19 ms·
Pornhub users in Louisiana now have to submit government ID to access the site
- user3939382 4y ago[flagged]
- saboot 4y agoThat's a pretty bold way to describe the state of Louisiana
- selimthegrim 4y agoI live here, I’ll allow it
- allthebestforus 4y agoAre you referring to government and politicians?
- michaelmcdonald 4y agoCan you provide the evidence / proof of Satan's involvement?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 0x4974h 4y ago[flagged]
- user3939382 4y agoWhatever helps you sleep at night.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoSatan. Satan helps me sleep at night.
- bhouston 4y agoWhile you are downvoted and you are speaking metaphorically, but there is still a lot of scum in this industry and exploited women. For example, isn't this what Andrew Tate is charged with? Basically tricking girls into joining his crew using the so-called "Lover Boy" strategy and then forcing them to do porn/camgirl/onlyfans? That is what I read anyhow: https://www.insider.com/andrew-tate-tiktok-explains-loverboy-method-he-is-accused-of-2023-1 https://www.insider.com/andrew-tate-tiktok-explains-loverboy...
- stirfish 4y agoWhat's a Satan?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- timeon 4y agoLike God, Satan is not real.
- belval 4y ago> age verification for any website that contains 33.3 percent or more pornographic material (a digression: we're seeing a strong opportunity here for sites featuring only 33.2 percent pornographic material). So what they can just add a bunch of free content that isn't porn and get away with it? Seems like a poorly thought-out law.
- PicassoCTs 4y agoNow, offering free hosting, if willing to sharelinkparts with a porn site.
- ptero 4y agoCreate some files of random numbers "for users that want to leverage those instead of running a local RNG" or some such. Text files (for counting percents), compressed (for local storage). Practically zero network costs. Or offer to serve "a stream of 'y' answers" for the users who do not want to depend on running a local "yes" utility. Count size uncompressed. Compress with a special "char number_of_repeats" algorithm. I wonder if this is enough to go past the current politician class...
- bombcar 4y agoIt might get past the politicians but judges in general are not a fan of this kind of "technical" workaround for the spirit of the law. Easier would be just to sponsor a you-tube like competitor/hosting service for video files, especially if the 33% is defined by space not access (if the politicals were smart it would be something like minutes of access time so they don't just get 68% of their SSDs filled with CSPAN).
- naasking 4y agoHow is "percentage content" calculated? By number of links? That's easy to game. By byte size? Pornhub would have to become YouTube to balance the amount of porn.
- VikingCoder 4y ago
- galleywest200 4y agoIm curious how this is going to be calculated. Is 33% of Reddit NSFW? Possibly. Do they ban Reddit without government ID? Talk about a conservative nanny state why don't you.
- KMnO4 4y agoIf there’s a way we can get Reddit to >33% I’d love to help. Let’s watch the policymakers struggle when they have to explain when you need to upload your drivers license to view /r/cats. Nothing helps fight stupid laws more than when they get in the way of regular people doing completely unrelated things.
- lode 4y ago> Let’s watch the policymakers struggle when they have to explain when you need to upload your drivers license to view /r/cats. Or maybe you'll need to upload 5 cat pictures (to keep it <33%) to view /r/nsfw
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anonporridge 4y agoMeh. They'll just carve an exception for sites that serve user uploaded content to gate specific communities that host porn. Reddit already does this, so it would be trivial for them to add an ID check for NSFW subreddits.
- nhatcher 4y agoReddit is banned here in Indonesia for that reason.
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoYou know...Louisiana's state legislature probably publishes an official record of their proceedings (the Federal equivalent would be the Congressional Record). It'd be a real shame/freaking hilarious if some legislator entered thousands of pages of erotica into the record, pushing an edition of it over the 33.3% threshold.
- twiclo 4y agoI'm certain that we're going to see plenty of comments about how this is terrible for privacy and it's an attack of free speech but we've had limits on porn forever. People didn't consider it a privacy violation if they were carded for buying a pornographic magazine and I'm certain everyone here would not suggest children should be allowed to purchase such magazines. Why should it be any different online? Yes it's scary what companies could do with this sensitive information and we should try our best to legislate against abuse of these details. It's possible. Bars have the ability to collect thousands of people's driver's license information and we haven't seen much of a security risk there. The fact of the matter is porn is accessible to children within seconds and for the last 30 years we have done virtually nothing to try to prevent it. We know that porn is harmful, especially to children, and we have done NOTHING to try to prevent it. I'm okay with adults being inconvenienced if it means we can protect children. That's a standard we've had in America for generations.
