3 ms·
While I appreciate the sentiment, nearly all new knowledge goes through peer review because for every important problem in academia, there's a competitor who is
by dekhn 4y ago
While I appreciate the sentiment, nearly all new knowledge goes through peer review because for every important problem in academia, there's a competitor who is the best person to point out problems with the theory.
"Holistic management of agriculture to fight desertification" is a non-quantitative science and falls under a very different regime from, say, people working at the state of the art in particle physics or biology.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scifibestfi 4y agoMost scientific breakthroughs in history did not go through peer review. That's a new consensus mechanism that was introduced not that long ago. Einstein was only subject to it once and didn't pass. Newton, Galileo and the rest were not subject to it at all.
- dekhn 4y agoI'm not defending peer review; I never enjoyed it when I published. It certainly never made my papers any better. Newton and others all published and then discussed the details in person, a lot of the peer review was "off-paper" and "post-publication". Also, the vast majority of scientific breakthroughs, by count, occurred after peer review- mainly due to the unbelievable pace of breakthroughs due to technological advancement.
- cma 4y agoThat sounded interesting so I looked into it. It seems to instead support peer review. According to this [1], Einstein's paper that didn't pass peer review turned out to be wrong (it said gravitational waves didn't exist), and was later published elsewhere with different conclusions and fixing problems that the referee's report had already pointed out. > The irony, of course, is that Einstein could have found that escape route months earlier, simply by reading the referee’s report that he had dismissed so hastily. The referee had also observed that casting the Einstein–Rosen metric (as we now call this solution of the Einstein equations) in cylindrical coordinates removes the apparent difficulty. [1] https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.2117822 https://physicstoday.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.2117822
- mistermann 4y ago> While I appreciate the sentiment, nearly all new knowledge goes through peer review... Only knowledge that originates in academia, and even then only a portion of it. > because for every important problem in academia, there's a competitor who is the best person to point out problems with the theory. While this may be generally true, it is not absolutely true. > "Holistic management of agriculture to fight desertification" is a non-quantitative science... Partially non-quantitative. Also: it'a (partially) true, but so what? > ...and falls under a very different regime from, say, people working at the state of the art in particle physics or biology. Right: one is known to be important, and the others are (at this point in time) hoped to be important (as they have been in the past).