4 ms·
Complete globalization was always a very bad idea. Journalists like John Pilger have been trying to warn us for decades but were ignored by society because ther
by wkat4242 4y ago
Complete globalization was always a very bad idea. Journalists like John Pilger have been trying to warn us for decades but were ignored by society because there was so much profit to be gained.
Admittedly the China we moved all our production to in the early 2000s wasn't that bad a business partner. However we've always known that countries can change very quickly and since Xi JinPing it's become a major geopolitical threat. Only now we're too invested and it will cost us a lot to pull out again. Still, it has to be done.
I hope we never make that mistake again and diversify in countries we can actually trust.
Personally I think leaving everything to "the market" is also a very bad idea since all the market cares about is money. Not the environment, not people, not society. Trying to get the market to take these into account makes for very awkward workarounds like carbon taxes/credits. There needs to be a balance between free markets and protecting our own interests, and those of the world as a whole.
- x3n0ph3n3 4y ago> Personally I think leaving everything to "the market" is also a very bad idea since all the market cares about is money. Not the environment, not people, not society. Trying to get the market to take these into account makes for very awkward workarounds like carbon taxes/credits. There needs to be a balance between free markets and protecting our own interests, and those of the world as a whole. This isn't a problem with "the market", but how finance and stock markets are heavily biased with short-term thinking. Money _in the short term_, is the predominant issue.
- RestlessMind 4y ago> Money _in the short term_, is the predominant issue. That's not just about money. Humans in general are bad at thinking long term and want immediate gratification. cf Marshmallow experiment, or how we are (not) tackling climate change.
- rhaway84773 4y agoThe problem is that risk increases rapidly with time. Any system whose goal is to optimize the usage of money, which is what finance basically is, will almost always value short term thinking over long term thinking because of the much greater risk involved. The way to counteract this is simple. Regulation and/or adding a monetary cost to the behavior you want to discourage.
- janalsncm 4y agoNegative externalities haven’t been properly priced in because the cost of dumping carbon into the atmosphere is zero. Change the cost structure and even the short-term calculations change immediately.
- cutemonster 4y agoOr dumping plastics in the ocean
- hulitu 4y ago> Complete globalization was always a very bad idea. Globalization was a good idea when US and its allies could produce cheap in other countries and sell expensive in their own country. Free market for the "free".
- cutemonster 4y agoIt was not a good idea but it seemed like a good idea (to many)
- windexh8er 4y agoBut that's not the reality of both sides to that coin. The countries that produced cheaply were given that opportunity. The US (and others) have always had the ability to make those cheap products, but countries (both competitive and unfriendly) still wanted to participate in globalization to get a piece of the pie. It's coming to an end, yes. But there's more nuance to the why than what's outlined in the article. I've been more and more impressed with Peter Zeihan's book "The End of the World is Just the Beginning" which is predicted on explaining the building blocks of globalization over the last 50 years and how and why it's coming to (and has been for some time) an end. It's very obvious why the US wants and needs chips being made state side at this point. It's a matter of national security and a long term protection of the country. I'd highly recommend the book, however [0]. [0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/58782897-the-end-of-the-world-is-just-the-beginning https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/58782897-the-end-of-the-...
- meany 4y agoAt the time, the belief among most policy people was that China’s economic growth would lead to democracy. Obviously, that didn’t happen, but I don’t think it’s accurate to suggest they traded against the worlds interest for profit. In the early 90s after the fall of the communist bloc, it seemed to many that global liberal democracy was inevitable.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoPerhaps if current oligopolies like the United States were to turn into democracies. That would have led the way.
- mikrotikker 4y agoWe can dream but I fear its getting worse. IMO organizations like the WEF are spreading neo feudalism via globalism, empowering the corporations at the expense of the everyday individual and the environment.
- wkat4242 4y agoI did also think that, but I don't think many people had expected China to become more authoritarian as it has. Though democracy isn't a guarantee that politics can't be hijacked by oligarch interests. Hungary and (until 5 days ago) Brazil are some typical examples.
- adventured 4y ago> At the time, the belief among most policy people was that China’s economic growth would lead to democracy. Obviously, that didn’t happen A late point to this discussion. Democracy is the wrong bar. Increased liberalism is the measurement, and the vast economic expansion was made possible by the same exact (slowly expanding) liberalism that was going on in China in the post Mao era. China was legitimately on a liberalization path, quite clearly, prior to Xi. People very commonly get all of this confused. The thing - the cultural decisions - that made the economic opening possible, is the liberalization (letting people be more free in numerous ways, simply put). It wasn't the economic expansion that might lead to democracy, it was the same thing that was causing the economic expansion, that made that vast expansion possible. That expansion would not have been nearly so powerful if Xi had had the same control, he would have (by necessity of his survival) smothered much of it just as he's doing now. And now Xi can't turn back, they (the remaining old power in the system) will kill him at this point. Xi would be executed for "corruption." So he'll have to keep going forward in terms of more rigid authoritarianism to protect himself, and it's obvious what that's going to cause.
- maybeagainz 4y ago[dead]