- lode 4y ago> We know that porn is harmful [Citation needed]
- twiclo 4y ago[flagged]
- micromacrofoot 4y agoBars verify your ID, they don't record it
- twiclo 4y agoPornhub doesn't have to record it. Bars could record it and so could PH.
- 12345hn6789 4y agoIn order to foster faithful discussion on this site we enjoy citations. Do you have any for your parent comment? You make many bold claims but do not have any research to back it up.
- themanmaran 4y agoAnd just like that, Nord VPN will see a huge spike in Louisiana users.
- eatsyourtacos 4y agoAside from the absolute absurdity of this.. especially from one of the states that value "freedom" more than anything else cough cough. How does this even work legally? If pornhub is not physically located in Lousiana but only accessible from there.. why do they even have to comply with this law? What would be consequences of not doing so? Would the only result be that Lousiana ISPs be forced to block them?
- seanw444 4y agoIn which case, I can see the how-to videos popping up already: "How to Unblock PH In 10 Minutes! (VPN)"
- commandlinefan 4y agoThe same people who think this is a good idea are bound to think that banning VPNs (to save the children) is also a good idea.
- brookst 4y agoPornhub just doesn’t want the hassle of a legal fight or PR-centric indictments from grandstanding politicians. Easier to block a state that probably contributes little revenue and (per pornhub stats) just stresses the trans porn servers.
- psychphysic 4y agoIf it's like the UKs proposals then MindGeek (PornHub owner) will have the good to go super private honest, ID portal. Plus they've lost a strong of these. Mostly from hedge funds that invest in visa/MasterCard turn out to be the source of morality. Like Bill Ackerman [0] already did with PornHub. [0] https://www.businessinsider.co.za/amp/bill-ackman-pornhub-millions-unauthorized-video-removed-mastercard-visa-2021-6 https://www.businessinsider.co.za/amp/bill-ackman-pornhub-mi...
- vxNsr 4y ago
- hoppersoft 4y agoIf you're browsing in Louisiana, expect to see the ads for VPN providers get a bit racier...
- RalfWausE 4y agoOk... now everyone moves on to the next porn site.
- fknorangesite 4y ago> the next porn site ...also owned by MindGeek.
- red16 4y ago[flagged]
- fknorangesite 4y agoFar be it from me to defend MindGeek, but how about you keep your antisemitism to yourself.
- seydor 4y agoI have an idea about an identity theft website, any visionary investors?
- bikeformind 4y agoLet’s play the unintended downstream consequences of misguided policy game… No fapper in their right mind is submitting their ID to pornhub to have a wank. This will just drive users to smaller, shadier sites that don’t comply with local regulations. These sites will contain more harmful or exploitative content, and their increased traffic will incentivize and facilitate a continued cycle of exploitation and abuse.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoA. Don’t let perfect be the enemy of good. B. Criminally investigate noncompliance.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoWhen you say "good" what are you referring to here? Because limiting access by ways of privacy invading policies seems to be just "bad".
- gjsman-1000 4y ago[flagged]
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoOK, so the "good" in this case being making it more onerous to access a legal product and making it more likely that said consumers of product will have their personally identifying information stolen due to a particular extreme philosophical bent, got it. I'm going to say I vehemently disagree with your stance on this, but I don't think it's worthwhile for either of us to engage. Edit 1: > My views would've been considered normal, rational, and reasonable for almost everyone but the latest generation of porn addicts. There's been pornography in some way, shape or form as long as there's been media to record it. There's been videos since the invention of film - prudes did their best to shut it down. Want to expand on what your "views" are? Because the ones you've expressed so far have been radical as far back as I'm aware of. > If you want me to consider your opinion valid, I challenge you to take 1 year without viewing it, and then reconsider. This seems very on brand to try to force others to take your stance just to engage with you. Edit 2: My last response on this as I abhor this "edit to respond" format. I can't read the article, it's behind a paywall, but your initial argument: > I’m going to be honest and say that I believe pornography is a level of sexual exploitation that no person, not even the actors involved, should be considered capable of legally consenting to partake in. Does not in any way, shape, or form align with this argument: > I believe, at this point, that pornography is actually increasing the subjection of women and increasing misogyny towards them, and there are actually many feminists who agree with me on this view. In fact that first seems to be infantilizing the performers by literally saying that the women and men taking part aren't capable of making their own decisions. It's absurd that a woman can't be considered capable of consent to being photographed nude, and it's ridiculous to hide that stance behind "porn is misogyny".
