Board of Trustees, learned about the potential for space-based solar energy manufacturing in an article in the magazine Popular Science. Intrigued by the potential for space solar power, Bren approached Caltech's then-president Jean-Lou Chameau to discuss the creation of a space-based solar power research project. In 2013, Bren and his wife, Brigitte Bren, a Caltech trustee, agreed to make the donation to fund the project. The first of the donations to Caltech (which will eventually exceed $100 million in support for the project and endowed professorships) was made that year through the Donald Bren Foundation, and the research began.
"Ok nobody tell him it's a bad idea and we get like 50 PhDs and 5 professors!"
- p1esk 4y agoYou forgot to explain why this is "pretty obviously a terrible idea".
- thisisbrians 4y agoSome ideas about what makes it challenging: - A satellite will have to transmit power through the entire atmosphere from space, which will have substantial losses even in perfect conditions - A satellite constellation in orbit would need many ground stations to transmit power to from space - Weather will get in the way of transmission to the ground, just like it does with ordinary solar - The cost of getting a PV array into orbit is very expensive relative to the amount of power it can generate and transmit
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> satellite will have to transmit power through the entire atmosphere from space, which will have substantial losses even in perfect conditions Balancing this is at least a half an order of magnitude difference in collection efficiency. > Weather will get in the way of transmission to the ground, just like it does with ordinary solar True. But there are extraterrestrial atmospheres where water vapor and ozone aren’t a problem. (I’ve only seen this proposed with microwave.) > cost of getting a PV array into orbit is very expensive relative to the amount of power it can generate and transmit This is the killer. That said, this is a long-term research endeavour. If we contemplate such an array around the Moon or on Mars, or in a world with in-space resource extraction and manufacturing, the economics shift.
- feoren 4y ago> half an order of magnitude Completely off-topic, but would "half an order of magnitude" be sqrt(10)? I've just never heard someone refer to a factor of ~3 as "half an order of magnitude".
- roelschroeven 4y agoSqrt(10) is approximately 3.162278, that's close enough to 3.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> just never heard someone refer to a factor of ~3 as "half an order of magnitude" Last time I looked, the estimates ranged from 270% to 50x. Seeing the latter, my brain went into astronomer mode and then I guess just ran with it.
- LarryMullins 4y ago> If we contemplate such an array around the Moon or on Mars, or in a world with in-space resource extraction and manufacturing, the economics shift. The economics of anything on Mars or the Moon amounts to 'try to convince a government to throw tons of money at you.' A technology which only makes sense in that economic context is very limited.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> technology which only makes sense in that economic context is very limited If this were a start-up I’d be roundly criticising it. It’s not. It’s a research project. And each of its sub-projects—testing new PVs in space, a novel deployment mechanism, power transmission—has clear value outside a space-based solar context. As a focussing mechanism, SBSP is neat because each problem needing to be solved to make it economically viable is immediately valuable on the ground. (Save for power transmission. That’s still niche.)
- p1esk 4y agoNone of these seem like obvious show stoppers.
- josh11b 4y agohttps://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/08/20/space-based-solar-power-is-not-a-thing/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/08/20/space-based-so...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- IshKebab 4y agoEven ignoring the power transmission challenges, putting stuff in orbit is really really expensive. Surely you knew that?
- DennisP 4y agoFor now. But if SpaceX succeeds in getting launch costs below $50/kg with Starship, space solar starts looking a lot more attractive. Advertised price on Falcon Heavy is already just $600/kg to LEO. A big part of that is the throwaway upper stage, which Starship eliminates.
- IshKebab 4y agoFalcon Heavy is around $2300/kg to LEO. Not sure where you got $600 from. I'm sure Starship will be better, but 40 times cheaper? I doubt it.
- DennisP 4y agoJust checked and the answer splits the difference. $97M for a Heavy launch, divided by 63,800 kg payload to LEO gives $1520/kg. I think my $600 must have been per pound (though that's still a bit off, at the current price). https://www.spacex.com/media/Capabilities&Services.pdf https://www.spacex.com/media/Capabilities&Services.pdf The biggest cost is throwing away hardware. If you're not doing that, you can amortize your entire hardware cost over the number of launches. At Falcon's launch cadence that's still going to be significant. But Starship is designed to do hundreds of launches per year, and if they manage it then hardware cost per launch is almost nothing. Then you're mainly paying for fuel and ground services, which are about a million dollars each. 100 tonnes to LEO for $2M gives just $20/kg, leaving plenty of margin for SpaceX at $50. It might seem hard to envision putting that much cargo into space every year, but if we did solar power satellites at scale, that's exactly what we'd need.
- IshKebab 4y ago> $97M for a Heavy launch, divided by 63,800 kg payload to LEO No, $97M is for a launch with reused boosters. 63,800 kg to LEO is when the boosters are dispended.
- cratermoon 4y agohttps://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/
- ablatt89 4y agoPretty funny how often when one brings up engineering challenges to solar, the challenges are ignored or handwaved. There's not even a back of the envelope calculation to prove the solution is scalable, maintainable, or cost effective the solution, it's all just feel good, "cool" factor, "saving the world" factor that's used to argue for investigation.
- alex_duf 4y agoYou mean solar in space specifically right? Because solar back on earth makes a lot of sense, whereas solar back in space to beam down on earth make no sense.
- ablatt89 4y agoSolar on earth makes sense in some contexts, but there's questions of how it's not scalable, clean up methods, local climate effects, is intermittent and causes the power grid instability. These are fair questions that should be looked at and solar on earth is not some solution to the problem of gas without tradeoffs, but these questions and concerns are usually ignored. https://www.nrel.gov/news/features/2020/renewables-rescue-stability-as-the-grid-loses-spin.html https://www.nrel.gov/news/features/2020/renewables-rescue-st... These concerns are not really brought up by the media.
- IshKebab 4y agoI don't think they're ignored exactly. They're just not really significant problems compared to the greenhouse emissions of gas or coal power. It's like how virtual keyboards on smartphones are not as good as a full physical keyboard (arguably) but nobody really talks about it anymore because the disadvantages of physical keyboards are so overwhelming that it doesn't matter.
- ablatt89 4y agoI don't think that comparison is fair at all. You're comparing concerns of a technology and how it scales, to how no one talks about physical keyboards and smart phones? That's not even remotely the same and is pretty dishonest to make that comparison. The problems of solar as a scalable renewable are very fair to talk about, considering that Africa and India NEED energy to grow their societies. The only solutions that scale are oil or nuclear. The idea you can just hand wave any concerns about renewables doesn't seem very rationale if you genuinely care about the problem.