- RunSet 4y agoPornhub should redirect traffic from Louisiana to a page that includes names and contact information of the politicians that sponsored the legislation. Here they are: https://legiscan.com/LA/sponsors/HB142/2022 https://legiscan.com/LA/sponsors/HB142/2022
- inglor 4y agoThat's a very risky move on their part for something I'm not sure is even _actually_ bad from their perspective. "Oh, we just _have_ to have this system in place that makes you identify, we don't collect your data _right now_ but now that we know who you are anyway and you're no longer anonymous - why not sign up to our subscription service?" Is making the website more work to use for free users which makes them stay around less and thus convert (later) less bad or is the extra data worth it?
- psychphysic 4y agoNah, it'll be reasonable to have a "why" blog post. And then listing cosponsors is entirely reasonable. Even PornHub benefits from it, they benefit from appearing to not want your data.
- abirch 4y agoThey have my data in fact they know people in my neighborhood who want to...
- hutzlibu 4y agoIt is bad for them, as most people likely will go somewhere else then, before providing ID. Porn sites aren't exactly rare content and hard to find on the internet.
- Manuel_D 4y agoI'm not so sure. It was never really anonymous if you weren't paying with crypto. And even if you were, it was still non anonymous if you bought your crypto off Coinbase or another legit exchange. Realistically there's not much to be had by obtaining information on PH's customers. "Hey! This guy... watches porn! Can you believe it!?" Reminds me of this gif [1]. I guess if someone is a hardcore anti-porn Mormon or something, then it might be leverage. But for the vast majority of people, I doubt consumption of adult media is a big reputation hit. 1. https://media.tenor.com/zvWORVx2xzcAAAAC/jurassic-park-no-one-cares.gif https://media.tenor.com/zvWORVx2xzcAAAAC/jurassic-park-no-on...
- chunk_waffle 4y agoHow are they even going to enforce this? There's probably millions of porn sites out there, and 99% of them are not even going to be aware of this law and not care if they do, especially in the case of foreign owned sites. This really just punishes the biggest sites that are aware and try to play by the rules (e.g. pornhub.) Why go to a site that requires verification when you can choose one of hundreds of thousands that won't.
- ttyprintk 4y agoEnforcement will start by making a dramatic example. Probably a loudly-publicized trans storyline.
- jesuscript 4y agoWho knows, this might be 3d chess by lobbyist. They might be carving out a porn lobby, where porn sites have to shell out money to the crooked system to stop these laws.
- silent_cal 4y agoFamilies will be allowed to sue the porn companies if their kids are exposed to pornography on their websites.
- ttyprintk 4y agoAnd in doing so, they get to make a public argument for the moral justification of monetary damages. The cynic in me expects Puritanical groups in America want those damages to reflect a judgement on deviance or pronouns.
- cowsup 4y agoEnforcement is not the job of the politicians. They just write the "Save the Children" laws and then go out and pat themselves on the back to their constituents.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoAre there really millions of porn sites out there? Doesn't MindGeek own like the majority of porn traffic online? Even given the volume of sites I'd easily bet the vast majority of traffic goes to a relatively small number of sites.
- popilewiz 4y ago[dead]
- inglor 4y agoAdding these laws that can be easily bypassed (in this case by using a VPN or providing someone else's ID) only encourages corruption and moves money to extra parties (in this case, VPNs most likely). Instead - why not invest that money/time in making education about a healthy sexual life available and to people? In general, approaches that are "let's prevent minors from doing X by telling them not to while still making it easy to do anyway" are bad, make kids feel talked down to and push them to understanding sexuality through porn which is what they're trying to avoid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- morisy 4y agoText of the law: https://legis.la.gov/legis/ViewDocument.aspx?d=1289498 https://legis.la.gov/legis/ViewDocument.aspx?d=1289498 Gives private parties (including parents) ability to sue for damages, versus criminal penalties. Not sure how it plays with interstate commerce clause, etc. Also gives similar rights to sue if ID information is retained or used for anything beyond confirming age.
- pjc50 4y ago[flagged]
- takoid 4y agoIt's also how Alex Jones was punished for his Sandy Hook conspiracy theories.
- alphabettsy 4y agoSort of. The distinct difference being that he targeted those families with his comments to begin with by saying they were actors, etc.
- pjc50 4y agoLibel law has a much longer legal history.
- cvalka 4y agoNo, it's not a hack against the 1st amendment. Any private party action is constrained by the 1ST amendment. It's a well resolved question. The unanswered question is what the limits are to out of state state power? It's a billion dollar question.
- charonn0 4y agoPrivate lawsuits can seek relief that otherwise would be beyond the state's power under the 1st Amendment. For example, speech itself can be penalized by a court if it violates a non-disclosure agreement.
- jacobyoder 4y agoHow does this work in the context of 'private' mode? This is something I assume a lot of folks would use for adult content. Do they have to verify each time? I've no doubt some people make accounts and stay 'logged in' to PH and similar sites, but I suspect a much larger set of folks browse in private mode without an account.
- incone123 4y agoOnce a gov id is linked to a user id then I'd only expect to need a user id to login again in private mode. I'm assuming they store it in case the gov needs to audit people's porn preferences.
- vorpalhex 4y agoThey aren't supposed to store the ID. Instead just a "has_verified=true" sort of flag.
- kpz6 4y agopoor residents of Louisiana [*]
- thepasswordis 4y agoI don't understand why people think this is a bad thing except unless they think children should be watching porn? We could argue over the implementation of it, and worry about the downstream consequences, but then shouldn't the argument be: how to accomplish this without those effects? If there was a guy on your block constantly trying to lure children into his house to show them porn, or even a guy on your block who was flashing himself at your children, you would find that objectionable (I hope). But it's okay for pornhub to do this because it's online? Why? I think this is good. I know that's probably a dissenting opinion here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- polishdude20 4y agoI think in this case, Pornhub isn't "luring" your kids to do anything. In any case, the parents can always put up a website blocker. If the kid continues to try and get on the website and even finds a way to disable the blocker, is that PornHub "luring" ?
- throw_pm23 4y ago[flagged]
- friedman23 4y agoPornographic content is too accessible. It's impossible for the parents to police this, there will always be one kid with negligent parents that will expose other children to this crap. We are talking 10 year olds here, it's already happening.
- silent_cal 4y agoYep
- polishdude20 4y agoWe can create cases where blockers aren't effective till we're blue in the face. At some point, the measures taken to prevent this start to do more harm to other parts of the population than good. My belief is we've slowly let parents get away with not actually parenting and moved that job over to the government and other institutions. There's many more ways to tackle this that may be more effective and actually seek to educate. How about start with some educational content on why porn is bad for young minds and how to talk to your child about it in a mature way? It's like nobody wants to acknowledge the elephant in the room and have a civil and mature discussion about it with their children because it's awkward or uncomfortable.
- silent_cal 4y agoThis is great news, I’ve been wanting to see this for a long time. Kids are exposed to pornography extremely young now and it can ruin their lives. If it were up to me I would hold the companies criminally liable for it, but this is a good start.
- silent_cal 4y ago[flagged]
- graypegg 4y agoMate, this isn't reddit. Participate.
- silent_cal 4y agoOkay, why don’t you think the government should try to protect kids from porn?
- alexb_ 4y agoThis is such an insane and obvious misrepresentation. It's about the second order effects that come from said protection. When you give people information or power, you must assume that everyone with said pwoer is using it as maliciously as possible (and knowing Louisiana, that can likely happen). Should the government have a log of every single person who has ever seen gay porn? Do you really think that information will be used responsibly?
- silent_cal 4y agoSo would you support legislation that legally requires the companies to verify the age of its users in some other way? By the way, checking ID is the way this is done for all other age-restricted activities already. But maybe you have a better idea?
- mrits 4y ago
- friedman23 4y agoI don't know about the implementation here but it's too easy for young people to access pornography. I know teachers and I hear horror stories of 10 year old boys being caught in the bathroom watching elderly porn. It just seems impossible for kids to grow up without the over sexualization of everything nowadays. Porn stars are becoming video game streamers because they know their target demographic is young teens. We are doing an insane social experiment with the next generation.
- irrational 4y agoOne thing I didn’t see addressed in the article is how they know you live in LA, or, even in the USA (in the case of Mike Lee’s wanting to take this national)? It’s not like ip addresses are conclusive proof of where you are located.
- pjc50 4y agoWill this apply to 4chan?
- salemh 4y agoGood! As a former hedonist, I also used to defend pornography with the zealousness of the inquisition - which many of these comments show. Dig beneath the surface, and you'll see the rot. This isn't even speaking of the poor teenagers who have ED in their teen years from destroying their endocrine systems, or being mutiliated by dopamine addiction. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5039517/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5039517/ Meanwhile, you can read the studies showing upticks of sexual violence among children and TEENAGERS assisted by this "freedom" of pornograpy with no limits. Understanding a Context of Risk: Pornography and Child Sexual Abuse https://osf.io/kf4uv/download/?format=pdf https://osf.io/kf4uv/download/?format=pdf One of the most troubling patterns emerging in the research relates to the increasing number of younger children (under the ages of 12-14) involved in perpetrating child sexual assault. Clinical and legal studies are reporting greater numbers of preteen children demonstrating interpersonal problematic sexual behaviors that intrude on the physical space and security of other children (Friedrich et al., 2006; Swisher et al., 2008). <> Most relevant to the purpose of this paper is the role of exposure to sexually explicit media as one of the explanatory variables in child sexual abuse. A meta-analysis of 22 studies demonstrates that exposure to pornography, particularly violent pornography, is significantly associated with increased rates of sexual aggression in the general population (Wright et al., 2016). Given that the average age of first exposure to pornography is age 11 (Wolak et al., 2006), it is important to begin to consider what role, if any, pornography may play in child sexual abuse, particular if perpetrated by children. Several studies have included sexually explicit media as a contributing factor for child-perpetrated sexual abuse. The Association Between Exposure to Violent Pornography and Teen Dating Violence in Grade 10 High School Students https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6751001/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6751001/ Exposure to pornography in general has been linked with adolescent dating violence and sexual aggression, but less is known about exposure to violent pornography specifically. The current study examined the association of violent pornography exposure with different forms of teen dating violence (TDV) using baseline survey data from a sample of Grade 10 high school students who reported being in a dating relationship in the past year (n = 1694) A Meta-Analysis of Pornography Consumption and Actual Acts of Sexual Aggression in General Population Studies https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/jcom.12201 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/jcom.12201 Is pornography consumption correlated with committing actual acts of sexual aggression? 22 studies from 7 different countries were analyzed. Consumption was associated with sexual aggression in the United States and internationally, among males and females, and in cross-sectional and longitudinal studies. Associations were stronger for verbal than physical sexual aggression, although both were significant. The general pattern of results suggested that violent content may be an exacerbating factor.
- womenhumantoo 4y ago[flagged]
- say_it_as_it_is 4y agoPresenting ID is fine when verification is done by a trusted third party that doesn't retain the information and simply passes an authorization token on. It becomes a problem when the ID is parsed and PII is tracked / monetized / exploited.
- womenhumantoo 4y agoThen choose your actions wisely. Is that urge to tug one out to pornographic crime scenes really so vital that you're willing to share your PII with some sketchy website? For decent guys, certainly not.
- blue17 4y ago[dead]
- classified 4y agoSubtitle should be "Blunders of a Bigot Nanny State".
- kradroy 4y agoSpeaking as a former employee of a large adult content network, and as someone who bent laws in my frequent (oh so frequent) searches for porn as a teenager, this law will be about as effectual as Louisiana's public schooling.
- ElfinTrousers 4y ago[flagged]
- complianceowl 4y ago[flagged]
- TheFreim 4y agoThis is a great start. Anything that limits access to pornography, which abuses both the "actors" and "consumers", is always good. Some, especially on a site such as this, bring up that it can be easily bypassed or that someone can switch to different sites. This is true to an extent, but it also undeniably adds one more barrier, one more annoyance, in consumption of destructive "adult" films. Furthermore, if enacted properly, this will discourage access by young children who don't have much knowledge about computers yet.
- lilboiluvr69 4y agoWhat about furry porn? Does that abuse anyone? Do you find fuzzy animals having sex to be dangerous to children too?
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoWhy can't children just enter strip clubs or watch their parents have sex? Is there no harm there? Why is there age verification to buy porn magazines? Why does it being digital make it different?
- nmz 4y agoDoes that mean that you get to watch your parents have sex when you reach adulthood?
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoMaybe a more apt analogy: why can't children watch 2 consenting adult strangers have sex? Why can't they enter a strip club? Why does a digital screen between them and the action make it acceptable?
- TheFreim 4y agoYes, it does abuse people. I do not think any reasonable person thinks it's good for children to be watching sexualized, humanoid, animals engaging in various sexual acts as being okay. I don't think it's good for adults either as it blurs the line and promotes depravity, encouraging attraction to animals or animalistic things.
- say_it_as_it_is 4y agoYou may notice that an identity verification provider, such as ID.me, gets an exclusive contract to act as the sole identity service that everyone must use as part of the draconian porn workflow. You should also look to see the relationship that Louisiana legislators have with the identity provider, what their lobbying contributions were.
- slibhb 4y agoI don't really understand the uproar in the comments. Socially conservative states should have socially conservative laws (like this). Ditto for liberal states. If it's unpopular or LA ceases to be socially conservative, democracy will fix it.
- d23 4y ago> I don't really understand the uproar in the comments > If it's unpopular or LA ceases to be socially conservative, democracy will fix it. You don't understand the uproar but argue uproar will fix it?
- slibhb 4y agoSomehow I doubt HN commenters and voters in Louisiana are a similar demographic... My point was that, if you disagree with this law and don't live in Louisiana, your attitude should be "those crazy conservatives!" plus an eyeroll and not "they're trampling our rights!"
- d23 4y agoIt seems like you're making up a strawman. Who here is claiming their rights are being trampled that doesn't live in the state? Also, it is possible to have concern for that which is outside one's own direct interest.
- was_a_dev 4y agoI'd take the argument that's what the electorate voted for. Why else would they vote for a conservative party if they didn't want conservative laws?
- d_e_solomon 4y agoOur system is setup so that the government - even elected via a democratic process - can't trample over certain rights.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
- yehaaa 4y agoWhy not work to standardise an adult content HTML meta tag and do the same for DNS. Now sites that are tagged as adult content can be blocked at device and router level by the end user.
- vorpalhex 4y agoThere already is a standard! Many porn sites comply with it! https://www.rtalabel.org/ https://www.rtalabel.org/
- parasense 4y agoSounds like a funny idea. Create a variant of PH where 70% of the content is pictures of LA politicians, where the other 30% is porn, ideally the gay/trans porn category. Sorry gays, it's nothing personal on your specific kink, it's more to do with their (LA politicians) aversion to those kinks, or whatever... hopefully you get the point. Also, what is to prevent people in surrounding states from setting-up forwarding proxies, or folks using a VPN? What about pornographic t-shirts? Like, wearing a t-shirt with some porn action, done artistically as to not be entirely obscene, say for example some henti-tenticle action.... covering 70% of the t-shirt. Does the person wearing that get to demand the ID of anybody walking down the street alongside them? lol
- goldenchrome 4y agoDumb law but porn is degenerate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- flotzam 4y agoIronically they've half broken pornhub.com for Tor users by previously setting up an onion service http://pornhubvybmsymdol4iibwgwtkpwmeyd6luq2gxajgjzfjvotyt5zhyd.onion http://pornhubvybmsymdol4iibwgwtkpwmeyd6luq2gxajgjzfjvotyt5z... which has now been down for months, but some (most?) of their servers are still HTTP 301 redirecting Tor users from .com to the defunct .onion
- LinuxBender 4y agoThis is the wrong way to limit porn to adults. For ages there has been a single line HTTP header that can be added to a site or even to the meta-data in HTML itself to identify adult content. A law could require all user-content sites to implement the header and require all browser apps, operating systems, mobile devices to make a best-effort attempt and requiring a parental control system that approve-lists domains that have the adult content header. A panel of the best UX designers in the industry could draft the RFC for device/browser updates and the law could reference the RFC. A panel of parents could test the beta versions. This way people can't really say "Its too technically hard to enable parental controls". This could even become part of the device setup such as buying a new phone and going through the setup menu. "Enable parental controls? Y/n" If "Yes" then the setup guides the parent through creating accounts for kids and lets them choose whether or not to allow user-generated/adult content per account. In NGinx it looks like this: location / { add_header Rating 'RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-RTA'; } In HAProxy it looks like this: http-response set-header Rating "RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-RTA" I do not know how to add this to Envoy or Caddy. This puts the control and liability of the approval on the parent and they don't even need to be technically savvy at all. This also puts the liability to self-label a site on the site owner/administrator and they can each have instructions in a standard location on the site how to enable parental controls in apps/devices after such a law requires devices to have this functionality created in a standard and simple way that just looks for the header. Despite being meant for adult content there is nothing stopping this from being used for user-generated content domains. The end goal would simply be to provide a method of parental controls per domain or globally. Most important, this method provides zero tracking of who is into what and does not leak financial or PII data. How to enforce this? Crawlers find user generated site, people submit user generated sites. No header? 3 attempts are made to contact the domains admin/technical contact. 4th attempt domain(s) are seized. Domain outside of the U.S. and that government will not cooperate? Sanctions. It's a big hammer but it works. Could a determined teen get around this? Sure, the same teen that would use a parents credit card or the card of a stranger. In my proposed method credit card fraud is taken out of the picture and people do not have to leak real names.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI forgot to add, some sites already use this. [1] [1] - https://www.shodan.io/search?query=RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-RTA https://www.shodan.io/search?query=RTA-5042-1996-1400-1577-R...
- blue17 4y ago[dead]
- nerdjon 4y agoOn paper this itself isn't necessarily a bad idea. Just like saying you need an ID to buy alcohol isn't a bad idea. BUT we all know damn well this is not about protecting the children. This is about further stigmatizing sex and porn because this country has such a backwards view on sex. We already do this with alcohol, kids (and adults) spend 21 years being shown how special alcohol is and and how "bad" it is and its no wonder 21 year olds are known for their benders here. We need to stop raising seriously repressed kids that have no idea how the world actually works, or get all of their actual information from the internet because their schools sure as hell are not teaching them about sex. Does the porn industry have issues? Yes... so does every other single industry. If we really want to go down that path than we should outlaw video games, the movie industry (I mean that industry had Weinstein!). (This is sarcasm if it isn't obvious). We also can't ignore the major privacy issues with collecting this data and how this could theoretically be used for other issues, particularly if tied to watching Gay porn.
- noabuseplease 4y ago[dead]
- bradlys 4y agoThings like this bring out the most socially conservative commentators. I know some subreddits do these kinds of posts to tag all the conservative commentators that are lurking and won’t flair themselves.
- ttyprintk 4y agoThere are two things commenters are signalling here, preserved with instant recall if in the future you need to confirm their leaning: 1. Their aspect on what’s wrong with unlimited access to sanctioned imagery. 2. Their aspect on how to comply or at least avoid a lawsuit. Once someone has answered #1, you can ballpark whether they find some sanctioned images more hazardous than others. Which means you can ask around #2: consider a small polity passing an ID law for access to social media. How will the mechanisms in the law work?
- theironhammer 4y ago[dead]
- cykros 4y agoThank God they're protecting kids from the content on Pornhub. Those kids will now be safe, only accessing content on much less harmful sites such as luxuretv, heavy-r, and other websites based outside of the US, where people don't have such filthy minds. More seriously, does this apply to people wanting to use the Bing search engine too? Also, if Pornhub were to simply not accept subscribers or ad content from Louisiana, does the state even have standing to enact this legislation? Seems like its jurisdiction ends when it's no longer a matter of intrastate commerce. Perhaps they could require that in state ISP's firewall the site, but it seems like acting on a company that isn't operating within their state is an overreach.
- ttyprintk 4y agoThere are exceptions for service providers.